3 ms·
> We might similarly observe, “Nobody moves to that state anymore. It offers too much economic opportunity.” This article rests on the premise that all you nee
by crazygringo 13y ago
> We might similarly observe, “Nobody moves to that state anymore. It offers too much economic opportunity.”
This article rests on the premise that all you need for a higher salary is to live somewhere where salaries are higher. But that is highly questionable -- just because they're higher in general, doesn't mean they'll be higher for you. At no point does the author convincingly explain that American unemployment is a problem of geographical mismatch, instead of the far more likely case of skills mismatch.
> If labor markets were operating efficiently, construction workers, along with electricians, plumbers... would receive enough compensation to live near the places where their work is most needed. But our labor markets are not efficient; rather, they are rigged and skewed, offering too much compensation to people with some skill sets (merging companies and writing derivatives, for example) and not enough to others whose skills are often just as hard to learn (e.g., brick laying and teaching children to read) and often more vital to society.
What? How exactly does the author magically come to the conclusion? As far as I can tell, construction work and plumbing and electrical wiring is all getting done. (Never listen to businessmen complaining about a lack of workers, it's just a masked complaint that they're having to pay higher wages.) What evidence is there that our labor markets are "rigged and skewed"? By whom? It's like the author doesn't understand the basic concepts of supply and demand in a labor market.
It's extremely interesting that Americans are moving less. I'd love to know more of why. But tying it into arguments about career mobility seems highly dubious, at best. It's ridiculous, and almost patronizing, to suppose that people's careers nationwide are being held back by not being able to live in downtown metro areas. It's a big country out there.
- mattsfrey 13y agoYeah I think housing markets are much more the problem. I just moved from a dead end place in upstate NY to Denver, CO, seeking the better job market for software developers. I'd have loved to have gone right to the main nerve in SV but the housing prices are just so insane it was beyond my budget.
- jellicle 13y ago> At no point does the author convincingly explain that American unemployment is a problem of geographical mismatch, instead of the far more likely case of skills mismatch. If it were a case of either of those, it would be visible in the data. Which it isn't. American unemployment - and European unemployment, for that matter - is a result of the class warfare practiced by the rich against the poor in recent years. Paul Krugman suggests Republican policies are responsible for 2% extra unemployment, nationwide: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/10/15/the-gop-tax/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/10/15/the-gop-tax/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/10/17/what-a-drag-2/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/10/17/what-a-drag-2/ High unemployment is a result of policies that have artificially suppressed demand for goods and services by taking money out of the hands of people who will actually spend it, resulting in an overall excess supply of labor and low demand for labor and therefore, low wages.