4 ms·
Per Duverger's Law (1), winner takes all voting systems begat a two party system. Because belligerents seek the smallest winning coalition. The saving grace of
by specialist 13y ago
Per Duverger's Law (1), winner takes all voting systems begat a two party system. Because belligerents seek the smallest winning coalition.
The saving grace of the USA's winner takes all elections is that we vote on absolutely everything, local, county, state, and federal. We have a great deal more involvement in local government.
What's the solution?
I'm glad you asked.
Most of the infighting is in the margins. So eliminate the margins.
First step is fair redistricting, maximizing competitiveness, so there are no "safe" seats.
Second step is universal voter registration. No more caging, provisional ballots, and other quirks.
Third step is campaign finance reform. I favor public financing of campaigns as a cure all. But there's so many other things which would help. Restore fairness doctrine, limit campaigning and fund raising to a small window before elections, any and all contributions are public records (no more shadow money), etc.
(1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law
- ctdonath 13y agoFair redistricting? Who gets to define "fair"? Unless we just lay down a grid and subdivide quadrants by population, there will always be stark differences over what constitutes "fair redistricting". Campaign finance reform, as commonly understood as you describe, is anathema to the fundamental right of free speech. Any attempts to regulate, limit, and document facilitation of free speech will be subverted. Better to go the other way, ensuring nothing and nobody actively hinders anyone's political speech: small players aren't stymied by high costs of compliance, loophole tunneling, or short-run big-cost campaigns. And again, what constitutes "fairness" in the badly-termed "fairness doctrine"? a lofty-sounding regulation, it empowers someone biased to decide how much of which view is promoted by what outlet - to wit, telling speakers what they can say when. "Freedom of the press" is a fundamental principle: you may buy a printing press (however broadly defined) and you may use it to facilitate whatever speech you choose at whatever cost you can raise money to fund it with; don't subvert that, or we'll have to repeat what enumerated that right in the first place.
- specialist 13y agoWho gets to define "fair"? Maximal competitiveness. down a grid and subdivide quadrants by population aka red lining Campaign finance reform, as commonly understood as you describe, is anathema to the fundamental right of free speech. Money != speech. Any attempts to regulate, limit, and document facilitation of free speech will be subverted. Laundering campaign money thru Super PACs et al is a form of speech? I thought you libertarians were all for open government, transparency, accountability. Regardless, freedom of speech != right to privacy. When you petition the government, you have to use your real name.
- ctdonath 13y agoWho's competing? Who decides what's competitive? How can you assure no bias by those on whom there is tremendous pressure for bias? Speaking to more than a dozen people at a time costs money. If you're going to try to persuade 50,000,000 people to vote for you (about how many voters needed to win a US presidential vote), that's going to cost a LOT of money. If your message is a tough sell, it will take even more money to sell it. Your example proves my point. Precisely because regulations exist to limit political speech, those seeking to fund more speech than allowed have to launder campaign money thru Super PACs et al; those who hit the regulatory limits on political speech but don't have the huge sums available for such "laundering" are stuck. The more you try to tighten limits on political speech, the greater the cost to bypass those limits - and the greater the rewards to those who do, seeing their competition impeded by regulation. And those limits WILL be bypassed, as there will ALWAYS be some way, given enough money, to bypass them. Libertarians are primarily for less governance, removing barricades erected where there is no need for them in the first place. There is no need for regulatory accountability in political speech if the regulations exist for oppressive purposes: restore liberty by removing the regulations, and there is nothing to account for. No need to make barriers open, transparent, and accountable if you remove the barriers entirely. Sure, you have to use your real name when petitioning the government. When citizens speak to other citizens, it's not the government's business.
- specialist 13y agoWho's competing? Who decides what's competitive? Really? Okay. It's a three way cage match between the Easter Bunny, Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy. No holds barred. We all decide by TXTing to vote while watching the pay per view live telecast.