3 ms·
How can a neutrino annihilate with another one? Where would the energy go? It can't make a photon, and there is no lighter particle for it. Or can this only ha
by ars 13y ago
How can a neutrino annihilate with another one? Where would the energy go? It can't make a photon, and there is no lighter particle for it.
Or can this only happen with the assistance of another particle?
- oofabz 13y agoI am no physicist, but could they decay into a virtual Z boson, which imparts momentum onto a nearby real particle?
- SaberTail 13y agoIn theory, a neutrino colliding with an antineutrino is similar to an electron colliding with a positron. If the neutrino/antineutrino pair has enough energy, you could produce new particles. Otherwise, they'll just scatter off of each other. Now, because electrons/positrons interact electromagnetically in addition to through the weak force, while neutrinos interact only weakly, how they scatter and the chances to produce new particles will be different. But the processes are conceptually similar.
- yk 13y agoIf the neutrinos have enough energy, then they can just produce a lepton-anti-lepton pair. But for low energies the simplest process is creation of a virtual W pair, that annihilates to two photons. Trying to explain a bit, because of the uncertainty principle you can borrow energy from the vacuum, as long as the resulting particles are destroyed quickly enough. So for intermediate stage in a process you do not need to exactly satisfy energy conservation, but instead the resulting cross section is suppressed and the reaction becomes more unlikely. But the neutrino less double beta decay works somewhat differently. In a normal beta decay, a nucleus transmutes to a daughter nucleus, a electron and a anti-neutrino. ( X, X' are the nuclei, nubar the anti neutrino, e- the electron.) X -> X' + nubar + e- In a neutrino less double beta decay, this is what the article is talking about, the anti-neutrino then reacts with the daughter nucleus to produce yet another nucleus and an additional electron. Here the energy to create the two electrons comes from the mass difference between the initial nucleus and the final nucleus. X' + nubar + e- -> X'' + 2 e- But it is only possible if the anti-neutrino is actually a normal neutrino, since otherwise the second reaction would need to create a positron, which would mean that the initial and final nucleus are identical, which means that there is no mass difference to create the electron positron pair. So detection of a neutrino less double beta decay is immediate proof that the neutrino is its own anti particle.
- ars 13y agoThank you! But I find it odd that the neutrino which doesn't participate in electromagnetic force can make a charged particle (the lepton or the W).
- yk 13y agoWell, there is charge conservation as well as lepton number conservation. So at the vertex a (electron) neutrino can couple to a W+ and a e-, since the lepton number of the neutrino is 1 and the reaction products do not have a total charge. ( But energy-impulse conservation dictates that at least one of the two needs to be virtual.) Actually there is something called effective field theories, which is essentially a technique to derive simple rules to calculate specific processes. ( For example, one can derive a effective theory containing only up and down quarks from the standard model. Such a theory would be sufficient for nuclear physics, since only up and down quarks are present in protons and neutrons.) In such a theory, which only describes the interaction between neutrinos and photons, the neutrino would acquire a small but non zero charge. ( Or equivalently the photon would be charged under the weak force.)