4 ms·
I'll cop to being a bit ideological here (mostly in the form of not fully justifying the statements here), but I don't think automation is displacing labor... y
by jerf 13y ago
I'll cop to being a bit ideological here (mostly in the form of not fully justifying the statements here), but I don't think automation is displacing labor... yet. I think this time that the explanation that we grossly increased regulation, taxation and even more so the fear of future taxation, government spending and benefits, and just in general have significantly raised the both the direct cost of hiring someone, and the reasonable expectations of future cost of hiring someone is a sufficient explanation. I find the idea that raising hiring costs can be done without resulting in lowered hiring to be, shall we say, something that can only be rationalized by a brain in "politics" mode, rather than "rational" mode.
(The test to this theory is that if we elect a regime that tones all of this back, and the economy comes roaring back 1980s-style, then this theory was essentially correct. If we do that, and it does not come roaring back, then my theory here is incorrect. I believe in treating politics scientifically, at least, my personal politics. My highest allegiance is ultimately to what works.)
However, lest this sound like a raw ideological rant, I do think it is near inevitable that either by the 2020s or the 2030s at the latest, that this automation displacement will be a real problem. We're looking at a world where trucking is gone as a viable job. Where fast-food will probably be rapidly in the throes of total roboticization. Where what farming jobs are still available will be rapidly falling to yet more sophisticated robots that have human-like dexterity and ability to detect ripeness. Taxis, gone, in favor of heavily capital-based self-driving car rent pools. I think this whole automation argument is premature today, but it's going to be a real problem in a relatively small number of election cycles. How is anyone who is not suitable for college and has no useful artistic talent combined with enough work ethic to use it profitably going to make it? I don't know.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>(The test to this theory is that if we elect a regime that tones all of this back, and the economy comes roaring back 1980s-style, then this theory was essentially correct. If we do that, and it does not come roaring back, then my theory here is incorrect. I believe in treating politics scientifically, at least, my personal politics. My highest allegiance is ultimately to what works.) Except that the economy only "roared back" in the 1980s for a narrow subset of the population. If we're on a labor-replacement curve where rehiring and growth are going to just keep getting less and less egalitarian, then an increasingly large majority of the population has the exact same problem as if jobs were just disappearing outright. The "selectivity" only gives you personally a fear more years to bury your head in the sand before you're the one standing in the dole queue. (Of course, on Hacker News we're even more goddamn privileged, since so many of us are programmers doing AI-complete jobs.)
- jerf 13y agoWe'd kill today for any of the 1980s employment numbers during its height. A generally middle-class lifestyle was still possible on relatively low skill jobs, the idea that unions would price themselves out of work was still laughably absurd, etc etc. I really don't think this attempt to project 2010 political rhetoric that far back in time is practical. It may not have been entirely egalitarian, but that's a chimera anyhow, so I would consider that a very weak criticism. Failing to achieve impossible goals is not a useful criticism.