8 ms·
This is probably going to get downvoted, but if lots of people are not overzealous puritans and want some skin, the best overall system design that maximizes ha
by VLM 13y ago
This is probably going to get downvoted, but if lots of people are not overzealous puritans and want some skin, the best overall system design that maximizes happiness and profit is probably sharding into
puritanweirdos.example.com with no skin showing between toes and top of turtleneck (edited to add no pokies either)
and
normalpeople.example.com with 99% of the human race
The best solution to a problem involving computers is sometimes computer related, but sometimes is social. The puritans are never going to get along with the normal people anyway, so its not like sharding them is going to hurt.
Another way to hack the system is not to hire or accept holier than thou puritans. Personality doesn't mesh with the team, doesn't fit culture, etc. You have to draw the line somewhere, and weirdos on either end should get cut, so no CP or animals at one extreme, and no holy rollers on the other extreme.
The final social hack is its kind of like dealing with bullies via appeasement. So they're blocking reasonable stuff today, tomorrow they want to block all women not wearing burkhas or depictions of women damaging their ovaries by driving. Appeasing bullies never really works in the long run, so why bother starting. "If you claim not to like it, or at least enjoy telling everyone else repeatedly how you claim not to like it, stop looking at it so much, case closed"
- Shivetya 13y agoHarassment laws/lawyers would find you their wet dream. The rule with pictures in any work environment is to err on the side of extreme caution. More than likely your not going to find out they don't mesh with the team till they quit or are fired. If your lucky its not followed by a lawsuit. See, its not their job to not be offended, it is your job to offer a harassment free work environment. Whom you are catering too depends on what is PC or not at the time, fortunately its pretty easy to determine whose whims to cater to or not
- jiggy2011 13y agoI'm not sure it is that easy, even HN discussions on the topic don't come to any particular conclusion and that is within a fairly narrow range of people. In an old job I had the task of cleaning spam off a forum, this meant looking at rather a lot of porn but it would never have occurred to me to sue on that basis, yet that is still a job that needs to be done.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoNope. Harrassment is a legal term of art, not a synonym for disagreeable treatment. Harrassment occurs when a person or group is singled out for distinct treatment, in the U.S. at least. Subjecting everybody to all types of porn is quite lawful. (There is a famous case of a bisexual pervert who indiscriminantly propositioned anything with a pulse. His self-designated victims were bitch slapped out of court.)
- aestra 13y agoWhat? No. Sexual harassment is unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical harassment of a sexual nature, no matter how many people are sexually harassed or the gender of the parties involved. There have been class action sexual harassment lawsuits. Jenson v. Eveleth Taconite Co. was the first which represented fifteen women. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jenson_v._Eveleth_Taconite_Co http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jenson_v._Eveleth_Taconite_Co. It's a fuzzy ground with say prominent displays of pornographic material in say an office environment. One might argue that it can make the workplace a hostile or overtly sexually charged environment. It is best to err on the side of caution.
- VLM 13y agoGood lord I've read that case and its about as far from the pr0n filter example as you can possibly get. That place was beyond nuts and so was the trial. They deserved every penny they got because the workplace was out of control crazy, and merely coincidentally happened to involve male/female issues. That is NOT a case about accidentally clicking on a web page or debating if huffpo headline stories are sometimes a little too racy, that was a case about a madhouse of stalking and intimidation and tire slashing and... I don't think a mere web pr0n image filter would have saved the mine 3.5 million dollars. Actually having capable supervisors and managers, yeah, that might have worked?
- aestra 13y agoI should have been more specific. The defense "I sexually harass everyone, so it isn't sexual harassment" is just not in any way valid. Full stop. Period. I used the first class action sexual harassment lawsuit as an example to illustrate the point of "just because it's company culture/I do it to everyone/he's just like that" doesn't make it not harassment. The GP was giving false information that if you sexually harass everyone, than it magically becomes not sexual harassment and then it somehow gets thrown out in court, but does not cite the relevant court case. Just because you ass grab everyone that walks by doesn't make ass grabbing not sexual harassment by the law. That's mostly my point. As far as a p0rn filter, that's a different story. You can look at it a different way, legally. I'm just playing devil's advocate here as to why it would be a good idea for someone to try to err on the side of caution in the workplace filter rules. They may want to avoid the situation where person A is sitting in their cube while person B is watching hardcore gay porn next door specifically to harass person A. Person A might feel that the employee didn't do a good enough job to prevent this type of harassment by blocking access to that content. If the employer doesn't try to filter out porn or at least create a policy against it, it might look like it is condoning or supporting it whereas their peers filter. (I just made that up, if say 85% of their peers make an attempt to filter) especially if it is well known that managers tolerate risque images/video if not outright porn, or if company culture tolerates it. A less grey example is if you put a picture of two women who are mostly clothed but kissing and put it in the office breakroom. Everyone sees it, but it creates a sexually charged environment that can be hostile to some. That's a big no-no in HR land.
- arjunnarayan 13y agoI mean, if you read between the lines from his class notes, this is basically what Peter Thiel says: Just don't hire these people. Nobody will say it publicly, because that opens them up to discrimination lawsuits, but that's the reality on the ground.
- walshemj 13y agoBut I haven't seen many actual case law writeups published by proper legal authorities that proves a lot of this over zealous activity by HR actually saves the company anything. I would bet a case of Moet that most of the Hyperbolic HR warnings over this stuff actuality have no reasonable chance of ever causing a loss.
- walshemj 13y agoOh dear looks like I pissed off the Puritan nutters or we have shudder induhviduals from human remains reading HN. I will say it again in my experience I have yet to see a credible case written up in reputable legal publications that detail any cases where a pron filter or the lack off one made any difference to a case. Any one care to post a link to prove me wrong rather than than moding me down?
- bad_user 13y agoPorn detection still has its uses and you're making the mistake of saying that only puritans are interested in porn detection. For example if you've got children, given your stance on the matter, you may not necessarily agree that a filter is necessary, but how about being alerted when your children are viewing obscene content? How about being alerted when your children are engaging in sexting? When it comes to children, maintaining their purity is only one side of the coin, a necessity with which not all people necessarily agree. But the other side of the coin that's a pretty objective fact is that children do get the wrong ideas about what they see and sometimes it happens with adults too, with porn being the main reason why men think they need big penises to satisfy women. And there's a lot of weird porn out there. With improper exposure, a child can end up growing with certain ideas about doing sex, with certain complexes and so on. And I'm not necessarily for censoring that content, as children can find ways around the censorship should they want to, plus these filters aren't perfect anyway. But I would find useful a system that alerts me when my child gets exposed to porn, such that I can take appropriate measures, like having fatherly talks about sex, explaining to him that what he just saw is a really bad idea in case he looked at something weird. Plus, exposure to porn can happen 100% by accident and that's my personal problem with it. I take my monthly dosage for appealing to my stockings fetish, but you know, I like to be in control of when that happens. Like going to a website and clicking on something can trigger a popup involving ads to either poker games or porn. Sometimes they've got sound too. Imagine hearing in the workplace the sound of a woman's moan. It's totally disrespectful to your colleagues, as it disrupts their workflow. I was searching for something on ThePirateBay once and it happened to me.
- icebraining 13y agochildren do get the wrong ideas about what they see and sometimes it happens with adults too, with porn being the main reason why men think they need big penises to satisfy women Is it porn that gives them the wrong idea, or is it because porn is the only concept of sex that they get exposed to? But I would find useful a system that alerts me when my child gets exposed to porn, such that I can take appropriate measures, like having fatherly talks about sex, explaining to him that what he just saw is a really bad idea in case he looked at something weird. Why wouldn't you have fatherly talks about sex regardless of exposure to porn? Imagine hearing in the workplace the sound of a woman's moan. It's totally disrespectful to your colleagues, as it disrupts their workflow. Playing any sound is disrespectful to your colleagues, by breaking their concentration. The pornographic part is irrelevant.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoYour last and second last points seem to contradict each other. You claim that people who are into animal sex are "weirdos" and we should draw the line there, then you claim that people who want to block something are bullies who should not be appeased. Also your claim that all people who wants to block pornographic images are really bullies who will not stop until all women are in burkhas is stupid in itself.