2 ms·
While not arguing that your counter-example is possible – I strongly reject the implication that businesses therefore are required to build that extra infrastru
by bigiain 13y ago
While not arguing that your counter-example is possible – I strongly reject the implication that businesses therefore are required to build that extra infrastructure, on the off-chance that some legal request might at some point in the future ask for sensitive customer data.
If a business chooses not to develop that, because they've decided that disallowing insider access is a better choice for their business, that's an entirely sensible and legal choice to make. If a court later decides they're not happy with that - the court must be the one who bears the cost of implementing a properly auditable and secured system, not the business who has no need for it. (And I note that Levison offered to build such a system for only $3500, which seems to be to be a _very_ reasonable price, and instead the government chose to play hardball. And to Levisons great credit, lost.)
Note too, that there are many instances where not having customer data available is exactly the right way to build things. Any court in the land can come and ask me to tell them which credit card got used at any of my client's ecommerce sites – I'll say "Sorry, never even saw the CC number. Absolutely no way I can disclose that to you. If you want me to implement a system that allows me to gather that data for you, speak to my bank and Visa/Mastercard/AMEX et al, and provide me with written court-backed absolvement from my PCI obligations, and I'll have my people prepare you a quote for costs on modifying the software.
- DannyBee 13y ago"the court must be the one who bears the cost of implementing a properly auditable and secured system, not the business who has no need for it. " The court is essentially an arbiter. It is on no one's side, and actually has no real skin in the game. This means it is not going to pay for this, it is going to decide which party pays for it :) If the parties fail to pay, or fail to comply, they will be possibly sent to jail Note that Levison has not really won yet, since he still has a contempt hearing coming up ...