4 ms·
Absent massive government intervention it wouldn't even be close. With the fixed rate, 30 year mortgage with no prepayment penalty, low down payment and massive
by bradleyjg 13y ago
Absent massive government intervention it wouldn't even be close. With the fixed rate, 30 year mortgage with no prepayment penalty, low down payment and massively subsidized rates; mortgage income deduction & the income exemption for imputed rent; and other government programs it becomes something of a closer call. Even so, it's still a highly leveraged asset that is as non-diversified as an investment can be, with very high transaction costs, significant carrying costs, and only moderately liquid markets at best.
The government policies to subsidize homeownership are unfortunate in that they are very regressive and they are quite expensive for the meager positive externalizes that possibly flow from widespread ownership.
- avn2109 13y agoCan anyone shed some light on why all this government intervention exists? In other words, why so much propaganda/pressure from the man to buy houses?
- don_draper 13y agoSome people think, rightly or wrongly, that home ownership: * Results in citizens that care more about the neighborhood * Nudges people into saving for retirement * Allows the average Joe to take advantage of inflation (this is true IMO). House goes up in value, so does their net worth.
- dandelany 13y agoTo expand on the retirement bit - a purchased home is a huge portion of most people's retirement savings, from a net worth perspective. Not having to pay rent makes it much easier for many people to get by on just savings/pension/a social security check every month. Assuming, that is, they've been able to pay off their mortgage by then.
- bradleyjg 13y agoOn the second and third points, all other things being equal, (which they aren't because of government intervention) people would be far better off with a diversified portfolio of debt and equity than a house.
- walshemj 13y agoAnd when Interest rates return to normal and they lose 30% or more in a bond crash on their "safe" government bonds what then? A diversified portfolio should also include property which is why I have investments in REITS as well as shares.
- bradleyjg 13y agoThere are many REITs traded on stock markets and included in broad total market funds including residential, commercial, retail, and industrial. E.g. AVB, VNO, EQR, SPG and many others.
- walshemj 13y agoAnd it is also a good for upward social mobility owning a home means your children can inherit it
- dingaling 13y agoHome ownership is seen as a remarkable mechanism of social pacification; the political theory is that people owning homes are less prone to take actions ( protest, crime or giving up work ) that threaten their means of retaining their home.