6 ms·
Downvoted for the unnecessary negativity x2. Fine, you think it's a stupid idea - just move on and close the tab then. Your opinion is just that: one person's o
by ScottWhigham 13y ago
Downvoted for the unnecessary negativity x2. Fine, you think it's a stupid idea - just move on and close the tab then. Your opinion is just that: one person's opinion. If you want to offer the guy feedback on his app, go for it. But there's just no need to comment on HN on every app/idea you don't like/hate/think-is-stupid with "I think it is a stupid idea." Surely you have better ways to spend your time (as do I).
- theboss 13y agoHa. Thanks. Isn't the point of this to save time or remember someone's name. Actually think about how your interaction with another person would go and how this app fits into that....It makes the interaction awkward and you probably won't even find their text message in time (your messages screen is a most recently used list...the message will be buried). Where is the plus side? I think the idea is stupid. If they like they are free to prove me wrong and show me it is a good idea. edit: I think sugar coating opinions so they have to be positive is pointless. Maybe me saying the app is stupid helps them realize some problem with their app that helps them improve it and make it much better (and then prove me wrong). If we were to Sugar coat all feedback then the feedback of horrible products will be indistinguishable from good products which makes it pointless.
- tomasien 13y agoI really don't mind the feedback. If you don't get the use-case, you don't get the use case. No offense taken.