2 ms·
I get 1.7 to 2 times as many neurons as elephants, a little more for whales, and they don't seem even half as intelligent. Homo floresiensis had a brain conside
by Houshalter 13y ago
I get 1.7 to 2 times as many neurons as elephants, a little more for whales, and they don't seem even half as intelligent. Homo floresiensis had a brain considered small for a chimpanzee and was capable of making tools and lighting fires and very likely language. Meanwhile neanderthals had even bigger brains than us. The number of neurons alone isn't responsible for intelligence.
Even if it was, that doesn't explain how intelligence works or what the hell the brain is actually doing.
- acqq 13y agoStill remember that when the question is formulated as "what makes us humans" it gets the theological note to it implying that we are special, "divinely better" or whatever. And that we're not. We're just one specific attempt of all evolutionary attempts that happened through the billions of years.
- Houshalter 13y agoWe're not special? We're not better? Are we really being politically correct for the sake of animals?
- acqq 13y agoNo, we are not "the chosen ones." We have the brains able to figure out more than other animals, but it was not predestined. And we are not the only ones "at the top of the evolution" either. Every animal you see is "at the top of the evolution" for its branch. I know it's hard to believe for those who grew up in protestant environment with the false belief that "God gave us the Earth to use it as we will."
- Houshalter 13y agoHumans certainly are "at the top of evolution". Though it depends greatly how you define "top of evolution". I mean in terms that we might go on to populate entire galaxies and survive long, long after the Earth has burned to a crisp and every other species is long dead. Or maybe you could define it in terms that we are capable of far, far more than any other animal. If you define it as "merely manages to survive and reproduce in the present" then yes, everything alive is at "the top of evolution", since that is actually part of the definition of "alive". Anyways I'm not sure it matters. How I came to exist doesn't change any of my goals. I'm still the same person whether I was put here by God or by random chance or by an evolutionary process.
- acqq 13y ago> we might go on to populate entire galaxies and survive long At the moment, we "might" only in Sci-Fi movies. The reality is completely different. Better look at how we really handle global warming or control nuclear weapons. Civilization we know is much more fragile that those who believe to be "chosen by deity" are able to recognize.
- Houshalter 13y agoNo country is stupid enough to use nuclear weapons, and it wouldn't make humans extinct in any case. And global warming couldn't even get as far as destroying civilization. We only have to make it 30 or 40 more years anyways.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWait, what? Last I heard, another 50 years of global warming and we're the source of a full-blown mass extinction, one that will probably include us. So you're saying all we have to do is survive long enough... to die out?
- Houshalter 13y agoFull-blown mass extinction? How? As I understand it it's mainly coastal regions slowly flooding and weather changing. That's not collapsing civilization. I'm saying we have 30-40 years until super-human AI. Though short of that there are still many other advances in technology we could make in that time that would change things completely.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago> Full-blown mass extinction? How? As I understand it it's mainly coastal regions slowly flooding and weather changing. That's not collapsing civilization. Mass extinction of large sums of the life on this planet. We might technically survive, but the ecosystem that supports us is dying, and quickly, and we're the ones killing it. >I'm saying we have 30-40 years until super-human AI. Ah, ok. Well, if that prediction turns out correct, then you should liquidate your bank accounts, because then it's 30-40 years until we all die screaming. (Translation: futurist pls go.)
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWe're not special. We were just the first to conquer all the other species.
- Houshalter 13y agoI would call that special.
- macspoofing 13y ago>Are we really being politically correct for the sake of animals? Are you for real? We are animals, through and through.
- macspoofing 13y agoI know what you're saying, but that isn't the question. The question is "what makes us human" or some similar ridiculousness. // Having said that, come on. There is a correlation between brain size (i.e. number of neurons) and intelligence. It may not be 1:1 or linear (though how do you know the Neanderthals were not more more intelligent, or we aren't twice as intelligent as elephants?) but there is most certainly a strong strong correlation.