6 ms·
Divisibility helps to be sure, but there are other issues. Expectation of deflation discourages spending and investment, because the currency I would spend wil
by dllthomas 13y ago
Divisibility helps to be sure, but there are other issues. Expectation of deflation discourages spending and investment, because the currency I would spend will itself be worth more tomorrow.
- ekianjo 13y agoNo, the currency would not appreciate much more if you keep it down the road, since bitcoin's value curve becomes almost flat when you reach that point, so there's no real value in hoarding your bitcoins when you reach that stage.
- gnaritas 13y ago> since bitcoin's value curve becomes almost flat when you reach that point What? The value of a currency is not only determined by how much of it there is, but by how much the economy needs to function. If the economy grows bitcoins will have to depreciate to allow smaller and smaller pieces to be traded. That's deflation, and it's bad. Divisibility isn't a feature, it's a bug that'll kill the currency in the long run because prices are sticky (people raise prices faster than they drop them) and the economy handles inflation far better than it handles deflation.
- ekianjo 13y agoHahah. Funny argument. Inflation is killing your economy, rather, because it encourages spending and frenetic consumption, this depleting the banks of the well needed savings that will be used for investment by private companies. Yeah, inflation works "so well", right.
- dllthomas 13y agoInflation encourages investment. If I can get a return sticking my money under a (literal or metaphorical) matress why would I take a risk with investing it? Funding your startup would be more expensive and more difficult in a deflationary world.
- ekianjo 13y agoI don't see how it can encourage investment if inflation punishes savers. Savers are at the source of investment. If nobody saves where do you borrow money for your startup? Oh, let me guess, by borrowing from other creditor countries, where people actually save, like in China and Japan ? Yeah, you are right, that worked pretty well for the US industry in the past 30 years to have a galoping inflation. Look where your industries went.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 13y ago"I don't see how it can encourage investment if inflation punishes savers. Savers are at the source of investment. If nobody saves where do you borrow money for your startup?" You're conflating all saving. Stashing money under my mattress (or in a vault) is not a source of investment. Saving is investment only if investing is how you save - investing is currently how you save partly because cash holdings lose value. "Yeah, you are right, that worked pretty well for the US industry in the past 30 years to have a galoping inflation. Look where your industries went." 1) Inflation has not been "galloping" over most of the past 30 years. 2) I certainly don't assert that high levels of inflation are a good thing - low, controlled, stable, present seems to give the best results. 3) Nonetheless, yes, look where our industries went: mostly to countries with weaker currencies and more inflation.
- ekianjo 13y agoI'm not sure where you get the illusion that we do not have a galloping inflation. See the gold price vs USD : http://goldprice.org/charts/history/gold_all_data_o_usd.png http://goldprice.org/charts/history/gold_all_data_o_usd.png And no, there has not been a "run for Gold" or things like that, Gold is not used as a currency anywhere a demand is still relatively low and stable. So that gives you a sense of how much inflation you have been getting over the years. It's certainly faster than the official numbers. And anyone who has lived through the past 30 years should know very well that you could buy more commodities with a single dollar in the 80s than you can buy nowadays with the same amount. Regarding savings -> you know most people do not get paid directly in cash, right? Most if not not all employers require de facto a bank account in order to pay salaries (we are not in the 60s anymore) and most of the savings go and stay there when you work. These savings become funds that the bank can use to emit loans and different financial services to private companies.
- gnaritas 13y ago> Funny argument. That's not an argument, it's simply how the economy works. > Inflation is killing your economy No it isn't. > rather, because it encourages spending and frenetic consumption Our economy is based on consumption, like it or not. > this depleting the banks of the well needed savings that will be used for investment by private companies. You don't really know how banks work do you. > Yeah, inflation works "so well", right. Actually yes, it does. You should educate yourself a bit on how the economy actually works, you sound like someone with little more than a high school understanding full of misconceptions and bad ideas.
- dllthomas 13y agoSo, the economy is growing, with the same number of bitcoins chasing more goods (or actually, fewer and fewer bitcoins chasing more goods, as some get lost or destroyed) and (as you pointed out) people deal with this in part by splitting the bitcoins smaller in terms of what they actually spend. That obviously leads to the currency becoming more valuable as you can exchange the same amount of currency for more other stuff, right? It's worse than that, because expectation of deflation means people hoard rather than spending, which means still fewer coins actually in circulation.
- grinnbearit 13y agoThe entire economy can run just fine with 1 infinitely divisible bitcoin in circulation. Any bitcoins held can only have an effect if they are spent. The buyer who converted his labour into bitcoin has, in effect, provided free labour unless he converts the bitcoin back.
- dllthomas 13y ago> The entire economy can run just fine with 1 infinitely divisible bitcoin in circulation. That's a strong empirical statement made without evidence. > Any bitcoins held can only have an effect if they are spent. Kind of. But bitcoins (or fractions thereof) being removed from circulation has an effect. And the expectation that that will happen has an effect.
- grinnbearit 13y agoThe only way it can be removed from circulation is by providing the labour in the first place. That effect has already been accounted for. On another note why would this a problem?
- dllthomas 13y agoThe problem is (an expectation of) fewer bitcoins chasing more goods. Removing bitcoins while adding labor doesn't counteract that dynamic, it adds to it. (It's also not true that that's the only way bitcoins are removed from circulation - some have already been lost/destroyed - but given my previous point that's simply an aside). It's a problem because of what money is. It's not an asset to be held as store of value, it's a medium of exchange to make trade work better. If everyone is refusing to spend their bitcoins because they expect them to be more valuable tomorrow, bitcoin is not being a currency and people have to use other currencies to get things done or things aren't getting done, either of which is an issue for bitcoin-as-a-currency (and the latter an issue for everyone). Arguably bitcoin could continue to serve as an asset anyway, but I don't understand that to be the vision. None of this is to say that I am confident this will be sufficiently an issue that things stop working, but I definitely see it as a risk.