3 ms·
> being poor impacts IQ simply because it becomes the mind's obsession of finding means to survive. While that's poetic, I'm very skeptical that you could even
by humanrebar 13y ago
> being poor impacts IQ simply because it becomes the mind's obsession of finding means to survive.
While that's poetic, I'm very skeptical that you could even prove that empirically.
It's much more likely (because it is empirically demonstrable) that IQ is more strongly impacted by genetics (IQ of the parents), prenatal care (especially with respect to smoking and binge drinking), and childhood (mal)nutrition. I'm not sure how you would even test "obsession with survival" controlling for those things, all of which are much more common in poverty-stricken households.
I'm not saying that worrying about the next meal isn't terrible, but I am saying that we need to make sure we're not getting our causes and effects mixed up here. We can't just emulate "middle class" advantages for poor kids and expect the playing field to be level.
In other words, it's not as simple as saying being middle class is necessary to be successful, because to some degree, having minimally successful parents is necessary to be middle class in the first place. And why are parents successful? Probably things like good impulse control, general responsibility, mental health, and innate intelligence. Many of those things have certain genetic components.
So how do we make sure every kid has a fair shake at being rich? I'm not sure there's a good answer to that since it seems like so many of your cards are dealt in who your parents are. If you're really worried about it, I suggest you support substance-abuse recovery programs and food banks. Keeping kids healthy, well-fed, and free of birth defects are things we should be doing anyway.
- nitrogen 13y ago> > being poor impacts IQ simply because it becomes the mind's obsession of finding means to survive. > While that's poetic, I'm very skeptical that you could even prove that empirically. A study which claims to show exactly this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6298326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6298326 Anecdotally, I consider this plausible based on my own experiences during lean months as a startup founder.
- humanrebar 13y agoI read that article. While those studies are interesting, they are definitely limited and far from conclusive. For example, they didn't control for genetics as far as I can tell. It's entirely plausible that "rich" people are rich in the first place because, statistically speaking, innate intelligence lets them make better financial decisions even under duress. While it's possible and interesting, I certainly wouldn't make policy recommendations or support charities based on that kind of evidence. In the meantime, while independent parties come up with something more conclusive, let's try to affect known vectors for stunted childhood development like parental substance abuse, prenatal care, and malnourishment. And, again, these are real problems we should be doing something about anyway.
- quinnchr 13y agoAre you seriously asserting poverty is not a known vector for stunted childhood development? Do you realize there are millions of impoverished people in this country who can't afford to eat healthily? You are aware of the effect nutrition has on childhood development right? Do you realize there exist impoverished parts of this country which simply don't have access to fresh healthy food? There's literally hundreds of ways poverty stunts childhood development...
- chc 13y agoIf you actually read the thread, he's asserting the same thing you are asserting. What he's disputing is the idea that one of the chief reasons poverty is hard to get out of is that, once there, the mind is too fixated on survival for higher intellectual achievements.
- humanrebar 13y agoTechnically, I'm asserting that we don't have enough evidence to say one way or another and that we shouldn't let studies like these affect our decisions or worldviews yet.
- walid 13y agoI don't think you can control for genetics, at least not directly. There is no intelligence genetic marker as far as I know which only leaves testing the IQ/intelligence of the whole family tree as the only option. However getting access to ancestors might not be feasible. On the other hand having a large pool of people is good enough since the distribution of intelligence is usually uniform and not restricted to things like class or parental income.
- DuskStar 13y agoHere's one way to control for genetics - compare orphans who were adopted early (Pre 1yo) and then see what the correlation between their IQ and both the parents and adoptive parents IQ. (Or use income as a proxy for intelligence; it might be hard to get the dead parents to take an IQ test)
- nickbauman 13y agoThe strongest indicator of a child's ACT score is the INCOME of the parents. Increasingly IQ tests are being revealed as being culturally-based, too. And the things that you list; things like impulse control, general responsibility, mental health, are strongly influenced by the environment that the subject must contend with. Eugenics always seem so seductive, but, like phrenology, much is revealed about the outlook and tendencies of the practitioner rather than the subject.
- logjam 13y agoDon't make the really vapid errors in logic of trying to dismiss something by name-calling it "poetic", followed by the really vapid claim that IQ "strongly impacted by genetics", followed by failing to link to a single fucking legitimate study showing that "strong impact".