3 ms·
It's not - but the resource & labour cost of printing a $100 bill is many orders of magnitude different from the resources and labour you can buy with said $100
by vkou 13y ago
It's not - but the resource & labour cost of printing a $100 bill is many orders of magnitude different from the resources and labour you can buy with said $100 bill. (Never mind that a lot more money exists electronically, then physically.)
If that were the case with BTC, nobody would be mining it.
Is there value in maintaining safe money stores and transaction integrity? Yes. Is that value the same as the value of all outstanding currency in the world? For anything but BTC, the answer is 'Hell, no!'.
- hoka 13y agoI'm not a big BTC believer, but building that infrastructure for the paper money system took hundreds of years and is STILL evolving. That's to say nothing of how bureaucratic the entire thing was.
- praxeologist 13y agoHow are paper systems evolving? I can't think of anything besides new creative euphemisms for the thrift like quantitative easing. Central banking is a relatively new practice from the late 1700's. Ben Franklin encouraged the printing of new notes because printing was his business (this was before he had much political sway) and I consider this one of his bad contributions.
- mrb 13y ago"It's not - but the resource & labour cost of printing a $100 bill is many orders of magnitude different from the resources and labour you can buy with said $100 bill. (Never mind that a lot more money exists electronically, then physically.) If that were the case with BTC, nobody would be mining it." Err, your logic is flawed. It is the opposite. If it were the case with BTC, then many people would be mining, which is actually what is happening! In other words: you claim that the resource & labour cost in making and mining 1 Bitcoin with an ASIC mining are huge. This is wrong. The difference in orders of magnitude is so big that this is precisely why the mining activity is currently exploding: there are huge profits to be made due to this difference between cost and value.
- vkou 13y agoYou're half-right - I clearly needed more coffee when I was making that post. However, my claim that "the resource & labour cost in making and mining 1 Bitcoin with an ASIC mining is huge" is completely correct - because even it costs $8,000 of resources, to mine $10,000 of BTC, it would still be a profitable enterprise. (In the meantime, you just wasted $8,000 of resources, to make... Nothing that puts bread on the table, a roof over my head, etc.) When printing paper money, your profit margins are orders of magnitude greater - if it weren't for the part where 'mining' it is illegal. Since the government has the sole monopoly on printing money, it is (Most of the time) far more valuable than the paper it's printed on. BTC, on the other hand, is barely more valuable then the 'paper' it's printed on - or, the electricity that was used to produce it. If producing BTC were anywhere nearly as resource-efficient as producing paper money, the margins for mining it would go up and everybody would be mining it, instead of doing productive work (Producing goods and services) to earn it. The government's monopoly on printing currency is exactly what keeps it more valuable then the sum of its parts. As such, if you think that there's value in preserving the integrity of monetary transactions, keeping track of wallets, etc, BTC is the wrong horse to bet on. It can be done a lot more cheaply and efficiently with traditional currencies.
- baddox 13y ago> because even it costs $8,000 of resources, to mine $10,000 of BTC, it would still be a profitable enterprise. (In the meantime, you just wasted $8,000 of resources, to make... Nothing that puts bread on the table, a roof over my head, etc.) Huh? I don't understand this analysis at all. If a musician takes $8,000 of resources (recording equipment, labor, etc.) and creates an album that earns $10,000, is that also $8,000 of wasted resources? You list things like food and shelter, so is your point that all resources not used directly for basic human needs are "wasted"? Remember that the musician (or the bitcoin miner) can use their $2,000 profit to purchase their basic human needs. > Since the government has the sole monopoly on printing money, it is (Most of the time) far more valuable than the paper it's printed on. It would be more fair if you also tried to estimate the total cost of government, or of the part of the government that manages the centralized currency. It's definitely not just the cost of making physical bills. > BTC, on the other hand, is barely more valuable then the 'paper' it's printed on - or, the electricity that was used to produce it. The reason a bitcoin is valuable is because it is definitive proof of difficult work. This is fundamental to how the decentralized trustless transaction log works, and is the only reason bitcoin users can be relatively certain that there is no fraud on the network. I think you see this as wasteful because you don't consider the cost of governments' management of currencies.