8 ms·
Poll: How many Bitcoins do you own?
- kalleboo 13y agoGave it a go back when namecheap added bitcoin payment just to try it out. I have 2 BTC left in a wallet backup, but I don't have the client installed anymore since I'm not keen on devoting 10 GB disk space to a copy of the blockchain. Back then they were super easy to get (at least in Japan - feed some cash into an ATM, enter mt gox's account #, enter your username as your depositor name)
- nwh 13y agoBe aware that you don't need the blockchain to use Bitcoin really. MultiBit or Electrum let you use the network securely without it, and have a minimal disk and memory footprint (megabytes, if that).
- surfearth 13y agoWow, up until your comment I had no idea that BitcoinQT was taking up over 18Gb on my hard disk.
- duiker101 13y ago0, I like the idea but I still haven't found a single reason to own one.
- goostavos 13y agoI don't currently own any. However I did pick up a Raspberry Pi recently, which made me a little interesting in the bit coin thing. I'm curious if a RPi cluster could (slowly) but efficiently (from a power consumption standpoint) mine.
- s0rce 13y agoNo, ASIC miners will be much more efficient.
- zapu 13y agoNot really, there is no way you could buy mining equipment right now and make net profits. There are several calculators online that take difficulty increase into account.
- c0ldfusi0nz 13y agoThe simple answer to your question is no.
- dan1234 13y agoI don't think the RPi could be much more than a status monitor for connected ASICs. The Pi's CPU is capable of around 0.2MHashes/sec at 3.75W[0] whereas even a weedy USB ASIC such as the BitForce SC 5Gh/s is capable of 5,000MHashes/sec at 30W[1] [0]https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison#ARM https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison#ARM [1]https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison#ASIC https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison#ASIC
- goostavos 13y agoAh, well, there ya go. Shows I haven't put much thought into it. I'll have to find another reason to justify building a Pi cluster! ;)
- prezjordan 13y agoYou would pay far more for the electricity consumed.
- dan1234 13y agoThe last time my interest was piqued I found it so difficult to buy them in the UK (looked like the best way was to wire some money so someone in France…) that I gave up.
- lucvh 13y agoI had exactly the same experience. Kicking myself now as they were $8 each at the time...
- TomGullen 13y agoRetrospective trading is a good way to chew yourself up. It's meaningless and pointless so don't dwell on it! Look at it from todays perspective.
- TomGullen 13y agoI've been trying to set up an exchange here in the UK, but am facing a lot of what I consider anti competitive behaviour from UK banking. I met Vince Cable to talk about it and hopefully the situation will change in the future: http://www.reddit.com/r/BitcoinUK/comments/1n99os/met_with_vince_cable_to_talk_about_bitcoin/ http://www.reddit.com/r/BitcoinUK/comments/1n99os/met_with_v... Although it's a big mountain to climb so perhaps it's wishful thinking at this stage!
- mgkimsal 13y agoGo talk to Burnley S&L http://www.burnleysavingsandloans.co.uk/about-us/ http://www.burnleysavingsandloans.co.uk/about-us/ See if Dave can help.
- TomGullen 13y agoThanks! Loved that documentary on Channel 4. Have dropped them an email asking if they can help. I'm not clear if they provide online banking or instant transfer notifications (SMS for example) which would be a core requirement for running a Bitcoin exchange. But I've asked, and hopefully something could come of it!
- TomGullen 13y agoWe've invested about 3% of our cash in them. It's a nice high risk high reward gamble.
- chiph 13y agoFor me, it's the chicken + egg problem -- the merchants that sell the stuff I want to buy don't accept them. So I don't have any BTC.
- nvk 13y agoI agree that's why we are launching a POS Terminal they are used to, its a long term play. More info here coinkite.com/faq
- egypturnash 13y agoI dunno if that's worth the effort; more and more businesses I see are using Square on a phone or tablet to take credit cards. But good luck.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoShouldn’t option 2 be ‘0.00000001-10’ instead of ‘0-10’? As it is stated now, someone with no BTC should vote for option 1 as well as option 2. Actually, the other options overlap too. I suggest using ‘11-20’, ‘21-50’, ‘51-200’, ‘201-1,000’, and ‘1,001-10,000’. EDIT: I adjusted option 2 to start with less than 1 but more than zero. Thanks for the correction. I also agree with other commenters that the ‘1-10’ range is too large.
- randyrand 13y agoThen what do people with .001 do? I like it how it is but to be correct it would be .00000001 - 10 (I think that's the right number of decimal places.)
- eterm 13y agoWhat if someone owns 0.2? Ranges should be taken to mean A < x <= Y it seems.
- olalonde 13y agoOops, good catch... I just edited the poll.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoThanks a lot. Good edit.
- tehwebguy 13y agoA good follow up question for those that have them: How did you acquire them? Currency Exchange, Selling Goods, Selling Services, Mining, etc
- scottlinux 13y agocoinbase.com is good if you are in the US.
- modeless 13y agoCurrency exchange, specifically Mt. Gox back when Dwolla still supported them.
- benmanns 13y agoI think 0-10 is a too large a range. There's a big difference between having $10 worth (~0.07 BTC) and $1500 worth (~10 BTC). The first is what I have, which is basically play money. The latter is a more significant investment.
- T-zex 13y agoSo this really depends on how you define the "play money".
- theboss 13y agoExactly this. I have some nonzero amount when I mined for 1 afternoon. Technically I don't have zero but I shouldnt be in the same category as people with a thousand dollars worth. With that said.... I said I have zero in the poll.
- crisnoble 13y agoI think I have .0005 left over in a wallet somewhere. I also said zero. Seeing all this loose change and no easy way to get it out of there I'm wondering if someone can suggest a charity who would accept the measly amounts but use the aggregate for good.
- theboss 13y agoHa. I wonder. If there are only a couple nerds like us we might only get 5 dollars or something. A charity proxy would be cool though, that way people like us have the ability to only donate .0005 and the people with 10,000+ can donate too. Then the proxy converts it to real money and donates it to a particular charity.
- the_watcher 13y agoThis is a good idea for a charity. Wonder how tough it would be to set up? Anyone with interest in looking into it, email me, might be a fun side project to play with some BTC tools.
- logn 13y ago
- skulquake 13y agoI wish I had looked more deeply into the protocol back when the 10k BTC pizza event had occurred.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- paulhauggis 13y agoI don't own a single Bitcoin. The problem is that it's too volatile.
- calinet6 13y agoProblem. Ha.
- eliben 13y agoThe dominance of 0 in the answers is illuminating
- nilved 13y agoIs it? A lot of people use Bitcoin, but it's still a very, very, very, very low percentage of people in all.
- eliben 13y agoI would expect the percentage amongst HN-ers to be way higher though.
- mozboz 13y agoAt time of writing 2/7ths of respondents own > 0 bitcoin. Are there many other new technologies you'd expect 2/7ths of all respondents to use/own? Especially one that doesn't really have a direct use to most consumers yet and high risk for people investing. 2/7th's is huge.
- okasaki 13y agoI mined about 50BTC years ago (when it took around 1 day CPU time), but a constantly deflating currency seemed like a dumb idea so I deleted it. It still seems like a dumb idea, but now I wish I hadn't.
- the_watcher 13y agoWait, you just deleted 50 BTC? That was possible?
- gus_massa 13y agoActually, he hasn’t deleted the 50 BC. They are still there but they are trapped. He only deleted the only copy of the key to transfer them, so those BC will be trapped there “forever”. Actually it’s possible to brute-force search for the key and make the BC free, and transfer them. But with the same method it’s possible to steal BC. The brute-force method is just too slow, and would require a few thousands or perhaps millions of years. (I don’t remember the exact estimation.) With the help of the Moor’s law and some advance breaking the cryptographic security measures, this can happen sooner, but this would be a problem for every BC user.
- gregburd 13y agoI think it's this facet of Bitcoin that's going to end up causing problems in the not too distant future. There will be an ever increasing number of "trapped" coins, BTC that belongs to someone who has abandoned it leaving it unused and thereby lowering the liquidity of the currency. A potential solution would be to incorporate demurrage, which gradually reduces the value of currency the longer it's held, into the BTC algorithms. Essentially by encouraging the holders of a currency to use that currency you'd a) create a more fluid market and b) remove trapped value in some fixed amount of time. If you wanted to maintain a pool of BTC for a long time you'd simply cycle it between two addresses faster than the decay rate so that it's value wouldn't decay.
- wmf 13y ago
- dreen 13y agoSomewhere around 2, I'm not sure. I don't have any use for it at all, but my electricity bill is included in my accomodation, so mining = free money for me. At some point I'll just sell it, a kind of emergency fund.
- Thiz 13y agoIn a couple of years it will be nearly impossible to own ONE single bitcoin for the majority of the population of the world. Satoshis aplenty but bitcoins, fugget about it.
- the_watcher 13y agoAt that point the microBTC will become the de facto denomination. It's already fairly close to that, IMO. When 1 unit of something is worth 100x the most widely available currency, it's no longer useful to list prices in that denomination.
- spurgu 13y agoI own ~2.4 (bought them for 10€) but I forgot the password to my encrypted wallet.
- Dakos 13y agoAnd this is why you should keep a txt file with all your passwords uploaded to dropbox, trust me.
- aidos 13y agoI might trust you (I don't, nothing personal), but I wouldn't trust dropbox.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- adamnemecek 13y agoDakos was joking.
- Munksgaard 13y agoTrust Dropbox, you mean.
- mail2vks 13y agoThat would mean Dropbox reading all passwords. Use KeePassX or any such tool and store the data file in Dropbox instead
- lucb1e 13y agoThe funniest about this is that nobody seems to get it's a joke. That means they probably did it some time in the past :D
- Xcelerate 13y agoMind if I give it a crack attempt? ;)
- igorgue 13y agoI sold all that I had (about 2B) after the Silk Road thing.
- ceejayoz 13y ago2 BTC, presumably, not 2B BTC... :-)
- Zenst 13y ago0 representation here - I do not own any, though that is reflective to my fiscal status currently though have not owned any previously either. Why I own 0 bitcoins (currently): One aspect I find facinating about bitcoins over normal money is how they can be tracked and every coin can be audited openly down to its creation. Whilst with notes this is possible, tills and other transactions do not note down those serial numbers used and coins have no way at all of being tracked. Both due to the analogue forms of transactions mean that no exact coin or note is tracked and at most the amount is tracked albeit in a form not tied down to the history of said coin or note. Bitcoins are completely different. Reason that is important is whilst the media etc seem to portray the criminal usage of bitcoins, the whole system is more secure and auditable than any paper notes or metal coins and with that any bad press about criminal usage of bitcoins are more equaly so with other forms of currency due to the very nature of usage. So one day I may very well get some bitcoins, but finances aside I do see them as dynamic as shares and in many weays less spendable than shares, due to lack of mainstream recognition and acceptance. When you can go into a major bank and get an exchange rate is when some stability gets introduced and the whole dynamic price akin to shares is removed. That is when I will personaly utilise them as a currency of transaction and fiscal storage.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Zenst 13y agoI was not aware of that; But in many ways it is still more auditable than alternative currencies. In some respect this tumbler sounds like money laudering albiet more detectable than alternative currencies. I would also imagine that such brokering/proxy services would still be reliant in that they kept records in a non-public form that would still be open to legal recorse via law authorities.
- schoen 13y agoI heard speculation that some ATMs were technically capable of recording the serial numbers of bills that they dispense to a particular customer (via OCR) and that some bill accepters used by banks or currency exchangers were capable of doing the same. Since modern ATMs already have quite sophisticated OTR on the input side -- I've found them very accurate lately at recognizing even sloppy handwriting on checks -- this is quite plausible technologically. It's not clear to me whether governments would ask cash-handling businesses to do this kind of bill-tracking today, and whether they'd expect to learn interesting things from it. (I'd imagine most bills participate in several cash transactions in between bank deposits.)
- mikeash 13y agoZero here. I don't own any bitcoins for the same reason I don't own any British pounds or Russian rubles: no reason to.
- atom-morgan 13y agoNot even as a way to diversify some of your savings?
- maxaf 13y agoBTC isn't a reliable store of value under any reasonable standard.
- mrtron 13y agoAlso isn't necessarily diversifying. A major USD crash could also crash BTC.
- TomGullen 13y agoHow so? Isn't BTC a good USD hedge?
- atom-morgan 13y agoIt's done well for me so far. Only time will tell :)
- aqme28 13y agoIt's not quite like investing in cash because it has far higher potential returns (and a lot more risk).
- mikeash 13y agoIt amuses me how the answer to "is Bitcoin a currency?" changes depending on which answer is good or bad.
- jcfrei 13y agoaround 0.3 btc and more ltc than I should've bought...
- jere 13y ago4 poll responders have over $1.5 million in BTC?
- olalonde 13y agoThose polls are rarely accurate especially at the edges (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5536734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5536734). I added a "5,000,001+" option just to see how many people will click it.
- jere 13y agoYea I was thinking about that... an option that is so plainly impossible that it doesn't need to be considered (over 1/3 of all BTC does it). I imagine $1.5 million is just on the edge of plausibility for some adventurous, wealthy founders here.
- rms 13y agoEven if they are untruthful, there are surely multiple bitcoin millionaires from Hacker News. Bitcoin was announced here multiple times in the very early days.
- kybernetyk 13y agoI don't own any. I'm waiting for when BTC will be a stable currency and not just a volatile speculation/investment object.
- droogs 13y agoI have just over 2 BTC, but now that Silk Road is closed down, I don't really have any use for them - my only purchases were pharmaceutical drugs that I can't get without prescription in my country. So I'll probably just hang on to them in case Bitcoin shoots up in value some day, and I can sell them for real money.
- Fuxy 13y agoI have 1 BTC I really love the idea of using it and if a had a easy and consistent way of getting it i would use it for most of my online transactions. As it stands now it's incredibly hard to find someone selling BTC unless you're willing to mail a copy of your ID over the internet something i would never do.
- the_watcher 13y agoWhat's wrong with Coinbase? I'm genuinely curious, I had no idea that people have issues buying and selling it, since I've only ever used Coinbase.
- Fuxy 13y agoBesides the fact that it only work in the US nothing. It doesn't even have an option for GBP.
- znowi 13y agoI'd like to hear some stories from the 10k crowd :)
- dredwerker 13y agoI have just over 1. I have traded really hard to get here. I started with about 0.3. I wish I had put some real money in but hey ho I see it as a curiosity that might go somewhere.I think that the govts will wake up and stop it, if it looks too successful.
- Gonzih 13y agoLooks like (at least for now) most of the people here (including me) do not care about bitcoin (less than 10 bitcoins).
- GigabyteCoin 13y agoIf everybody here had ~10 bitcoins, that would only be enough for ~1,100,000 people in the world to own bitcoins. If Bitcoin ever becomes mainstream... most people will have well below 0.01 BTC in their wallets at any given time.
- dasil003 13y agoThat makes me wonder if they'll come up with names for fractional bitcoins just because people hate dealing with decimals.
- jordanthoms 13y agoThey already have :)
- stevewilber 13y agoMajor self-selection bias in this poll. People who don't care about bitcoin (and therefore own zero) won't click on the poll.
- mildtrepidation 13y agoThis may be countered by the fact that people who sign up and log in to HN (and most other sites that allow user commentary) in the first place tend to be vocal about their opinions and predilections. I don't have much faith in BTC and don't own any, but still participated. I'm not saying the bias you mention doesn't exist, but it's not as black and white as you state.
- jlgreco 13y agoZero. I dislike the idea of using bitcoin for currency speculation, though I look forward to using it for normal transactions sometime in the future when it stabilizes and when buying/selling them on demand becomes more streamlined. Basically I am interested in "bitcoin, the cryptocurrency", not "bitcoin, the investment".
- bergie 13y agoThere are several bars and restaurants in my neighbourhood that accept BitCoin, so I'm happy to have some for day-by-day use. Especially as most places in Berlin don't accept cards
- jlgreco 13y agoThere are a few things I could use bitcoin for, but not enough for me to bother using bitcoin instead of other currencies right now. I hope that changes soon though.
- walden42 13y agoIn this early stage, the point is to support an idea you agree with and help it grow. It can't change "soon enough" without the initial users.
- plaguuuuuu 13y agoI don't think it will necessarily stabilize due to lack of any intrinsic value. The best future for Bitcoin is instantaneous on-demand conversion from other currencies.
- kylelibra 13y agoTotal bitcoins in existence ~12M Bitcoins claimed to be owned by people participating in this poll ~35M
- matt_kantor 13y agoNow it's upwards of 75M even if all voters are at the lower bounds of each range.
- nordsieck 13y agoIt could be that people are claiming to own $5M+ worth of bitcoins.
- Kinnard 13y agoNot enough!
- 3lackRos3 13y ago5,000,001+ 12 people.This is funny
- felipelalli 13y ago13 x 5,000,00 = 15,000,000 Almost impossible.
- egypturnash 13y agoI have five. A couple months ago I thought about getting into ASIC miners, but a look at the numbers made me decide to not bother - nothing in the range I was willing to spend was likely to turn a profit. So I took the money I was willing to spend and bought four BTC from Coinbase. Then when the price crashed after the Silk Road bust I got a fifth for a bit less. Now that it's bouncing up around $150/btc I'm kinda wishing I'd bought more - if there's another drop I'll probably move myself up into the 11-50BTC range, then keep sitting on them.
- Glyptodon 13y agoI've stranded some fractions of a bitcoin in wallets I have the addresses for. IE probably < $10 worth that I got for free from some random websites or something once. At various times I've wanted to buy some and store them properly, but buying them was too much of a hassle. Especially with all the personal information exchanges make you give them. I got kind of turned off when I realized the only way to convert cash was to know someone. (The primary thing I though they'd be useful for was paying for a VPN subscription.)
- Zoomla 13y agoI am happy with the fraction of bitcoin that I received for free.. maybe one day it will be worth cashing in, but hopefully not.
- codemonkeymike 13y agoI personally own 11.2BTC, Bought in at about $140 with $1000 and after a few crafty trades was able to make my money back and more. Its like a game, BTC go up and down for no predictable reason so you just have to buy low and sell high instinctively, and sometimes your wrong... instinctively
- rschmitty 13y agoso like an unregulated market of a single stock?
- codemonkeymike 13y agoYeh like trading on the OTCbb
- lifeformed 13y agoI have 1BTC that I got from selling an album of music I made, back when a bitcoin was worth $4.