4 ms·
From the sounds of the article (paper is blocked) it appears that what's actually being tested is the ability of people to read the thoughts of fictional or por
by bane 13y ago
From the sounds of the article (paper is blocked) it appears that what's actually being tested is the ability of people to read the thoughts of fictional or portrayed characters.
> For example, folks who were assigned to read highbrow literary works did better on a test called "Reading the Mind in the Eyes," which required them to look at black-and-white photographs of actors' eyes and decide what emotion the actors were expressing.
A running joke in some acting circles is to sit down with a fellow actor and give them emotions to try and "emote". It becomes a joke because the emotions that are thrown out quickly become hard to even understand let alone interpret into a face. "pensive anticipatory surprise!" "respectful despair!"
The problem with this is that it tests for the ability of an audience to "read" a fictional character, but not necessarily a real one.
For example: this http://images.sciencedaily.com/2009/10/091031002319-large.jpg http://images.sciencedaily.com/2009/10/091031002319-large.jp... is an actor making an angry face. How many people here know someone real who's face becomes absolutely calm when they are in the heat of rage?
Authors have no greater insight into people's psychologies than anybody else, but they can construct a character that, when well motivated, has a representational psychology that can drive a story.
However, various factors make this hard in many cases as certain, close to real, believable characters really require the author to, in some sense, "be" that character in order to represent that character's thought processes. This frequently falls down in certain cross-representations. For example, cross-gender representations are frequently very flat: women written by women tend to have full and complex inner worlds while their men tend to be flat archetypes and visa-versa.
Really good authors get praise for writing cross-representational characters well and the best authors simply try and avoid it through clever story construction (unfamiliar cross-characters are turned into flat background players, or they're turned into crazy people where their madness creates an unpredictable inner-drive that covers up for the authors lack of knowledge). What was the last book anybody read, written by a White American privileged male author that explored the inner psychology of a Black inner-city French teen girl?
You'll notice that children are also as terribly written as they are painted in Renaissance paintings.
http://uglyrenaissancebabies.tumblr.com/ http://uglyrenaissancebabies.tumblr.com/
It's not that the author never lived as a child, but that as children, we don't have the faculty and level of self-awareness to record what it's like to be a child in most cases.
More importantly, emotional display is often very cultural. Can anybody tell me what this emotion is?
http://www.sarugallery.com/files/B1120nor.jpg http://www.sarugallery.com/files/B1120nor.jpg
or this?
http://www.theoneshots.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/20130616_theoneshots_salima_2pm_minjun.jpg http://www.theoneshots.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/201306...
or this?
http://en.korea.com/fx/files/2011/07/14.jpg http://en.korea.com/fx/files/2011/07/14.jpg
So I'm colored very skeptical about this paper. I think it measures something, but the conclusion about what it's measuring is wrong.
- NhanH 13y ago(Not to say that the paper is correct, I haven't read the actual study). Authors don't need to have greater insight into people's psychologies, even if the characters is just a representation of the author's mind, a reader reading many different works would have a glimpse of many minds, and it isn't hard to argue that it would help in reading actual thoughts of real people. And the distinction of thoughts of fictional characters and real people is a thin one, as you said it yourself, many characters (within a certain genre and level of works) are in fact very realistic - a believable character has to be grounded somewhat from reality. Pick a fictional character in a good literary work, chances are in the real world, someone somewhere would have the same personality. And the not-so-good children in Renaissance paintings doesn't affect the quality of Mona Lisa at all.
- bane 13y ago> a believable character has to be grounded somewhat from reality. Yeah, I think there's basically a few classes of characters that authors tend to use: - Based on somebody they know (or a synthesis of a few people). These are easiest to give reasonable approximations of normal psychologies to. Or at least a good surface description of their behavior seems to be enough for people to fill in the mind of the character. - A completely artificial character, but constructed on a profile so as to seem real. A bit like how modern artists start drawing characters from a basic frame to give a realistic movement or position, then fill in the details. This I think is harder in literature since you really have to build a detailed profile of the character as a model so that they provide a consistent and believable behavior. But I think this is also limited by what the author understands about people's psychology and behavior. If the author can't figure what motivates a certain kind of behavior, then they can't really build the psych model of the character and you end up with weird, unmotivated characters without agency. Lots of the more painful Literary Fiction I had to suffer through in school is like this. I think this is also dangerous for readers as it conditions them to expect real people to think and behave like this. - A flat archetype or stereotype for a character the author needs in the story but doesn't know well enough to write about well. So they become part of the background fabric of the story, providing part of the framework for the better defined characters to work within, but never really coming into their own. Even main characters suffer from this. > And the not-so-good children in Renaissance paintings doesn't affect the quality of Mona Lisa at all. It's funny you brought up the Mona Lisa, a painting with an expression so strange there's little agreement about what emotion it's conveying at all.