4 ms·
This photorealism makes new games very boring artistic-wise. Old games with hand-drawn graphic had some artistic value in them, they made pepole imagine other
by ajuc 17y ago
This photorealism makes new games very boring artistic-wise.
Old games with hand-drawn graphic had some artistic value in them, they made pepole imagine other worlds etc. Now it's just photorealism everywhere.
I wonder, when game graphic dadaism and cubism will appear.
Art is not about making more realistic copies.
- ken 17y agoHe mentions Okami in the comments -- I don't think that's quite dadaist but it's certainly not photorealistic.
- jcromartie 17y ago> Art is not about making more realistic copies. Indeed, but maybe it's just that (certain) games and film are getting closer. Films use realistic special effects to get you to suspend disbelief when the setting includes magic or aliens. We have sci-fi and horror games that try to evoke emotions and senses of otherness/horror, and I think the photorealistic approach does that more effectively.
- wmf 17y agoFez is made out of cubes; does that count? :-)
- Splines 17y agoI think it's not that games are becoming more realistic, it's just that the range of possibilities for art in games is getting closer to realistic. There are still many games that have a distinct art style that is not at all realistic (off-hand, Castle Crashers and Braid on XBLA come to mind). Will we have non-realistic FPS games? Maybe, but unlikely, as one of the points of FPS games is to immerse people in a world, and making that world look as real as possible is part of that goal. Right now, I'm having a hard time thinking of an FPS game that is non-realistic (Madworld on Wii?)
- chops 17y agoTeam Fortress 2 is cartoony and not realistic at all.
- joshwa 17y agoVideo games have reached a technological milestone/inflection point similar to those reached in other mediums in the past-- the transition from painting to photography, or from expensive digital photography to inexpensive digital photography, or CGI in movies: Past a certain point of fidelity, the art direction/production design (what you actually choose to put in the frame) becomes much more important than raw technique. (related: amidst a flood of crap, curation becomes essential)
- baddox 17y ago"Art is not about making more realistic copies." True, but video games aren't simply visual art, like a painting. Photorealism can help immerse you into the game's fiction, which can definitely make the game less boring.
- randallsquared 17y agoI don't think most games are intended as "art" in any high sense, but only as "entertainment". Personally, I'd find it awesome if WoW looked more realistic. (If you're not familiar with the graphic style of World of Warcraft, it's very cartoony, even crayony).
- pchristensen 17y ago"Art is not about making more realistic copies." No, but entertainment is about creating a convincing, immersive experience.