5 ms·
His cure is worse than the disease. If everyone did as he did we would cause MUCH more environmental damage to the world. Wood fire? There is nothing worse fo
by ars 13y ago
His cure is worse than the disease.
If everyone did as he did we would cause MUCH more environmental damage to the world.
Wood fire? There is nothing worse for the environment except maybe coal, and even that (in the US) is not necessarily worse. Wood smoke is a very serious pollutant, which in quantity would blacken the sky.
A rocket stove is pretty good - but it doesn't come close to the efficiency of a natural gas one. So he's using a worse fuel, and being less efficient at it.
Beeswax candles? Is he trying to find the most wasteful and most inefficient way to light something? And candles make smoke too.
- brazzy 13y ago> If everyone did as he did we would cause MUCH more environmental damage to the world. Absolutely not - but a lot of people would starve without industrial-scale agriculture. > Wood fire? There is nothing worse for the environment except maybe coal Except that he's probably using less than 1% of the energy everyone else does. No car. No fancy applicances. No food transported across the globe and packaged in aluminum cans. No meat.
- ars 13y ago> using less than 1% of the energy everyone else And releasing thousands of times as much pollution. It's not worth the exchange.
- manicdee 13y agoThousands of times more pollution? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence! The energy content of wood varies based on how dry it is (obviously, water can't burn so you remove the water to increase the proportion of remaining mass that burns compared to the energy released when burning the combustible mass) abut ends up being approximately 15Mj/kg. Using an efficient wood stove you can extract about 70% of this energy as heat, for the purpose of heating and cooking. The energy content of coal is about double that of wood. Typically we don't burn coal in home fires, rather we burn the coal in a large power plant, carry the energy as electricity then consume that energy in various forms at home. The typical efficiency of coal fired power plants is in the order of 30–40%. So you are basically at parity with wood fuel, with the convenience of a large power plant where it becomes economically viable to scrub ash and soot out of the exhaust. So how much less pollution does as coal fired power plant produce than a wood fire at home? It turns out that scrubbers are anywhere from 95–99% efficient depending on design, energy input and maintenance. So what we are left with is an estimate of the pollution produced by a wood fire being in the order of hundreds of times worse than pollution produced by the same energy production at a coal fired power plant. To qualify for "thousands" of times more pollution, the scrubbers at the coal fired plant would have to be 99.9% efficient without consuming a significant portion of the energy produced by the power plant (this is the goal of "clean coal" projects).
- ars 13y agoI was comparing to natural gas, which is what most people prefer to cook on. But even comparing coal, and being a few hundred times worse, 1% of the energy usage is nothing to celebrate.
- brazzy 13y agoEven if that were the case: making (and disposing of) cars, gadgets, etc. causes lots of pollution that is not related to the consumed energy.
- huhtenberg 13y agoWood fire smoke blackening the sky is the top HN comment. Awesome.
- mcantelon 13y agoWhat would create more pollutant... a wood fire for a single person or a 45 minute, each way, driving commute? Do areas in which wood fires are the norm have blackened skies?
- icebraining 13y agoSeems like a false dichotomy to me. Instead of going back to Mesopotamia, we could telecommute.
- svantana 13y agoThey are different types of pollutants. Wood fire creates a lot of carcinogens while (carburated) exhaust fumes are basically safe to inhale, although they do contribute to global warming it seems.
- manicdee 13y agoAnd yet people commit suicide by deliberately inhaling those "safe" exhaust fumes. Carbon monoxide, man. It's damaging stuff.
- ars 13y agoOh, a wood fire. No question whatsoever. Non diesel cars release very little pollution. >Do areas in which wood fires are the norm have blackened skies? http://practicalaction.org/smoke_kenya http://practicalaction.org/smoke_kenya http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs292/en/ http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs292/en/
- jotm 13y agoThis reminds me of someone who thought steam engines (basically water, right?) were more environmentally friendly - he was very surprised when I told him they burned massive amounts of wood and coal to power those engines :-)
- baq 13y agoNot only that, pretty much every power plant in operation is a steam engine. The exceptions are solar, wind and river dams.
- eksith 13y agoBiomass pellets (or similar compressed fuel) is probably closer to natural gas in exhaust than loose fuel like wood and sticks since they burn much hotter. There are tons of examples online on how to build rocket stoves out of old LPG cylinders, steel tubes and such, and even I came up with a design someone with reasonable welding skills should be able DIY for pellet use : http://eksith.wordpress.com/2012/10/14/pellet-stove-2-0 http://eksith.wordpress.com/2012/10/14/pellet-stove-2-0 I agree on Beeswax. As nice as it is to smell (and I rather like the warmer glow than a paraffin candle) it's a luxury; not a proper solution.
- justinhj 13y agoIf we went back to pre-civilization where people lived in bands of 200 people and lived sustainably on the food that each area provided, then that would require massive population reduction. At the level of population the planet can naturally support the pollution from fires wouldn't matter. It only matters when you scale it up to 9 billion of us, which is only possible because of technology.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- madaxe 13y agoWood fire? There is nothing worse for the environment Although the carbon you release by burning wood was recently sequestered by the tree, rather than Ga ago, as with petrochemicals, so the net carbon shift is relatively neutral. Point taken re: nanoparticulates, but wood is nowhere near as bad as fossil fuels.
- ars 13y ago> Point taken re: nanoparticulates, but wood is nowhere near as bad as fossil fuels. That is not true. Wood smoke is much worse.
- madaxe 13y agoMuch worse in terms of nanoparticulates, yes - I'm not disagreeing with that - but with wood you're releasing carbon that was currently extant in the biosphere, rather than carbon which was sequestered hundreds of millions of years ago.
- ekianjo 13y agoOn top of that, the big flaw of his liestyle is that he has needed money up until now to buy all the tools and utilities he uses everyday now that he is moneyless. And he profits of the fact that people around him live in a world where they produce and exhange goods that he can use for himself as well. Another modern Bobo (french word for Bourgeois Boheme).And yeah capitalism is super flawed obviously since the whole world is getting out of poverty as a whole. Indeed we are doomed!
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoWood fires aren't great if you're growing and cutting down the trees but if he's burning wood from trees that have fallen naturally and would otherwise rot it's a lot better - the rotting itself releases CO2 at a similar level so you're not increasing the overall CO2 emissions, just changing how it comes about. Obviously trees that fall naturally aren't sustainable on a large scale but for an individual it's feasible.
- ars 13y agoI said pollution not CO2. Wood fire creates smoke, which is much much worse than CO2.