4 ms·
No doubt he was a brilliant inventor. But designing gadgets is not science, and if that's all he did he wasn't a "scientist".
by leephillips 13y ago
No doubt he was a brilliant inventor. But designing gadgets is not science, and if that's all he did he wasn't a "scientist".
- Brakenshire 13y agoSeems like an odd thing to say. He was an applied materials scientist, you don't have to work on fundamental theories to be a scientist.
- yeukhon 13y agoEven theoretical scientists actually make product and those are theoretical results they can prove on paper. Those proofs are products and are delivered to the next level of assembly - the applied scientists whom we call them engineers. I.E he's an engineer.
- VLM 13y agoIts merely a PR failure. He's a practicing electrochemist, but for PR purposes he made some interesting gadgets to demonstrate his work. By analogy, you're arguing the NASA guys are not scientists, but artists making large fiery phallic symbols. Lets say you spend all day designing cool battery tech, there's nothing to really show a journalist, so you put it in a gadget like an electric car and then the journalist assumes all you do is bolt batteries into cars all day. I will say that he has the proven ability to make awesome demonstration equipment for a materials science / electrochem class. Maybe a MOOC like Coursera or ed-x should draft him to teach an electrochem class or maybe materials science.