5 ms·
This stuff annoys me, "Ovshinsky’s achievements are all the more remarkable because he had no formal qualifications beyond a high school diploma." It annoys me
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
This stuff annoys me, "Ovshinsky’s achievements are all the more remarkable because he had no formal qualifications beyond a high school diploma."
It annoys me because the guy clearly had the equivalent of a Phd in materials science, he just didn't happen to get it at an accredited institution.
The annoyance comes from the people who read this and say "Gee, even somebody that never went to college can do this." rather than "Gee, you can learn anything even without attending a college if you have the drive." I got similarly annoyed when someone with a PhD makes an assumption that because someone doesn't have a PhD they must not be able to get a PhD, but knowledge isn't like that.
Rather than pitch this guy as someone with no formal education, we should hold him up as someone who chose to educate himself deeply in the subjects he was passionate about. To seek out knowledge and to hone his ability to separate truth from fiction, insight from platitude.
- jonnybgood 13y agoWithout a piece of paper saying so, you can only prove your level of knowledge through successful actions. Otherwise, how else can it be proven? This is what I have observed.
- pdonis 13y agoOne small correction: even with a piece of paper saying so, you can only prove your level of knowledge through successful actions.
- kyro 13y agoThe problem you're talking about, which I agree exists, has more to do with readers than with the author because I really didn't read any of that in the article. The author just seems to offer admiration for the guy's drive and resourcefulness, and doesn't at all advocate not attaining formal qualifications. What I wanna know is how this guy put together an effective and cohesive curriculum instead of the scattered and unfocused one I tend to fall into when trying to self- educate.
- TheZenPsycho 13y agoOnce you have a specific goal in mind, it suggests the kinds of questions you should be asking the library oracle, and you let that guide what you study. In other words, if you have an actual problem, and you really need to solve it, that is the motivating and focusing force. At least, I am guessing that's how he did it. I could be totally wrong.
- auggierose 13y agoNo need to get obset, that's where the "formal" in formal qualifications comes from.
- thatthatis 13y agoIn economics, degrees serve the roles of prior selection filters, ability to complete tests, and easy to understand signals of approximate knowledge level. Autodidacts can never hope to match the prior selection filter, but it seems conceivable that the knowledge level signal could be recreate through a credentialing equivalency test of some sort.
- yen223 13y ago> "... a credentialing equivalency test of some sort." Like some kind of degree, issued by an accredited university?
- VLM 13y agoMore like a github repo or published scientific papers which are good enough to be cited by others. Once you're over 30 or so and have had some real jobs if the local network is small enough, your interviewer probably knows someone who knows someone who knows what you can do. Note that he's pretty old. I read a popular science/discovery magazine level bio of him in the 80s and he was old them. Unless this is his son following in dads footsteps? The relevance to being old is by analogy its impossible to get into the nuclear engineering biz in 2013 without a title of nobility, err, I mean a degree in nuke sci, but back in the 1940s the los alamos OG were shipping working product without the benefit of a title of nobility, err, I mean a degree. So its highly likely that when he was a kid and flooded lead acid was cutting edge high tech, there probably was no relevant title of nobility to bestow upon him when he was young, the field grew up around him such that a kid today could never break into the field without a title of nobility.