4 ms·
First, let me point out that it is meaningless to offer a single counter-example as a response to a statistical generalization over thousands of terrorist incid
by gwern 13y ago
First, let me point out that it is meaningless to offer a single counter-example as a response to a statistical generalization over thousands of terrorist incidents and hundreds of terrorist groups over the past century or so. You haven't even begun to argue on the same level. "Smoking is bad and cuts X years off life expectancy." "What willful amnesia! Don't you remember your uncle was a smoker and died at the ripe age of 85?"
Second, what the predecessors to AQ did in Afghanistan is irrelevant. They were fighting a conventional/guerrilla war against a government run by a foreign superpower, and were heavily funded by the rival foreign superpower and its regional nation-state allies like Saudi Arabia who viewed it as a matter of geopolitical survival w/r/t subversion to neighboring countries & global energy supplies. This looks nothing like their later terrorist campaigns and the lessons or success of one do not generalize to the global summaries of terrorist groups - not that you bothered to explain how the 7 puzzles 'go right out the window' in the first place.
- theHiccups 13y agoI pretty much reject the entire premise of any sort of quantitative "statistical generalization", when it comes to "terror", because terror is an arbitrary qualitative generalization to begin with. So, here comes this analysis that attempts to state facts as: 1. Terrorists only target civilians 2. Guerrillas only target uniforms holding weapons ...and never the twain shall meet! These kinds of generalizations in social science are flawed from the outset, but now we try to plot the numbers anyway? I don't buy into the idea that a heterogeneous mixture of non-state, civilian-killing groups can be boiled down to bald numbers. I think it's a mistake to even try. I don't think targeting civilians is a rational goal, so how are you going to apply ratios to it?
- gwern 13y ago> I pretty much reject the entire premise of any sort of quantitative "statistical generalization", when it comes to "terror", because terror is an arbitrary qualitative generalization to begin with. I don't think it is. While there are differences about edge cases, you'll find an awful lot of agreement among people about 9/11 or a random suicide bomber blowing himself up in a cafe. Terrorism can be reasonably defined, classified, and statistically treated. > I don't buy into the idea that a heterogeneous mixture of non-state, civilian-killing groups can be boiled down to bald numbers. I think it's a mistake to even try. If they really are heterogenous then they can be analyzed in more meaningful subgroups!