7 ms·
Stanford Ovshinsky: the greatest scientist you've never heard of?
- leephillips 13y agoNo doubt he was a brilliant inventor. But designing gadgets is not science, and if that's all he did he wasn't a "scientist".
- Brakenshire 13y agoSeems like an odd thing to say. He was an applied materials scientist, you don't have to work on fundamental theories to be a scientist.
- yeukhon 13y agoEven theoretical scientists actually make product and those are theoretical results they can prove on paper. Those proofs are products and are delivered to the next level of assembly - the applied scientists whom we call them engineers. I.E he's an engineer.
- VLM 13y agoIts merely a PR failure. He's a practicing electrochemist, but for PR purposes he made some interesting gadgets to demonstrate his work. By analogy, you're arguing the NASA guys are not scientists, but artists making large fiery phallic symbols. Lets say you spend all day designing cool battery tech, there's nothing to really show a journalist, so you put it in a gadget like an electric car and then the journalist assumes all you do is bolt batteries into cars all day. I will say that he has the proven ability to make awesome demonstration equipment for a materials science / electrochem class. Maybe a MOOC like Coursera or ed-x should draft him to teach an electrochem class or maybe materials science.
- jpopow 13y agoA genius man. Too bad haven't such people as politicians. Particularly thankful I am for his contribution too CDs and DVDs which I upcycle once used to flowers and jewellery. www.facebook.com/rawcopiednature Thank You Mr Ovshinsky. I will bring you a golden one when moving to US after applying to YC.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Brakenshire 13y agoIIRC, an Ovshinsky NiMH battery patent is what's behind the idea in "Who Killed the Electric Car?", that various companies bought up a key technology of Electric Cars to run them into the ground. Although I'm not clear on whether the story is true. At least, by the time the patent had expired, it seemed to have lost its pre-eminence, as there didn't seem to be any particular explosion in NiMH technology afterwards.
- SamuelKillin 13y agoI'm pretty sure they even take a walk around his factory with him in the movie
- jdmitch 13y agoHe saw science ending poverty by ensuring everyone had access to the resources necessary for life. This is an interesting statement, given that it doesn't sound like any of his inventions seem to be particularly focused on ending poverty in any direct way.
- davedx 13y agoHi jdmitch, I read a lot of negative comments on Hacker News lately, including those posted as 'feedback' for things people have made and dared to post here, but also on articles where people are trying to spread some optimism and light amongst the typically depressing headlines we read every day. So after reading this article, I of course clicked through to the comments hoping for some positive responses. Why? I don't know really, just because, you know, it might be nice to acknowledge the achievements of a man who dedicated his life to science, engineering and the betterment of society in general. It might be pleasant to, just once, instead of nitpicking, belittling, or demeaning the original poster or subject of the article, say something positive. I briefly considered finding some evidence to demonstrate how much of a positive effect solar panels are having in developing countries (I'm fairly sure this is true). But then I decided not to, and just post something a bit more in the spirit of your original comment, a bit more thoughtless and petty. If we were in a real life conversation, and someone brought up this genuinely interesting, game changing, benevolent gentlemen, and you responded in such a way, I think I would tell you that if you can't say something nice in such a situation, I suggest you don't say anything at all.
- fnazeeri 13y agoMet and worked with him (briefly) in the 90's. Nice guy. No focus. Lost a lot of other people's money. Probably should have been a professor instead of a businessman.
- rgbrenner 13y agoWhat do you base that on? He founded ECD in 1960, was the CEO for 46 years, built it into a 300m+/year revenue company. Left it in 2006.. it went bankrupt in 2012. The bonds that led to the bankruptcy were issued in 2008 by his replacement/ The trustee recently filed suit against 3 chineese companies saying ECD went bankrupt because of their price fixing. Are you saying that because it went bankrupt 6 years after he left, that he was a bad businessman? http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424127887323829104578622011650335422 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142412788732382910... http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303442004579122261141953326.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230344200457912... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Conversion_Devices http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Conversion_Devices
- ivanhoe 13y agoI'd say he was more of The Tesla of our age, than The Edison (as The Economist titled it's article http://www.economist.com/node/8312367 http://www.economist.com/node/8312367)
- mortdeus 13y agoBut the Kardashians are just so much more interesting. Have you seen the buns on that Kim girl?
- democracy 13y agoHe was a great man, indeed, and his life principles of paying more focus to creative side and not immediate profits deserve great respect.
- dimkar 13y agoTotally agree with you: when it comes to innovation, money gaining should not be the only goal, money is a means, and Ovshinsky proved it. Very positive and meaningful article.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThis stuff annoys me, "Ovshinsky’s achievements are all the more remarkable because he had no formal qualifications beyond a high school diploma." It annoys me because the guy clearly had the equivalent of a Phd in materials science, he just didn't happen to get it at an accredited institution. The annoyance comes from the people who read this and say "Gee, even somebody that never went to college can do this." rather than "Gee, you can learn anything even without attending a college if you have the drive." I got similarly annoyed when someone with a PhD makes an assumption that because someone doesn't have a PhD they must not be able to get a PhD, but knowledge isn't like that. Rather than pitch this guy as someone with no formal education, we should hold him up as someone who chose to educate himself deeply in the subjects he was passionate about. To seek out knowledge and to hone his ability to separate truth from fiction, insight from platitude.
- jonnybgood 13y agoWithout a piece of paper saying so, you can only prove your level of knowledge through successful actions. Otherwise, how else can it be proven? This is what I have observed.
- pdonis 13y agoOne small correction: even with a piece of paper saying so, you can only prove your level of knowledge through successful actions.
- kyro 13y agoThe problem you're talking about, which I agree exists, has more to do with readers than with the author because I really didn't read any of that in the article. The author just seems to offer admiration for the guy's drive and resourcefulness, and doesn't at all advocate not attaining formal qualifications. What I wanna know is how this guy put together an effective and cohesive curriculum instead of the scattered and unfocused one I tend to fall into when trying to self- educate.
- TheZenPsycho 13y ago
- jrjr 13y agoMr. Ovshinsky spent a lot of time prying money out of corporations, without meaningful results. His greatest accomplishment was the ability to convince investors. He's no Kennedy, or Tesla.
- TheZenPsycho 13y agoI would consider convincing corporations to "waste" their money for no profitable result, is a great achievement. More corporate money should be spent on the betterment of invention and human welfare without an expectation of profits.
- pdonis 13y agoIt looks like Ovishinsky's corporation did make a profit, at least while he was running it. So I don't think your implied dichotomy--you can make a profit, or you can improve human welfare, but not both--holds water.
- TheZenPsycho 13y agoI implied no such dichotomy. If there were such a dichotomy though, it would be no great shame to "waste" money regardless.
- pdonis 13y agoBut profit is what tells you that what you are doing is valuable, i.e., that it is not a waste (no scare-quotes) of money, or more importantly, of the time and effort of the people involved. So the fact that Ovishinsky's company made a profit while he was running it is not an accident: it is a consequence of the fact that his inventions were valuable, so that spending his time and effort, and that of his employees, on them was worth doing. Your definition of "waste" appears to be something that you think is worth doing, but which does not make a profit. But if it is worth doing, why is it not making a profit? And if it is not worth doing, why put "waste" in quotes? People's time and effort would be better spent on something else. Finally, if you want to spend your own time and effort (and money) on something that others might consider to be not worth doing, that's your choice. But when you talk about convincing others to "waste" money, you are no longer just committing your own time and effort (and money); you are committing theirs. The track record of this method of organizing human activity when not constrained by the need to make a profit (in order for the activity to stay in business) is not good.
- jrjr 13y agoMr. Ovshinsky spent a lot of time prying money out of corporations, without meaningful results. His greatest accomplishment was the ability to convince investors. He's no Kennedy, or Tesla.
- officemonkey 13y agoI don't know about that. I bet if you asked random 100 people who "Charles Steinmetz" was you would get similar dumb looks. And Steinmetz blows this guy out of the water.
- shn 13y agoI wonder why somebody promotes this person out of the blue and becomes an HN material? Yes it is an anniversary but why not do it while he was vertical last year or the previous year. I gather from the comments that his achievements are controversial as well. That is why I asked this question.
- kbart 13y agoMaybe to remind the engineers here that "making tons of money" is not the only approach in life? I find this article interesting, related and thoughtful. One of these rare counterexamples to the popular culture.
- ryanatkn 13y agoThis interview with Ovshinsky has some interesting stuff. [1] He talks about his motivations being socially driven, his vision of how humanity can use science and technology to make our world better, how a car company reduced his 201 mile range electric car (which happened to be his very first prototype) to a 125 mile one at retail, and how it might be a bad idea to go into business with an oil company if their long term strategy is counter to yours. Neat guy. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yh4KuCVlF14 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yh4KuCVlF14
- kzisme 13y agoIt makes me happy to know someone interesting came from good old Akron, Ohio.
- arjn 13y agoI just dropped by to say that Stanford Ovshinksy is not unknown ... just relatively lesser known. I knew about him as far back as 1997 thanks to a documentary about him and his work. I recall one of the catch-phrases he used to describe his work with amorphous crystals - "Tyranny of the crystal".