4 ms·
One thing that I always find surprising is that Soviet space programs have about the same fatality rate as NASA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacefli
by rdtsc 13y ago
One thing that I always find surprising is that Soviet space programs have about the same fatality rate as NASA.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_accidents_and_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_ac...
I remember jokes about unreliable and shoddy Soviet construction, people cutting corners and all, and about "high quality" American technology, where everyone is honest and human safety comes first. Yet looking back the track record doesn't quite match.
Obviously Americans launched larger crews. But you know, that is also perhaps thing that should have factored in -- "If we launch 8 people at once, we will probably kill all of them if an accident happens".
Another issue is well Americans just launched more flights so they clearly would have a higher accident rate. It seems from the above site, the rate of accidents (per flight?) is about the same for both space programs.
- VLM 13y agoDeath rate is a result of middle management behavior, and the insight is stereotypical middle manager behavior is self organizing and reproducible regardless of higher level political belief? Middle manager behavior in Russia is interchangeable with middle manager behavior in USA, even if their claimed mythology changes? You could come up with an alternate theory where death rate during actual R+D is very high and indeterminate, its just that actual R+D happens in small distinct pellets only a tiny fraction of the actual total program lifetime. So if 99.9% of the deaths come from fundamentally R+D mistakes but 99.9% of time is spent doing something other than R+D (ranging from operations to investigations) then the short term result is the same death rate. What I'm getting at is killing astronauts and cosmonauts results in program paralysis for many years, and we've only got a few decades of data, mostly spent in paralysis mode?
- m0skit0 13y agoTypical Cold War propaganda stuff.
- cema 13y agoNot necessarily. Space research and a few other special programs were different from the rest of the industry (both in the USSR and the USA). Greatly simplifying, I would say it like this: the top level of the industrial development in the USSR was on the par with the rest of the world; the average level was below that of the West.
- huhtenberg 13y ago> One thing that I always find surprising is that Soviet space programs have about the same fatality rate as NASA. Funny enough, but it's the same thing that surprises me, though for the exactly opposite reasons. Growing up in Soviet Union era I have this ingrained belief that Soviet space program was the safest one, which is actually true if you look at the absolute numbers and also consider zero fatalities since the early 70s. I don't know if it were propaganda or not, but the common knowledge was that Soviet launch vehicles were built for the safety of the crew first and foremost, even if at expense of other priorities. Also the same went for the fighter jet safety systems and a common story goes that for a long time only Soviet jets had ejection seats capable of safely rescuing pilots if activated on the ground.
- znowi 13y ago> Soviet space program was the safest one I've always had a similar perception. Incidentally, Soyuz is considered the safest craft with only two accidents (Soyuz 1 and Soyuz 11) in 46 years.
- tanzam75 13y ago> Incidentally, Soyuz is considered the safest craft with only two accidents (Soyuz 1 and Soyuz 11) in 46 years. No. There were only two Soyuz missions with fatal accidents. However, there have been a number of Soyuz missions with nonfatal accidents. Multiple ballistic reentries, multiple engine failures, multiple docking issues, multiple failures of the braking rockets on landing. Cosmonauts have suffered bruises, broken teeth, broken ribs -- one crewmember on Soyuz 18a was so badly injured that he never flew in space again. But Soyuz was an inherently robust design. It is designed to be survivable, to have backups to backups. You may not enjoy the experience, but the Soyuz will try its best to bring you back to earth alive. For example, there have been three separation failures during reentry, most recently in 2008. This is an extremely harrowing event, because the unseparated spacecraft assumes a head-first orientation, unprotected by the heat shield. However, the Soyuz is robustly built, and in all three cases the reentry module survived long enough for the connection to the orbital module to burn free. Once that happened, the mass distribution of the reentry module automatically rotated it to face heat-shield forward. Those three separation failures could've killed 8 cosmonauts. Instead, they killed no cosmonauts. Because the Soyuz could tolerate this particular failure mode.
- kllrnohj 13y ago> Yet looking back the track record doesn't quite match. Well it does, kind of. I mean, during the space race itself and the cold war the US's space program had no in flight fatalities. The first NASA flight fatality wasn't until '86, a good 14 years after the Apollo program had ended. For what it's worth the Soviet's response to the Shuttle program was a failure. NASA remains the only one to get a partially re-usable orbiter into use. > But you know, that is also perhaps thing that should have factored in -- "If we launch 8 people at once, we will probably kill all of them if an accident happens". The Space Shuttle program already had a good 24 successful flights, 6 of which were in the Challenger, before the first fatal flight. It wasn't like they crammed in a bunch of people in an experimental ship for shits and giggles. The first set of shuttle flights only had a crew of 2.
- rdtsc 13y ago> For what it's worth the Soviet's response to the Shuttle program was a failure. I always thought Buran was a great success. It performed the first fully autonomous flight. It did at a fraction of what the Shuttle cost. It is just that "shuttles" are just a bad idea to start with. It is like saying Soviet Nuclear Airplanes were a failure compared to American Nuclear Airplanes. Well the idea of nuclear airplanes isn't that great so comparing advances in it doesn't say much. They started it as a response to show that they could do it. Then it was deemed a bad idea. Americans kept launching these oversized, expensive, hard and expensive to maintain machines. Looking at that particular Wikipedia page, informally it looks like the Soviet also didn't have any fatalities after 1971. Americans had quite a few. [quote from wikipedia article] "Soyuz accidents have claimed the lives of four cosmonauts. No deaths have occurred on Soyuz missions since 1971, and none with the current design of the Soyuz. Including the early Soyuz design, the average deaths per launched crew member on Soyuz are currently under two percent. " Sounds like historically their design is just better.
- kllrnohj 13y ago> It is just that "shuttles" are just a bad idea to start with. Shuttles are a fantastic idea. Just because the implementation wasn't brilliant doesn't make the idea bad. Then again I'd strongly disagree with your claim that the Shuttle program was bad in the first place. It had a very successful and impressive 30 year carrier. The comparisons of the Shuttle vs. the Soyuz are bad in the first place as the two platforms are vastly different in lifting capability. The correct comparison would be the Shuttle vs. the Proton-M/K, and the Protons are far from reliable (Proton-M has had 8 failed launches since 2001). Without the Space Shuttle we wouldn't have the ISS for example. > Sounds like historically their design is just better. Better than what? The Saturn V is the only rocket that has propelled humans to the moon, and the entire Saturn family has zero deaths. And the Saturn V remains to this day the heaviest lifter mankind has created (NASA's SLS and China's Long March 9 are in development to surpass the Saturn V)
- qwerta 13y agoSoviet rockets were more reliable because they did not throw away the good designs, after they were tested. I guess space exploration could be completely different, if Space Shuttle would launch and land without humans. Apollo could be used as 'lift' to Shuttle on orbit. Shuttle is excellent truck, but man-rating it for atmospheric flight was huge waste.
- justin66 13y agoThe problems inherent to the STS design - which make it so expensive to operate, among other things - would maintain even if it weren't man rated. You'd still have to rebuild the skin of the vehicle and the solid rocket boosters every time you used it. If you messed that up with an unmanned version you'd still risk blowing up your very, very expensive toy every time. We could launch Apollo capsules and big cargo containers with Saturn rockets, before STS.
- tbarbugli 13y agowell, there was some anti URSS propaganda going on in US. might be another surprise but no, kids were not dinner material either :P