3 ms·
Am I the only one wondering where the meat of the argument went? There seemed to be some vague resentment at the pop-business-marketing-solution-in-a-book indu
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
Am I the only one wondering where the meat of the argument went? There seemed to be some vague resentment at the pop-business-marketing-solution-in-a-book industry and some desire to link it back to the professional middle class
To me the argument should run differently:
- technical innovation has never been higher, both in absolute terms and in the products being brought to market.
- yes many innovations are tiny evolutions on existing products, but blame consumer surplus capture rather than a conspiracy.
- If we want more forward leaps in science and technology we should lobby our governments to double the STEM spending at least. It's hard to bring a product to market if it's core has not been invented.
- And really, TED talks, and all the other pop-insight industry, is not lying - they may be repeating some basic ideas (learn how to solve a problem, use that method in a new area, monitor the results) and we should not get upset if people try to hype up their life's work. No just accept that there are 7 billion people, and we need that many to see the next ground shaking concept invented in time.
One other point - I suspect the reason the author is hearing the same points raised time and again is a sign of an a creation of agreement over the accepted new paradigm for society to use. once upon a time slavery was an acceptable paradigm, so was anti-gay prejudice and so was religion and superstition.
What we see is the new modes of thought getting tried out like clothes in a shop. One day we will all quote Maslow.
- brownbat 13y ago> Am I the only one wondering where the meat of the argument went? I didn't read an argument so much as just a sneer against professionals who admire scientists and inventors. But hey, sneering for sneering's sake is sometimes fun. The last paragraph has a little more structure than the essay as a whole, and is mercifully much shorter. Maybe the best revision wouldn't be repairing the argument so much as reducing the whole thing to a tweet. > the professional-managerial audience['s] members hear clear, sweet reason when they listen to NPR and think they’re in the presence of something profound when they watch some billionaire give a TED talk. And what this complacent literature purrs into their ears is that creativity is their property, their competitive advantage, their class virtue. Creativity is what they bring to the national economic effort, these books reassure them — and it’s also the benevolent doctrine under which they rightly rule the world.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agosneer smeared smoothly - have a point
- AJ007 13y agoHow do you measure innovation? Stating that the rate of innovation is dropping seems about as ambiguous as saying that morality is decaying. What the hell does it mean? The cost to performance ratio of computing is increasing at an exponential rate, e.g. the human genome project. We have DNA printing that likely is going the same way too. There is software for compiling DNA (Genome Compiler.) I find this both extraordinarily innovative as well as increasing in at an exponential rate. Humans like to copy each other. So, rock and roll in 1965 may have seemed wonderfully innovative. If you had listened to it from 1965 until 2013, it may not seem as much anymore. You've "heard it all." Perhaps the same could be said of network TV dramas. Some things appear to innovate in spurts. Take for example the Oculus Rift. Virtual reality headsets, for consumers, were stagnant since the mid 1990s. If you bought one in 2011 it would have been more or less the same as one you bought in 1996. Seems like a huge lack of innovation! Well, now we have the Oculus Rift. It turns out all of this development with mobile phones is directly useful for making virtual reality headsets fast, light, and high resolution. Who would have thought Angry Birds contributed to progress in virtual reality? I think we will see the same thing happen with other industries and products, where for 2 decades nothing interesting happened and then in a matter of months a company produces a game changer using advances in mobile technology, genetics, databases, etc. Now, perhaps someone who looks at the Oculus Rift says, that's not innovative, the concept existed 25 years ago. If that is how we are measuring innovation, it seems both shallow and dismissive of the incredible amounts of labor and creative genius involved. In 1953 Tintin went to the moon in a vertically landing rocket. I would be extremely embarrassed to call Elon Musk not innovative for having a working version of this rocket today. We measure things in such short time spans. Many of the things done have yet to manifest themselves as recognizable solutions for humans. If we look at human history in periods of hundreds of years or thousands of years, the amount of innovation we have seen over the past decade is phenomenal. Should the government be helping? Perhaps. Our larger concern should be innovation that doesn't do irreversible damage to the environment and consequently humans. Often government backed innovation is really about building very destructive weapons, which there is no private market for. If innovation is a little slower in exchange for not ending up with the next nuclear bomb, I won't be complaining.
- VLM 13y ago"How do you measure innovation?" If a MBA has a graph of it showing smooth change fitting a trendline, its not innovative anymore? So something like a graph of NAICS & SIC codes over time, or a graph of folks doing something so new that no code exists so it gets graphed as "other"? Number of people employed by a business less than 10 years old?