8 ms·
Dear Google, Commit Your Broad Patents to a Defensive License
- anon1385 13y agoGoogle use patents offensively when it suits them. They are not on our side. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-13-406_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-13-406_en.htm The European Commission has informed Motorola Mobility of its preliminary view that the company's seeking and enforcing of an injunction against Apple in Germany on the basis of its mobile phone standard-essential patents ("SEPs") amounts to an abuse of a dominant position prohibited by EU antitrust rules
- pavanky 13y ago> The Commission opened the investigation in April 2012. While the process of buying out had begun at this point, it wasn't finalized until May 2012. I am not sure how much "Google" had to do with this decision.
- bsullivan01 13y agoNice one, others did it, not Google. Too bad this notice was published on 6 May 2013. Surely Google had time to stop whatever Motorola was doing until May 2013 but decided not to, even if Google had no hand in pushing Motorola to do this.
- pavanky 13y agoThen use that argument in the first place. Changing the argument to something else when the obvious flaws are pointed out is rather weak.
- air 13y agoI bet Google is very interested in stopping all patent lawsuits between Motorola and Apple, but Apple is not.
- cromwellian 13y agoMotorola, and HTC to some extent, are companies that were on their last legs, almost bankrupt, and the world's most profitable tech company, with half the market, and $150 billion in cash, is engaged in offensive lawsuits against them trying to enact import bans. Who is the bully here? It's like a billionaire punching a street bum in the face, and then whining when the bum fights back ungentlemanly. The two biggest bullies, Apple and Microsoft, have cross-licensing agreements and a behavior of ganging up on Android. I find it absurd that FRAND patents are practically valueless, but "obvious" patents, which are effectively standards essential because wide applicability, are worth billions and import bans. Apple sued HTC over a patent which is a college algorithms homework question, the first strike on the Android was launched by Apple in 2010. I would view all suits against Apple since then, not as trolling, but as an attempt to negotiate a cross-license by forcing them to the table.
- bsullivan01 13y agoIt's like a billionaire punching a street bum in the face, and then whining when the bum fights back ungentlemanly. Very touching, minus the fact that APPL was once almost bankrupt too and that the iPhone, that everyone started copying, really made them that $150 Billion. Care to tell us what Android looked before the iPhone? Oh, it looked like the market leader of that time, Blackberry. http://gizmodo.com/334909/google-android-prototype-in-the-wild?tag=gadgetsandroidhardwareinthewild http://gizmodo.com/334909/google-android-prototype-in-the-wi... I find it absurd that FRAND patents are practically valueless No one forced them to make them FRAND patents. At least they get a cent here or there from every phone on earth.
- pavanky 13y agoThey made good business decisions to make that money. That does not give them the right to become ass holes and claim everything they did was original and exclusive to them. Everything is a copy of a copy of a copy. Some better than others, some different, some identical. It is insane that this shit needs to be patented.
- 13y ago
- devx 13y agoMotorola already started that battle before Google bought them In fact, there were some theories that Google bought Motorola because they were about to attack other Android OEM's, too. I'm sure that's not the only reason, but it probably played a role. I know just weeks before the acquisition was announced, Motorola's CEO implied his intention of going after other Android OEM's.
- bsullivan01 13y agoNow, we understand you may never assert this patent. Given your history, you may only be acquiring it "defensively." This is the same argument as Obama used for the bill allowing indefinite detentions https://www.aclu.org/national-security/president-obama-signs-indefinite-detention-bill-law https://www.aclu.org/national-security/president-obama-signs... without a trial: "I will never use it" or something like that. The point is that it should never exist, what happens next year or five years from now? By the way Google is a convicted patent troll, http://finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-says-wins-patent-trial-004332318.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-says-wins-patent-tri...
- pavanky 13y ago> Though the award was just half of the $29 million in damages Microsoft had sought, the company hailed today’s ruling as a landmark victory “telling Google to stop abusing patents.” But the patent battle predates Google’s 2011 acquisition of Motorola Mobility. Microsoft first sued the phone maker in 2010 for overcharging on patent licensing. Source: http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/04/motorola-versus-microsoft/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/04/motorola-versus-microsoft/ Please try to stop inventing facts. EFF does this thing for a living, I would think they would not miss something as obvious.
- skj 13y agoI see examples, time and time again, of companies (especially Microsoft) twisting facts to make sound-byte-style comments that make Google look bad. However, I cannot think of a single example where Google has done that about any company. Can someone prove me wrong?
- throwawaykf02 13y agoSee the whole "Bing rips off Google's results" thing. No less than Stephen Colbert fell for it and the truth never got as much publicity. People still believe Bing scrapes Google. Interestingly, the whole thing was instigated by Vic Gundotra, who's ex-Microsoft...
- devx 13y agoHow about Microsoft and Apple? Do they get a free pass from this, because they're less likely to do it, so why even bother asking them? I'm not defending Google, and I support EFF's request. I'm just saying this seems to happen quite often. For example, even though Apple was trying to make things better for Foxconn employees, they were actually the ones being targeted and criticized "for not doing enough", a lot more than the other Foxconn customers were.
- devcpp 13y agoThey're the patent trolls we're trying to defend against. Are you also going to ask the NSA to protect people's privacy?
- skore 13y agoIt's not about fairness, it's about trying to find the right point to apply pressure and create a public discussion. Both Apple and Microsoft could not care less about how terrible they are in their (ab)use of patents and they particularly don't care how customers perceive their use of patents. Challenging them gives you a zero percent chance to succeed. In fact, they have a lot of clients and customers who might even cheer them on. In any case, they have spent a lot of time and energy to spin this in the past and they would just repeat that pattern. There is a very tiny chance that you would have success with Google - even if you don't succeed with them directly, you might get the ball rolling on a public discussion. Trying Apple or Microsoft is a surefire way to kill any such discussion very quickly.
- jrockway 13y agoThere are two factors at play. Imagine you want a date. Do you call up your favorite celebrity and ask him or her out? No. You find someone that you like that has a greater than 51% chance of actually saying yes. (OK, it doesn't need to be 51% since you stand to lose less than you could gain. But some mental calculation like that is going on.) The other factor is Internet hype. Try this: write a story involving Google or Apple as the protagonist, submit it to HN or Reddit, and watch as the Internet goes crazy for it. The companies are "hot" now, and merely mentioning them sells newspapers (or pageviews, or Reddit karma, or whatever). If what you're writing is technically true and contains controversy, all the better. The first factor rules out Apple. The second factor rules out Microsoft. And who's left?
- wissler 13y agoI agree with the sentiment but as a publicly owned company it may be considered in breach of duty to stockholders to commit to such a thing. These companies are about only one thing: how much money can we get? If they make good stuff along the way, that's OK, but that is not their purpose. It's a reversal of proper means and ends. In our system, money is the end, creating things is the means. In a proper system, it's the reverse.
- calt 13y agoAnd google is the king of unusual business models. It can be in a company's wallet's best interest to be moral if it drives up sales and trust. I can think of countless companies that exist in the "we're green so buy us" space.
- cromwellian 13y agoOne of the issues is how you define "defensive" purposes. If you are locked in an ecosystem battle with opponents who are fighting on multiple fronts over years (Microsoft shaking down Android vendors, Apple suing to ban and restrict competition), then you yourself may never be sued directly, but your interests are nevertheless, still being attacked indirectly. It's like a Cold War where your client states are fighting it out against other superpowers. Thus, is it "offensive" if Apple sues one of your customers over a stupid patent on phone number extraction via regular expressions, or Microsoft sues over FAT32, and you retaliate by suing them because they built a bill-splitting app into their product? Or must they launch a nuclear missile directly at your capital before you're considered justified in a counter-offensive? The hope I think of asserting these kinds of patents is that mutually assured destruction results in detente. You build up a nuclear arsenal so that it becomes unthinkable by your opponent to attack, and this is undermined if you hold yourself to some kind of pledge never to use them, or never to use them unless your capital is bombed directly. What the EFF is asking for is a nuclear non-proliferation treaty and test ban, but they are asking the weaker player (who has fewer weapons) to give up their weapons and give up making, and not the superpowers.
- bsullivan01 13y agoLet's cut the crap and get to the point: are you saying that the Patent Office should grant a patent for tip splitting to Google? Yes or no? It's sad and hilarious at the same time to see Googlers defend these ridiculous positions as their company shifts strategy every week chasing an extra dollar. Who knows what you'll defend next week. You build up a nuclear arsenal so that it becomes unthinkable by your opponent to attack Redmond and Palo Alto are shaking in their boots, this tab splitting innovation from the smartest people on earth really tipped the balance :-). Apple and Microsoft have been building operating systems and patenting each step of it for 30-40 years. That's why every Android manufacturer bowed to Microsoft
- afsina 13y agoYou would cry if you see those "patents" MS is using for extortion. Most have nothing to do with OS. If any is related, MS is too scared to disclose it because it would be against Linux or Unix (which is around for 40-50 years). http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/02/the-three-patents-microsoft-is-hammering-the-nook-withand-why-they-may-be-invalid/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/02/the-three-patents... http://androidcommunity.com/barnes-noble-reveals-microsofts-android-patents-in-detail-20111114/ http://androidcommunity.com/barnes-noble-reveals-microsofts-...
- javajosh 13y agoWhat is the nature of the EFF's power? Can they harm Google calling them a hypocrite[1][2] if only via reputation or public shaming? Will programmers on certain forums, for example, be less likely to accept a Google position because of Google's patent policies, especially ones that are highlighted by the EFF? Then I think: apart from fearing the mighty EFF's vast and influential power (ha), what other concerns might motivate the patent decision maker at google (whoever that is) to take action in this case? Perhaps they are motivated by the respect of their colleagues. Perhaps they have something I read about in college, called a "conscience", which I was led to believe was a powerful influencer of individual behaviors. Wouldn't that be amazing, if the decision-maker at Google actually told the world that their conscience wouldn't let them take a certain action they believed to be wrong? That would be a massive win, in so many ways, and for so many people. And I, for one, might call back that Google recruiter. [1] http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2013/02/lets-defend-innovators-against-patent.html http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2013/02/lets-defend-i... [2]http://www.geekwire.com/2013/joke-google-seeks-patent-splitting-restaurant-bills/ http://www.geekwire.com/2013/joke-google-seeks-patent-splitt...
- throwawaykf02 13y agoTo be fair, something that gets the extreme cases of bill-splitting right probably deserves a patent, if not a Nobel. After all, Bistromathics is the most powerful computational force known to parascience...