3 ms·
I have a different view of '+1'. I see it more like an indicator that I like something, to be seen by the people who make the thing I like, so they know it's go
by barrkel 13y ago
I have a different view of '+1'. I see it more like an indicator that I like something, to be seen by the people who make the thing I like, so they know it's good. I don't particularly want to share that with anyone.
- oakwhiz 13y agoThis is interesting because I think way too many different meanings are attributed to a single social action. If someone posts a good news story about a current event that you disagree with, should you like or dislike the news story? A lot of HN folks would probably like (or upvote) the story, but some people, especially in other communities like YouTube, have a reversed view on this, and will use the dislike button to express a negative emotion even if they actually thought the video was good. For this reason I'm actually surprised that significant advertising value can be mined from data about +1s and likes. I wonder if we need more expressive "single-button" social interactions, like some kind of hybrid between tags and likes. At the very least, some kind of way to express to the computer, and to friends, that you want to promote some piece of content (or censor it) while simultaneously disagreeing/agreeing with the idea presented in the content.
- bsullivan01 13y agoFor this reason I'm actually surprised that significant advertising value can be mined from data about +1s and likes. The value might be just to get the person to click on an ad, and pad up this quarter's revenue, right before Christmas. Of course if ad clicks go up, unpaid traffic from unbiased Google goes down even more.
- riquito 13y agoAren't you misinterpreting the effect of +1? +1 makes publicly available the fact that you like something, so you are saying "I want to share with the world that I like this thing"
- barrkel 13y agoIf I want to share something with the world, I'll post it on twitter, facebook, my blog, the off-topic mailing list at work, or another relevant forum for sharing with the people I think may be interested in that thing. There is no context, zero, wherein I want to share anything with everyone; and I'm certainly not going to categorize contacts into "circles" etc. FTR, I think I've clicked on +1 buttons perhaps three times, and all of them were in Google Reader. That also had a sharing feature, which is the thing I used when I wanted to share the article. Mostly I used the +1 to add to the existing like count for any given article - and as I said, that wasn't often. In so far as +1 is for sharing, that's how much I don't use it.