4 ms·
DUPE: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6467431 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6467431 I feel my comments still stand: Ugh. So many problems: 1. It'
by FireBeyond 13y ago
DUPE: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6467431 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6467431
I feel my comments still stand:
Ugh. So many problems:
1. It's a violation of "Kickstarter cannot be used to fund e-commerce, business, and social networking websites or apps."
2. This is a website, right? Then why: "Travel to the eleven biggest bike cities in the United States to meet with shop owners and give them the ability to register bikes for free (the cities: NYC, San Francisco, Portland, Seattle, Philadelphia, Madison, Tucson, Austin, Denver, D.C., and Minneapolis)."
(Awesome, let's use Kickstarter to pay for me/us to take a trip through the US "to meet with bike shop owners and give them a chance to use the website"...)
3. "Offer region specific recommendations for reporting bike theft to the police." - so an extended goal of this site is to "recommend how to report to the police, customized for regions"?!?
4. Some stickers.
5. Oh, and you have to pay to register with the Index.
And they seriously want $50K for this?
Sorry for the cynicism... but this is a website, some stickers, and a tour of the US for the founders.
(I mean, the 'stretch goal' is effectively, 'we get to go on an even bigger tour to, huh, tell bike shops about our website')...
- mjolk 13y agoHow is this worse than other Kickstarter projects? (serious question, this seems as legit as any to me)
- FireBeyond 13y agoActually, on reading the updated Kickstarter project, I feel I need to amend point 3, the "region specific recommendations" of the stretch goal are "send us to even more places around the US to talk there".
- colmvp 13y ago1. It's a violation of "Kickstarter cannot be used to fund e-commerce, business, and social networking websites or apps." Diaspora was a social network.
- FireBeyond 13y agoSo Kickstarter is bad, and by all means getting worse, at enforcing their own TOS, as advertised. Does this make the point any less true? I understand that it's hard to derail a popular project that may violate your TOS when it's also generating you a commission on every dollar of backing.
- na85 13y agoNot to mention it won't prevent crime at all. Lots of people will buy stolen bikes off craigslist, knowing they're stolen. Others who are in doubt will still buy stolen bikes off craigslist because they will never learn about this niche website. And thieves can just file off the serial no.
- sethherr 13y agoI don't think many people buying bikes on craigslist want to get a stolen bike. Bikes are stolen because they're easy to sell - check out the link someone posted here earlier: http://blog.priceonomics.com/post/30393216796/what-happens-to-stolen-bicycles http://blog.priceonomics.com/post/30393216796/what-happens-t... Rather than try to make bike theft profitable - you'd prefer to just say it won't work and give up?
- sethherr 13y ago1. We're a staff pick and were project of the day last week, so they don't think we're violating their terms of service. 2. The whole point is to make registration convenient by having bike shops register bikes for their customers. We need to talk to the bike shops to do this. 3. The actual quote: "location specific advice for responding to bike theft." Have you ever reported a bike stolen? In Chicago you have to call at 2am to get someone who will take the report, and if you don't have a serial number you have to call a few times until you get an operator who will report it. More importantly we want to tell people about what they can legally do if they encounter a stolen bike - and how they can repossess it. 4. That was a reward created because someone asked for it. Sorry that you don't like it? 5. YOU WILL ALWAYS BE ABLE TO GET FREE REGISTRATION
- FireBeyond 13y ago1. And there was a "buy my kid a laptop and send her to a summer camp" Kickstarter that made all sorts of headlines and, despite being blatantly against the TOS, they kept up. I'm sure the percentage of fees they kept had nothing to do with that decision (or the possibility of PR). Regardless, their TOS pretty clearly says "no business or social websites". 2. How many bike shops do you think you can cover in your tour? How many orders of magnitude more effective do you think your site would be if that money was instead invested in other promotional means, rather than visiting a dozen bike shops in a dozen cities, for example? 3. If police are so over-worked in a jurisdiction that that's how you have to contact them to file a report (versus the hundreds or thousands of municipalities that allow online report filing), what makes anyone think that giving them the ability to view a stolen bike report on your website is going to be more effective? I'm also relatively certain that a third party who encounters an /allegedly/ stolen bike has no real option to "repossess it". 4. You're right, I don't have to like it. And maybe if you get to $200,000 of funding, /that/ stretch goal can be "our team of eight will visit one bike store in every one of the 289 US cities with a population of over 100,000". It's quite close to the least effective possibly imaginable method of promoting such a service. You could take out full page ads in multiple bike magazines, sponsor events, and the like. But that might mean your team doesn't get to go on a road trip from San Francisco to New England. 5. If registration is $6.99 for me to do it myself, or go to a bike shop and do it for free (something I probably do regularly as a bicyclist), where is any incentive to do so? Or, as you mention POS integration, perhaps it's only free if you do it when you buy a bike. Or "if it's already stolen" (better hope you already wrote down the serial), somewhat edge cases.
- ethomson 13y agoSo, I'm still not sold on this idea, mostly because this is a huge problem and you're going to have to hit every link in the chain: the sellers of new bikes, the consumers of new bikes, the sellers of used bikes, the consumers of used (or stolen) bikes, the police... If this idea has a hope of working, it will be because they were able to get a critical mass of people on board. This will require travel, face time, salesmanship, etc. Point #2 seems not unreasonable to me.
- FireBeyond 13y agoWhat infinitesimal proportion of bike shops do you think a team of eight can cover with less than $50,000 of funding, to achieve said 'critical mass'? Versus, say, manufacturer outreach, Facebook and Google advertising, event sponsorship, magazine ads?
- sethherr 13y agoWe're already doing all the above (except magazine ads, which we're working on).