3 ms·
You're basically talking about inserting a fraudulent transaction into the blockchain. Even if 99% of nodes included that transaction, the remaining 1% of nodes
by erikpukinskis 13y ago
You're basically talking about inserting a fraudulent transaction into the blockchain. Even if 99% of nodes included that transaction, the remaining 1% of nodes would still reject it and build off the longest chain without it. This is different than a double spend where if 51% of the network starts building off an alternate chain, it will eventually surpass the 49% chain in length and then the 49% will switch over and the transaction will be canon.
That said, there's nothing stopping any number of miners (51%, 1%, it doesn't matter) from forking the Bitcoin protocol and declaring that the transaction is, in fact, valid. This is equivalent to creating a whole separate currency with the Bitcoin wallets as a starting point. It would just slowly diverge from Bitcoin.
I just don't see that kind of thing happening. People think Bitcoin is software, but it's really just a contract between people. And it only has value to the extent that people stick to the rules. The reason things went so smoothly during the 0.7/0.8 fork is that everyone just wanted to stick with the spirit of the contract, and it was pretty clear that that meant reverting to the 0.7 chain and fixing the incompatibility.
Basically, Bitcoin is rules. You can change the rules, but that's not changing Bitcoin it's just creating something new. In programming terms, Bitcoin is immutable. You can create a modified copy of it but you cant change it.