3 ms·
> Almost none of this is true if the operating system allows you to provide a write-only layer – you'd be limited to the operations which the GPU can perform wi
by JoshTriplett 13y ago
> Almost none of this is true if the operating system allows you to provide a write-only layer – you'd be limited to the operations which the GPU can perform without the browser seeing the bits but that would address the needs of most sites at or better than the current plugin situation.
Leaving aside the other fundamental problems of having a required proprietary component, this still isn't true. Browsers don't currently allow sites to use third-party images as WebGL textures without permission from those sites, because there are any number of ways to run transformations on those textures that will reveal information about them.
Exactly the same issue would apply to rendering DRMed content: if the site can composite that content, it can analyze that content and figure out what it contains.
- acdha 13y ago> Browsers don't currently allow sites to use third-party images as WebGL textures The quote included specifically addressed that point: “you'd be limited to the operations which the GPU can perform without the browser seeing the bits” Just as browsers have limits about how plugins interact with the rest of the page, it's quite easy to imagine analogous restrictions on how a restricted layer could be composited or tainting the rest of the page to prevent read-back operations. Again, the fact that everyone from users to content providers seems to be satisifed with the Silverlight status quo shows that this is not technically impossible because it's already in daily use by millions of people.
- JoshTriplett 13y ago> The quote included specifically addressed that point: “you'd be limited to the operations which the GPU can perform without the browser seeing the bits” It doesn't matter if the browser can see the bits directly. If the browser can supply GPU operations that manipulate the bits, the browser can infer the contents of the bits in umpteen different ways.
- acdha 13y agoWhich, under the normal definitions in standard English, is “seeing the bits”.