3 ms·
"You're assuming that the only way to compromise a computer is through a direct internet connection." I'm assuming the exact opposite. I recognize, as does Sc
by notacoward 13y ago
"You're assuming that the only way to compromise a computer is through a direct internet connection."
I'm assuming the exact opposite. I recognize, as does Schneier, that infection can occur without such a connection. Any mechanism that facilitates transfer of data also facilitates infection. That includes USB sticks and CD-Rs, which have the additional problem of leaving artifacts around for others to pick up later. It's the "we can secure USB sticks better than we can secure networks" belief that's magical.
"Only by physically denying the infection the means to spread can you protect against it."
As soon as you physically move a USB stick from one machine to another, you've effectively created a network. A really crappy one with high latency, but that doesn't make it any more secure as you yourself illustrate with the diskette example.
- mseebach 13y agoA network connection, even brief has an enormous attack surface. The corresponding surface when using physical media is much smaller.
- notacoward 13y agoBull. A network connection on a physically separate network subject to proper inspection/monitoring has a very small attack surface. The corresponding attack surface for a USB stick is larger, with new exploits being discovered every day. The separate switch is functionally identical to the USB stick. They both allow transfer of data. They can both potentially be attack vectors. They both (in this construction) require manual intervention to complete the data path. The only difference is that it's a lot easier to get a copy of someone's data on a USB stick, after someone conveniently recorded their data transfer on a readily purloined bit of media. You can't acknowledge the exploits that have occurred via diskettes or USB sticks, and then also say they're fundamentally better than an isolated network. It's illogical. In fact, it's stupid.