3 ms·
Can anyone actually prove that forcing everyone to identify themselves would cut off trolling? Everyone seems to take that as given, but I don't see the evidenc
by jerf 17y ago
Can anyone actually prove that forcing everyone to identify themselves would cut off trolling? Everyone seems to take that as given, but I don't see the evidence. Especially if you define "trolling" large enough to include things like merely being anti-social, or being voluminous, or just anything in general that would make you not want to be online.
You might cut down on the trolling, but merely, say, cutting it in half isn't going to change anything.
- evgen 17y agoIt is actually kind of simple really. If you have fixed identity (or even psuedonyms that are tied to a "true name" a la Chaumian credentials) then filtering out bad behavior becomes easier. Users cannot create sock puppets, they get one chance to troll and then join the global killfile or get put a sufficient number of user killfiles as to have the same effect. If the identity was non-pseudonymous or the pseudonym systems supported cross-domain joins it would get even harder to troll since a trolling attempt at site A might get you added to user filters at sites B and C. The trolls would not go away, but no one would ever see them and this would have the same effect.