6 ms·
The core Internet institutions abandon the US Government
- a3n 13y agoA good thing. The US has squandered its right to lead.
- chimeracoder 13y agoWho says that any single governing national body should ever have the right to be an all-but-unchecked international leader, the way the US has?
- a3n 13y agoTo the extent that the US provided technical leadership, resources, stability and benevolent dictatorship, they could hope for the community following them as the best alternative. There is no longer any basis for such hope or expectation. It's probably been a long time coming, and too bad it had to happen the way it did, but that seems to be the way these days in so many areas of US "leadership." We can't be trusted.
- justanother 13y agoThis. We nurtured it, we funded it, and as recently as WCIT-12, I personally had zero desire for international governance, as many other countries have some very 'non-open' ideas about what to do with the Internet. But, as it turns out, so do we.
- sologoub 13y agoExactly the point though, towards the end of the article, they lament the fact that instead of an open and somewhat self-regulating environment, we are getting more "political oversight". Political oversight is seldom effective, especially when you try to honor the rhetoric that everyone must be on equal footing. With such a plurality of stakeholders, any consensus is extremely difficult to achieve. Instead, you often end-up with a bunch of half-measures and nuisance regulations. In my own ideal world, governments and their regulations stay within their borders and the "Internet" as a pseudo-entity is not regulated in any way.
- tokenizer 13y agoWhile this is necessary knowing what we now know. I really hope it isn't continued by the UN as a tool for the countries with worse human rights violations.
- jafaku 13y agoWould you mind using a stronger font/color? This is unreadable for me.
- tux 13y agoYeah that exactly what I thought. Could not even read first sentence of that page. Even after zooming the page ^_^
- gcb1 13y agoat least you can zoom. death to all lazy slobs who just cancel zoom on mobile instead of doing his/her work.
- aethertap 13y agoIf you have a javascript console handy, this helped for me: document.getElementsByClassName('content')[0].style.font="14pt arial bold"
- bengtan 13y agoFor Firefox, goto View => Page Style => No Style
- Draiken 13y agoSaying Dilma Rousseff "has been intensely critical of the US government and the NSA spying program" is a big overstatement. Regardless, let's hope this segregation happens and the internet can get a little bit of freedom from the greedy hands of the US Government.
- gcb1 13y agothe day snowden announced that a bazilian company (vale) was spied she cancelled a trip to washington if no official explanation was given before her visit. on her latest UN adress, which btw was right before obama's, she ended with strong criticism and call to action about the program.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- speeder 13y agoShe cancelled US visits and contracts. Complained on the UN assembly. And even raged on twitter (yes, raged on twitter, teenager style). How that is not being intensely critical?
- Draiken 13y agoThat's showing off as a critical. Nothing was DONE. A lot was said. If she had actually taken action against it, I'd buy it. She didn't and she won't, so I (and you should too) assume that's just propaganda. At least in Brazil it's how every politician plays the game.
- generj 13y agoI guess hoping for a dramatic dismantling of Bluffdale and Clapper's arrest on perjury charges was always unrealistic. In reality, we've already started to win. Jewel v. NSA, rather than being dismissed under executive privilege and placed into the realm of "paranoid nutjobs" is proceeding strongly, as are a multitude of other lawsuits with strong merit. There's been a renewed interest in stronger systems, which will ultimately be the only way to prevent against surveillance. After all, policy changes only are secure and trustworthy of the government that makes them. The transfer of Internet institutional power away from the US is just another step, even if it's probably a bit less useful than you might suppose, given that every major technological power has also participated in similar surveillance schemes. So while I still wish for political reform in the short-term, I am continually re-assured by other efforts which will solve this issue in the long-run. So long as we don't forget about this issue, it will be solved one way or another.
- curiousdannii 13y agoWhat differences will this make now?
- gcb1 13y agogood point. the article is thin on this topic. my guess is that latin countries will have a local exchange instead, which is about damn time to be honest. which happens regardless of that meeting...
- tptacek 13y agoInsofar as the Internet is an "entity" with any of the kind of agency that would allow it to "abandon" anything, it is governed by telcos, 5-6 major US Internet companies, and the content industry.
- mrleinad 13y agoBrazil's government (and UNASUR as well) is pushing for building connectivity for all of South America, excluding the USA, so all information flows between countries without going through US companies.
- a-priori 13y agoAs a Canadian, I wish this were possible for us. Virtually all of our Internet traffic, even to hosts in other parts of Canada, go through American territory. I'm not sure if it would even be possible to route our traffic around the US.
- atlanticus 13y agoApparently you are not aware that Canada is part of the five eyes. If you are then I don't know what to tell you.
- a-priori 13y agoI am aware, and that's something I've voiced my concerns about with my MP, but I don't see anything changing under our current government. But even if we weren't, it would be possible for American agencies to intercept Canadian traffic without any sort of due procedure.
- atlanticus 13y agoYou have no responsibility to take to the streets to protest the evils of the Canadian government as long as you can blame the Americans.
- iambateman 13y agoThis is a graphic explaining "who runs the internet": http://www.icann.org/sites/default/files/assets/governance-2500x1664-21mar13-en.png http://www.icann.org/sites/default/files/assets/governance-2... I don't think we fumbled our right to lead. Internet standards are bigger than the US. This is good, imho.
- atlanticus 13y agoThe more that people buy into the idea that the only problem is the US the easier it is for the entire West to continue with business as usual, regardless of election time posturing by EU nations.
- walshemj 13y agoah more jollies/meetings in hard to get to 3 world dictatorships so that "civilians" cant hold ICANT to account.
- dlitz 13y agoHopefully, this will just involve transferring the governing authority away from the U.S. government without changing how the IETF/IANA are actually operated. It would be bad if the traditional, international standards-setting organizations (e.g. ITU, ISO, ECMA, IEEE, etc.) ended up gaining control over the IETF/IANA, and they've been eying for it for some time now.
- mcguire 13y agoMany HN readers may support this action (heck, me, too), but this is a ridiculous article. "...turned their back on the US government..." "...he conspired with her to convene a global meeting..." The "major Internet organizations" have about as much organization as a room full of cats. Don't expect this important action to actually mean much. Except possibly for a new herd of top-level domains, useful primarily to extort money from trademark owners.
- suprgeek 13y agoI guess everyone is getting tired of the Arrogance and heavy-handedness of the NSA. Arrogance - We (NSA) will sabotage, undermine and subvert legitimate efforts at security because we need the ability to Snoop on everybody. Thus making the Internet Unsafe for everybody else as well only to suit their paranoid needs. Heavy-Handed: We will store all communications that we get get our hands on either directly or thru foreign lap-dog governments(Five eyes). The rights of Americans other nationals and everybody else be dammed. About time some one held their feet to the fire for this nonsense. Snowden should be given the Nobel Prize for Human rights (A new category that needs to be set up)
- snowwrestler 13y agoI find this article to be pretty overwrought. NSA efforts have focused on exploiting applications, weakening encryption standards, and subverting telcos and big hosted service providers. None of those are managed by Internet governance bodies. Altering the internal structure of ICANN would not inhibit NSA activities one bit. The revelations of NSA spying have pissed off a lot of other countries, and no doubt increased their desire to splinter the Internet into a federation of national networks, which would be easier for them to each respectively control. That would help them protect from NSA spying... but it would also give them greater capability to control every other aspect of Internet access. This is the approach that was rejected at the ITU, and recall that we all cheered that result. I think it's interesting that this article describes the values of freedom and democracy as cherished by the U.S. Aren't they cherished by all people? Who doesn't want to be free? There is a group of people who don't cherish those values, and those are the leaders of national governments that are known to be oppressive, censorious, or both. Would China really be a better steward of "Internet values" than the U.S.? I don't think so.