2 ms·
That's not actually tagging. Maybe it's a namespace standard.
by joshu 17y ago
That's not actually tagging. Maybe it's a namespace standard.
- csbartus 17y agoNo, it is semantic tagging based on RDF, stored on semantic databases like Freebase and DBpedia. Practically your tags will be part of an universally shared, searchable database ... that's the real time data web baby! :D
- sp332 17y agoIt is tagging, using RDFa. The "new standard" in the headline has a new semantic namespace, but the cool part is a new XML namespace, with a nicer way of writing RDFa tags. Example: <body xmlns:ctag="http://commontag.org/ns# rel="ctag:tagged"> <span typeof="ctag:Tag" rel="ctag:means" resource="http://dbpedia/resource/Twitter /> <span typeof="ctag:Tag" rel="ctag:means" resource="http://rdf.freebase.com/ns/en/web_2_0 /> </body> This relates your page semantically to the concepts "Web 2.0" and "Twitter". Better explanation: http://faviki.wordpress.com/2009/06/11/common-tag-is-released/ http://faviki.wordpress.com/2009/06/11/common-tag-is-release...
- joshu 17y agoI understand the spec. I understand what RDFa is. It's still not tagging. Tagging is a UI and organizational conceit. A minimal way to attach a nickname for a class of things to a new thing to classify it, such that users are actually able to use it, and to feedback the list of used nicknames so as to encourage convergence. Given that I made up the term in the first place, I'm pretty sure I'm right here.
- sp332 17y agoSome tagging sites are using it, Zigtag for example. What is the relationship between Common Tag and tagging? Or are they unrelated?
- DocSavage 17y agoThen there'd be two ways to view the word "tagging." One is the UI and organization style you popularized through del.icio.us. The other is the common English gerund of "to tag", which is the way Common Tag is using it. Maybe it would have been better for them to call it Common Label... Re: common "tags" through a shared namespace -- seems like it'd be a good thing to do and would increase the relevancy of our stuff to search engines. Would Google actively support Common Tag or does Google support it naturally through RDF indexing? This approach also reminds me to review the debates on Ontology. http://www.peterme.com/archives/000558.html http://www.peterme.com/archives/000558.html I would like to implement some kind of semantic marking for the data on my web site. If not Common Tag, what's the best way to say "this is an Author who has written that" or "this is regarding the Terminator movie (1984) directed by Cameron..."?
- joshu 17y agoRDF or RDFa plus any of the myriad schemas that are available. You would use Dublin Core for the first, and you could reference the IMDB URI space for the second. Commontag does not appear to do these things.
- DocSavage 17y agoCommon Tag uses RDFa so I'm confused (bear with me) on your objection to the scheme. The use of Freebase and DBPedia makes sense since all of their data is under relatively open license, unlike IMDB.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"This relates your page semantically to the concepts "Web 2.0" and "Twitter"." I'm sorry, but no, it doesn't do anything resembling "semantics". Some background for why I say this is here: http://www.reddit.com/r/web_design/comments/8ly99/ask_web_design_who_started_myth_about_xhtml_being/c09tfp9 http://www.reddit.com/r/web_design/comments/8ly99/ask_web_de...
- Tichy 17y agoIt just looks horrible. I think all this is too complicated, which is also the reason that semantic web failed. How is it suppose in the UI? Instead of just typing my tags, am I supposed to search for the appropriate tags first? It is an interesting problem how to get people to tag correctly, but I don't see how a standard would help? Also, I think modern search engines are capable of discovering that "NY" and "New York" mean the same thing.