3 ms·
> Alter and Oppenheimer disagree But they're not the ones who can decide whether subsequent studies replicated their findings or not! It's up to the scientific
by bambax 13y ago
> Alter and Oppenheimer disagree
But they're not the ones who can decide whether subsequent studies replicated their findings or not! It's up to the scientific community as a whole to decide.
The problem is, no one is really interested in replicating earlier findings, and even less in invalidating them. What people want is produce new and interesting (unexpected, curious) results that gets the authors noticed.
Many such studies never get replicated (see the famous one about how talking to students about old age makes them walk slower), and nobody cares.
So this part of Gladwell's response is even more disingenuous than the rest.