4 ms·
Any time we see a phenomenon breaking down along gender or race lines, when skin color and genitals are not involved, that's a red flag that people are being ex
by sliverstorm 13y ago
Any time we see a phenomenon breaking down along gender or race lines, when skin color and genitals are not involved, that's a red flag that people are being excluded for silly reasons.
Well that's a sweeping statement if I ever saw one. Are you prepared to stand behind it? I'll give you a moment to reconsider.
Edit: Seriously, you all believe that any time there is a gender disparity not involving genitals, it is happening for "silly reasons"? There is not one job where gender-related phenotypes might naturally result in skewed distribution?
- TeMPOraL 13y agoI have to agree with you here (mostly with the edit). Differences between genders do not boil down to just the shape of the genitals; there are significant physical and psychological differences, so it is only to be expected that there will be gender disparities occuring. It seems to me that the very talk about sexism is starting to be a "silly reason" for changing things.
- sliverstorm 13y agoYeah, I admit the comment pre-edit was pretty snarky. The edit expanded on what I was referring to.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoThere are certainly differences between the sexes beyond genitals. But that's not the hypothesis that's being pushed. The hypothesis being pushed is "the percentage of programmers is skewed because of genetic differences between men and women" The trouble is no evidence, nor can I even imagine a study that could gather evidence, which could validate that hypothesis over this one: "the percentage of programmers is skewed because of differences in how men and women are treated" Maybe you don't care about having scientific evidence for your belief and it's coming from elsewhere. I respect that... I think there are lots of valid ways of knowing and I'd be excited to hear about yours. But my strategy is to assume different "kinds" of people are equivalent unless there is some scientifically sound evidence to the contrary. And there is simply no solid evidence that genetic differences between men and women (or different races) are a factor in the kinds of distribution differences that we're talking about. Some people like to chain together a set of very tenuous conclusions from very shaky studies to support that idea, but for me as a scholar it just doesn't hold water.
- sliverstorm 13y agoBut that's not the hypothesis that's being pushed. The hypothesis being pushed is... Please. That is not the hypothesis that is being pushed. Nowhere did I argue if there are gender disparities, it is because of gender differences. I was specifically objecting to the opposite notion, if there are gender disparities, it cannot possibly be because of gender differences. The scholar in you ought to understand that distinction, and why it is important if we are to have a logical discussion...
- erikpukinskis 13y ago> if there are gender disparities, it cannot possibly be because of gender differences. That's not what I said at all. I said if there are gender disparities that's a red flag. Red flag, meaning we should go and check and see what's going on because something is fishy.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoI used the term "red flag" very intentionally. I'll give you a moment to reconsider.