2 ms·
This piece was written by Gladwell in response to Chabris. Between the two of them, Chabris, as a PhD holder and tenured professor, clearly has the higher groun
by snowwrestler 13y ago
This piece was written by Gladwell in response to Chabris. Between the two of them, Chabris, as a PhD holder and tenured professor, clearly has the higher ground when it comes to understanding the science in question.
Yes, Gladwell mentions Alter and Oppenheimer in his writing, but remember that the knock against Gladwell is that he selectively brandishes science when it suits his narrative. He's just doing that again here.
The fundamental complaint from Chabris is that Gladwell did not even acknowledge the existence of any controversy on this subject in his book. He simply picked the study he liked best and wrote about it as if it were fact.