2 ms·
Bullshit does drive thinking people away. The assorted levels of BS I've seen did convince me to be far more skeptical of climate change. I assigned a high prob
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Bullshit does drive thinking people away. The assorted levels of BS I've seen did convince me to be far more skeptical of climate change. I assigned a high probability to the AGW hypothesis when I started grad school, but was well below 95% confident when I graduated, and have become even more skeptical since then.
Bits of shadiness that have pushed me away:
- When I started reading papers on climate simulation (I was also solving wave equations numerically), I started seeing wildly unjustified assumptions in climate modelling papers. In spite of the obvious flaws, the models are portrayed as highly accurate rather than merely the best than can be done on current hardware [1]. This reduced my confidence by a bit.
- Odd claims about the validity of the models. GCM models + economic analysis suggests that the cheapest method of mitigating climate change is geoengineering (specifically, using human engineered pinatubo-style forcings). Yet geoengineering is dismissed as wildly unpredictable. Either GCM is an effective model, or it's not. If not, we have no counterfactual to compare to the historical record.
- Climategate. That's not how science is done. Yet rather than cleaning house, double checking everything and forcing the perpetrators out in disgrace, everyone rallied around them. That feels more like politics than science.
This paper is just using models and getting headlines. It's not a big deal. But throwing nonsense at people in an effort to get them to accept your claims is a bad idea, particularly when the primary argument is an argument from authority.
[1] Making unrealistic assumptions and doing the best you can is just a part of science. I object only to portraying toy models as the real world.