9 ms·
This Bird Can Stay in Flight for Six Months Straight
- mikektung 13y agoSeems like this would make for a great model for long endurance UAVs
- tfgg 13y agoMake the UAVs refuel by eating insects in the air?
- toomuchtodo 13y agoOr ride thermals.
- netcan 13y agoDon't be silly. UAVs eat micro-USVs.
- cadab 13y agoFrom the study[1] here is an image[2] of the comparison between flying, gliding and resting. [1]http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/full/ncomms3554.html http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/full/nco... [2]http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/carousel/ncomms3554-f6.jpg http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/carousel... Edit. Its a shame there no technical details of the sensor, I'd be interested in seeing how a device like this kept functioning over a year.
- unwind 13y agoIt only takes ones reading every four minutes, which probably pushes the duty cycle for the processor and sensor chips down enough to make the energy budget. Assuming a slow 3 seconds for each cycle of "wake up, initialize sensor, take a reading, store it to flash, set timer, go to sleep", that's a duty cycle of 1.3% which is pretty nice.
- swamp40 13y ago> "wake up, initialize sensor, take a reading, store it to flash, set timer, go to sleep" Actually, you can do all that in about 30ms. Less, if you just save to RAM and then only write to flash when you have filled up your buffer.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pscsbs 13y agoScientists generally don't want their data stored in volatile memory. If something goes wrong, they lose valuable data points.
- ramchip 13y agoIf something goes wrong, the rest of the dataset will be missing anyway. I don't think it matters much if 25000 points are missing or 25100.
- swamp40 13y agoYou can't typically write just 1 byte into flash - you have to write in pages of say 4KB. And writing to flash is painfully slow. So it's most efficient (current-wise) to store up 4KB worth of data in RAM and then write it all to flash in one fell swoop. It's a tradeoff with data security, but I think it's a good tradeoff because only rarely will things go wrong, but the additional current burn is guaranteed and constant if you write every datapoint to flash. Magnetic FRAM is making a comeback just to scratch some of these low-power itches. It's faster, uses less power, and has greater write endurance. TI even put it in one of their latest MSP430's.
- unwind 13y agoI know, that's why I said "slow". :) I wanted to aim for a very "bad" estimate, just to make the point more clearly: the duty cycle is low for this system.
- nether 13y agoThere could be a tiny pendulum generator, like in watches.
- fhars 13y agoThe large chip on the image seems to have a number starting with 16F (or maybe 18F), so it seems to be some PIC microcontroler in a 20QFN package. The other two black objects on the board seem to be the accelerometer and light sensor, there are loads of these available in these sizes from your favorite parts suppliers. According to the (german) page https://pdb.bfh.ch/search/pdbwebviewdetail.aspx?lang=de&projectid=a67b3c0b-a09d-4bc7-bc4c-ea25a9778cab&instId=3898707e-4722-4b93-9c06-c0a2784a7ab1 https://pdb.bfh.ch/search/pdbwebviewdetail.aspx?lang=de&proj... they are currently working on a next version that does also include air pressure and magnet field measurements.
- samatman 13y agoI almost hesitate to say it, but I did read the article hoping to find the average airspeed velocity of a slightly-laden European-African swift. I feel as though the BBC would have included this important information.
- wikiburner 13y agoSlightly related, but here's a recent article on a "Drone That Can Fly Continuously For 5 Years". I think this was submitted recently and didn't take off, but it's pretty interesting: http://lasvegas.cbslocal.com/2013/10/07/aerospace-company-develops-drone-that-can-fly-continuously-for-5-years/ http://lasvegas.cbslocal.com/2013/10/07/aerospace-company-de...
- antsar 13y agoWorth noting: The tags only collect data every four minutes, so it’s impossible to rule out the chance that they touched down occasionally in between these intervals—but every single one of the data points collected for more than six months in a row indicated that, at the time, they were either actively flying or at least gliding in the air.
- moron4hire 13y ago"For more than 200 straight days straight" as opposed to 200 straight days on the sauce?
- alphakappa 13y ago(Note, this is just a critique, not criticism of some obviously painstaking research) It would be good to see the results after these experiments get peer-reviewed and replicated. Without just the information presented, it's possible to imagine issues. For example, data is collected every four minutes (We don't know for how long, but let's assume that it's for a few seconds to conserve power). Is it possible that when they are on the ground, they aren't completely still - will their motion on the ground be mischaracterized as flight? It would be great if an altitude sensor could be practically added to the sensor package.
- rtkwe 13y agoPressure sensors don't really give a good measure of altitude from one sample. For starters weather can drastically change the pressure in a region. If a sensor package could somehow filter that out with a 4 minute sample rate (doubtful) then the sensor is still giving you altitude relative to sea level which means the data would have to have a GPS component to differentiate between on the ground on a tall hill or flying over a flat lowlands area.
- alphakappa 13y agoYou're right. So how else could this problem be solved given the power constraints? (P.S. I do have to mention - It's very likely that my critique is completely invalid because they may have performed measurements of these birds in flight Vs. these birds on ground, and the accel data may show completely different characteristics for both. It's also likely that they may have chosen the sampling rate and data duration based on these experiments, but since this is HN, it's fun to speculate on how this experiment could be improved.)
- fhars 13y agoSomebody else posted a link to this graph from the publications that shows results for different movement patterns actually observed while the birds were in the summer colony: http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/carousel/ncomms3554-f6.jpg http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/carousel...
- 205guy 13y agoLike others, the tech is really promising, and it would be useful to have more info. I also think it's fascinating how the advanced tech is allowing scientists to gain more insight into the animal behaviors that are all around us, yet still unknown. Another migratory bird feat is the Pacific golden plover[1] that fly from Alaska and Siberia to Hawaii and New Zealand over several days. The incredible thing is that after raising their young in the north, the parents fly south without them. The young birds fly south by themselves and find the islands by themselves (presumably). There is much unkown about this migration, and these sensors would be very helpful. [1] http://www.kilaueapoint.org/education/naturefocus/hnf3/index.html http://www.kilaueapoint.org/education/naturefocus/hnf3/index...
- nether 13y agoThis is a HUGE outlier among birds capable of long endurance flight, if the data turn out to be accurate. The Alpine Swift is tiny, 2-ft wingspan and 0.2-lb weight. In contrast, the Albatross stretches its wings to 12 ft and weighs 20 lb, and can fly for up to a few days straight (longest known endurance). Similar for the Condor and Stork. The large wingspan minimizes induced drag and lets it glide extremely efficiently, just like the U-2. As bird wingspans decrease, flapping frequency increases and flight endurance decreases, as with pigeons, hummingbirds, and flying insects. Aerodynamically, flight is vastly less efficient at smaller scales because the air molecules remain the same size. There are physical justifications for long-endurance birds being huge, just as there are with long-endurance aircraft. Data collection seems highly suspect. Collecting v_dot every 4 minutes seems insufficient for takeoffs/landings that probably take a few seconds. I wonder if this polling rate satisfies the Nyquist criterion for typical acceleration changes of the bird? Then they mention relying on the pitch angle to determine flight. How clear is this correlation? Birds attain pos/neg pitch in climbs and dives. They adjust their pitch on the ground as they walk, while picking up bits to build nests, and ducking down to feed their young. I look forward to seeing this undergo peer review as alphakappa mentions. This type of flight seems very unusual, but perhaps they manage to feed off insects enough to sustain themselves.
- interstitial 13y agoSince I know practically nothing of birds in depth, how do they sleep during these extended flights? Or is bird "sleep" something different?
- otterley 13y agoCompletely guessing here, but I suppose it's the same sort of involuntary control you have over your body during sleep that keeps you from wetting yourself or rolling off the bed in the middle of the night.
- Someone 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleep_(non-human)#Birds http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleep_(non-human)#Birds: "A peculiarity that birds share with aquatic mammals, and possibly also with certain species of lizards (opinions differ about that last point), is the ability for unihemispheric sleep. That is the ability to sleep with one cerebral hemisphere at a time, while the other hemisphere is awake" In other words: the brain has two CPUs, and they switch off only one at a time.
- cjensen 13y agoThe interesting thing to me is why? What would cause this evolution? Most swifts fly all day and can barely perch, but they do perch for the night since they require sight to locate aerial insects and the effort of flying all night is a big energy drain on a small bird. I can think of only two possibilities: First possibility is that insects are dense enough that they are feeding themselves at night. Second is that the safety of being off the ground plus abundant daytime food makes this a better survival strategy. Can't wait to see what the ornithologists come up with to explain this.
- Someone 13y agoA different species, a different insane record, and different technology, but also discovered only because of advances in the miniaturization of electronics: some arctic terns fly 90.000 km in about 9 months (http://ardea.nou.nu/ardea_show_abstract.php?lang=uk&nr=4099 http://ardea.nou.nu/ardea_show_abstract.php?lang=uk&nr=4099).
- tocomment 13y agoI feel like this wouldn't jibe with conservation of energy. Unless the bird can eat in the air somehow. It just physically couldn't store enough fuel to fly to fix months straight, right?
- dllthomas 13y ago"Unless the bird can eat in the air somehow." By, say, catching airborne insects. Which is how swifts (and also swallows) typically feed themselves.
- elwell 13y agoPsh, any bird can stay in flight for 5 years if aboard this drone: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6528598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6528598.
- forgottenpaswrd 13y agoGreat animals. It is spectacular seeing them flying in big groups. They are also very useful for controlling mosquitoes.
- argumentum 13y agoThis is awesome .. also ironic that on the #4 and #6 stories on HN right now are these: *This Bird Can Stay in Flight for Six Months Straight* and *Aerospace Company Develops Drone That Can Fly Continuously For 5 Years*
- piokuc 13y agoWatch migration of eagle Arnold from Slovakia to (probably) South Africa, on a google map: http://spravatanap.sk/web/index.php/component/content/article/2-uncategorised/140-lety-arnolda http://spravatanap.sk/web/index.php/component/content/articl... The page is in Slovakian but Google translate does a good job.
- ccleve 13y agoWhat's more likely: a bird that can fly for six months straight, or a software bug that caused the sensor to yield misleading data on what the bird was actually doing?
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoHow likely would you say it is for an air-breathing mammal to spend its entire life in the ocean? It would need to be swimming all the time, even while it slept, to avoid drowning.
- Ellipsis753 13y agoAwesome article and very interesting. However to go on a bit of a tangent what did people think of the sensor in the photo? It's interesting that such as small sensor still has long pads for connecting (presumably to program it and get data off) and also that it has a little tag on the left of the picture (making it bigger). I can't see a battery in the photo. Is it on the backside or is it powered in some other way? Also what is the little metal wire for? I would think that it was an antenna, however they state that they had to find the birds again to get the data back so it would seem that they don't communicate wireless. Could it be getting powered from radio waves instead? What do you think? Is there more information on it somewhere?
- goblin89 13y agoA sceptic in me suggests that new sensors could exhibit some sort of unexpected behavior that skewed experiment results. > Perhaps most exciting is the fact that this finding came after just the first time the new, ultra-lightweight movement sensor was used in avian research.
- texasCoder 13y agoFrom the linked wiki article describing sleep in non-humans: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleep_%28non-human%29#Sleep%20duration http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleep_%28non-human%29#Sleep%20d... Comparative average sleep periods for various mammals (in captivity) over 24 hours Horses – 2.9 hours Elephants – 3+ hours Cows – 4.0 hours Giraffes – 4.5 hours Humans – 8.0 hours Glad the avg sleep period of humans in captivity has been measured...
- davorak 13y agoArticle at nature website: http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/full/ncomms3554.html http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/full/nco... Scroll through the figures here: http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/fig_tab/ncomms3554_ft.html http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/131008/ncomms3554/fig_tab/... I could not find the raw data at a glance or the elevation over time which would have been useful to see if there were any likely points where it could have landed and taken off again between data points.
- X4 13y agoSwift Rescue: Saving a Protected Alpine Swift, Stuck Atop a Six-Story Building (HD) – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T83EHM_rUlw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T83EHM_rUlw
- GuerraEarth 13y agoSince the birds can sleep with just one cerebral hemisphere dormant at a time, rest while gliding, eat and drink while airborne--and it is much safer in the air than on land, it actually makes more sense for the birds to remain aloft. It's just different than what we (can)do.