3 ms·
[This is a copy of a comment I posted to a previous discussion on this topic.] The problem is that the standard itself isn’t enough to actually support any of
by JoshTriplett 13y ago
[This is a copy of a comment I posted to a previous discussion on this topic.]
The problem is that the standard itself isn’t enough to actually support any of the content it claims to support.
It’s the equivalent of standardizing the object or embed tags: it’s a standard way of getting at non-standard functionality, and sites then depend on specific implementations of that non-standard functionality, the same way they depend on the Flash plugin today in ways that knowing how to implement the object tag doesn’t help with.
Standardizing a single fully-specified mechanism for DRM might actually be useful (debatably), but that would break the current model in which DRM is completely unsound and relies on security-through-obscurity. “Standardizing” a means of getting at the myriad non-standard DRM implementations and their non-standard APIs is worse than worthless: it’s actively harmful, and it prolongs the death of those technologies.
Right now, content providers have to choose whether to support the open web or DRM. They should continue to have to make that choice, with supporters of the open web reaching a larger audience, until eventually all the holdouts either switch or lose. This is a major step backward for that goal, and the W3C has no business claiming EME has anything to do with the open web.
- pyalot2 13y agoIt's not just that it prolongs that clinging to anti-feature systems by the content industry. EME kills the webs future by a simple insidious mechanism. the CDM (content decryption module) needs to provide the raw bytes to the browser so that the browser can composit the webpage with the video (layering things behind/ontop and transforming it with CSS). But if the CDM delivers the plain content to the browser to display, then the browser (or any program, like wget) could simply use the CDM to dump the plain content to disk. Since EME cannot work in this fashion, the CDM cannot be made available to Open Source/community browsers (like Firefox, Chromium, Webkit builds, Khtml etc.) In turn this means that if large web-properties (like Facebook, Youtube, Netflix, Amazon etc.) adopt DRM for one reason or another, Open Source/Community browsers will be known to users as "those browsers that don't work". You will end up with another proprietary browser monopoly web, like in the good old days of IE6. Why is it you think that Microsoft (of all companies) is pushing EME along at a frentic pace as if their life depended on it?