3 ms·
He contradicts himself in the text: #1: > So we put the user first, but different users have different preferences. Putting the user first doesn’t help us to s
by shmerl 13y ago
He contradicts himself in the text:
#1: > So we put the user first, but different users have different preferences. Putting the user first doesn’t help us to satisfy users’ possibly incompatible wants: some Web users like to watch big-budget movies at home, some Web users like to experiment with code.
#2: > No one likes DRM as a user, wherever it crops up.
DRM never means putting users first - it's always anti user, for which #2 precisely attests. So, #1 had to read: "we put DRM lobby first". That sounds about right about what they did. And, DRM obviously goes way beyond just preventing tinkering with the code in its anti user nature.
So this principle is clearly violated: In case of conflict, consider users over authors over implementers over specifiers over theoretical purity. Users don't want DRM. Users want media. Publishers want DRM. Putting users over publishers means showing publishers the door, until they come back with DRM free content. Publishers will bend since DRM is idiocy and always was, W3C shouldn't bend.
- paulftw 13y agoYou are right about him contradicting himself, but I think first half (rather first 2/3) of his post are just philosophical beating around the bush. He nearly lost me half-way through. But what he's actually trying to say is that if W3C won't standardize some form of DRM, publishers lobby will fill the gap. And whatever comes out of that lobby will be thousand times worse for the users and implementers. I don't necessarily agree with that, but this is the message of that blog post. A lot of users want their internets work fast and without glitches on their PC from 2003, under WinXP and IE8. In order to satisfy interests of those users we must stop introducing new CSS features and JS extensions. That's just how sad the world we live in is. I tend to think that publishers aren't as powerful as they used to be. Browser market is dominated but rather open Chrome and Mozilla still going strong. Duopoly of iOS and Android is quite dangerous though - if these two reach any agreement, W3C opinion won't matter.