2 ms·
Given the stated assumptions, yes. Is there a flaw in that logic? To arrive at another outcome, you'd need to weigh the suffering and somehow decide that a sin
by MichaelGG 13y ago
Given the stated assumptions, yes. Is there a flaw in that logic?
To arrive at another outcome, you'd need to weigh the suffering and somehow decide that a single person's life, who is actively trying to hurt others (that is, they aren't an innocent bystander), is somehow worth more. In some scenarios this can be a philosophical debate (how much small annoyance to millions of people is one other person's life worth?), but with an active adversary and no other course of action, it seems like the only rational decision.
You seem to be indicating that in this scenario you'd always value a single person's life (despite their actions) above many others' suffering. Is it because you view LE as morally superior, or do you have another set of priors that shape your reasoning?
- tptacek 13y agoI don't need to interrogate my priors to come to the conclusion that it is invariably wrong to order hits on people.
- MichaelGG 13y agoFurther down in the comments, you indicated it was OK in the case of Nazi Germany since it wasn't "real" law enforcement and it "involves certitude". That seems to indicate to me that you don't actually believe it's "invariably wrong".
- tptacek 13y agoRidiculous and a little offensive.
- MichaelGG 13y agoOK, easier scenario: A guy is insane, and is going to murder 20 people. Your only option is to ask his friend to kill him. Is is still "invariably" wrong? Anyways, my original question to you (and on other threads, like where you appear to defend seizure actions) is where exactly are you getting your priors? In all your replies you just rephase things as if we're supposed to draw the right conclusion. And I'm only asking because it's you, someone proven in security and rather insightful on many threads. If it's just an innate, fundamental belief you hold, fine. I was just wondering if you had some special source or logic that lets you decide these things so absolutely.