4 ms·
Seems to me a flaw in this argument is that much smarter humans do show up from time to time, without apparent ill effect. It's conceivable that we could at lea
by DennisP 13y ago
Seems to me a flaw in this argument is that much smarter humans do show up from time to time, without apparent ill effect. It's conceivable that we could at least enhance intelligence to John von Neumann's level.
- jameskilton 13y agoThat's not the argument. The argument is that it's impossible to artificially improve a person's intelligence.
- NotOscarWilde 13y agoI concur. In my opinion the "impossibility of improving IQ" in gwern's first sentence should be understood as "impossibility of improving IQ through supplementation at the current level". I think the source of the problem is rather our very limited understanding of maintaining and improving the brain functions. As far as my limited knowledge goes, we still cannot reverse many dementia-inducing illnesses; once we see deeper into them, maybe better supplementation will appear. It's understandable that various "trivial" methods at increasing IQ fail. (Heck, we don't know much about benefit/hazard of many chemicals that enter our body; and even when we do -- smoking, obesity -- people tend to disregard the advice.)
- gverri 13y agoWhile you can't improove your IQ overall (in controlled tests), it's completely possible do get better at logical games, thus increasing you score at IQ tests. I know it because I have trained a bit for some IQ tests and the results improve the more you train for it. That's something everyone should be capable of.
- gwern 13y agoIt's conceivable, but it's not going to be easy or simple. Think of how many billions of humans existed simultaneously with John von Neumann without being anywhere near his level. If we figure that Neumann was mostly due to a stellar combination of alleles, then that implies he got lucky on a very large number of alleles (imagine a bunch of alleles which can be on or off, and Neumann got all of them 'on'; then because he was 1 out of 5 billion or whatever, he got log_2 5,000,000,000 = 32. This is not 1 variation, which is easy to select on, or 2, but 32. The current state of the art, using n=100,000 is around 3 SNPs. (I apologize in advance to the geneticists for my reasoning here.)) And I would note that Neumann, despite being happily married, a gifted negotiator, lady's man, and party-goer, never had children. So Neumann might violate either the simple or reproductive fitness requirements: to the extent we can hope to manufacture Neumanns through genetic engineering, it's not going to be easy; and to the extent we can judge from n=1, the reproductive fitness penalties may be large.
- Gravityloss 13y agoHe also died from pancreatic or bone cancer at age 51
- gwern 13y agoYeah, but that's almost certainly unrelated. It's not like geniuses routinely die young of cancer.
- thromeaway34 13y agofyi, http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marina_von_Neumann_Whitman http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marina_von_Neumann_Whitman
- gwern 13y agoAh. My bad. I guess I was thinking of his second marriage and didn't remember he had a daughter. But I see she only has 2 kids, so maybe it will still be true soon that von Neumann was without any surviving descendants...