6 ms·
He was left in a very terrible situation and decision. He was facing someone who was willing to destroy many other people's lives (assuming drug dealers would b
by MichaelGG 13y ago
He was left in a very terrible situation and decision. He was facing someone who was willing to destroy many other people's lives (assuming drug dealers would be arrested). If you take that as a given prior, then the step of deciding to prevent that person from hurting others seems like basic self defense (while noting that the USG prevented him from using other measures).
Edit: There's always still the possibility that DPR was aware he wasn't hiring hitmen, but felt it was the best negotiation tactic.
- tedunangst 13y agoHow did he come to be in this terrible situation where he was forced to make such a decision?
- grugq 13y agoIt is covered in the Complaint. Essentially someone using the alias FriendlyChemist (FC) gained illegal access to a vendor's account, and possibly to a lot more. This gave FC a large trove of PII on SilkRoad buyers and sellers (names, addresses, etc). FC attempted to blackmail Dread Pirate Roberts (DPR) saying he would release the information publicly unless DPR paid him $500,000... which he needed because he was in debt to his upstream drug supplier. DPR then asked to be put in contact with the upstream supplier so he could "sort something out". The timeline of events is here: http://grugq.tumblr.com/post/62928607375/dread-pirate-roberts-extortion-timeline http://grugq.tumblr.com/post/62928607375/dread-pirate-robert...
- tedunangst 13y agoSorry, I meant the question to be a bit more meta. You don't usually wake up and find yourself in "oh shit, I need a hitman" situations out of the blue. It takes some work to get there.
- jlgreco 13y agoIs the premise here that nobody should ever put themselves into situations where they cannot rely on law enforcement and the justice systems to resolve disputes and incidents? Shipping companies semi-frequently seem to find themselves in situations where the wake up and think "Oh shoot, I need to hire some mercenaries." It takes some work to get into that sort of situation, but does that imply that they shouldn't have gotten themselves into that pickle?
- tedunangst 13y agoIt implies I am less sympathetic to his plight. Put yourself in a hard place, expect to make hard decisions. In the case of mercenaries or bodyguards or whatever, that is exactly the kind of precaution one can take to avoid being in a truly nasty pickle.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf you are running a massive international illicit market worth billions, you are probably going to require that service sooner or later, unless you can walk away from it.
- matthudson 13y ago> "... gained illegal access to a vendor's account..." Kind of off topic, but suppose "FC" were arrested, could this person be charged with malicious entry into an otherwise illegal enterprise? Do those legal rights extend to people who had already been breaking laws? Obviously, a bank robber has a right to not to be murdered by another bank robber. But can the other bank robber be charged with stealing the victim's ill-gotten money in addition to the murder?
- tedunangst 13y agoThought experiment: compare and contrast weev and FC.
- grugq 13y agoYes, particularly for the second "hit" that he arranged (the one in the Complaint). However, the first "hit" (outlined in the Maryland indictment) seems to have been more of a set piece entrapment-alike. This was when he popped his online-hitman cherry, and it was the most difficult one for him. He seems quite distraught and upset in the messages, he has trusted this guy ("The Employee") as an admin, he loaned him the money for the "substance that would test positive as cocaine", he likely socialized with him and revealed a great deal of personal information. I think the Feds played him (Ross Ulbricht) in this case and totally set him up for a fall. I accept that he stepped off that cliff himself, but I think it is likely that he was guided the whole way there by the Feds. After this first hit, orchestrated from start to finish (?) by the feds, the second one seemed easier. He had learned to live with himself after the deed was done, he had pushed beyond that moral barrier of "don't have other people tortured and killed", and he had learned that violence can solve problems. Now, as to whether this second "hit" was just him negotiating with a scammer, or whether he believed he was actually having someone killed. I think it is clear that without that first job, that first hand held walk through the dark side of the underground, he wouldn't have reacted that way. I think he would have been less susceptible to the manipulations of the feds if he was in a normal social peer group. If he had some rational people who weren't inside the Silk Road bubble who could say "you want to have someone killed because they stole some SHA256 hashsums? Are you fucking insane?!?"
- tptacek 13y agoThe premise of this comment is that the harm of having someone killed is outweighed by the harm of reporting a community of people to law enforcement.
- MichaelGG 13y agoSigh, I guess I was not clear enough with "If you take that as a given prior". If you do have the assumption, axiom, belief, whatever, that drugs are moral and ease suffering, and that releasing data on these people will lead to long lives in prison, causing a chain of disastrous effects on many families, then yes, stopping the person that is trying to harm these other people may be considered. Many people die each year due to the USG's war on drugs policy, and it has a violent affect on many of the countries to the south of Texas. Just for a bit of context/scope. Edit: On second reading, I actually dislike your rhetoric even less. You can rephase anything as a series of immediate actions. It's not the harm of "reporting to law enforcement" it's what happens next.
- tptacek 13y agoThe response that your second reading of my comment generated seems to be "you didn't fully consider the impact of reporting someone to law enforcement, and, by implication, could be incorrect in your weighting of whether it might be justifiable to have someone killed to prevent them from doing that."
- MichaelGG 13y agoGiven the stated assumptions, yes. Is there a flaw in that logic? To arrive at another outcome, you'd need to weigh the suffering and somehow decide that a single person's life, who is actively trying to hurt others (that is, they aren't an innocent bystander), is somehow worth more. In some scenarios this can be a philosophical debate (how much small annoyance to millions of people is one other person's life worth?), but with an active adversary and no other course of action, it seems like the only rational decision. You seem to be indicating that in this scenario you'd always value a single person's life (despite their actions) above many others' suffering. Is it because you view LE as morally superior, or do you have another set of priors that shape your reasoning?