11 ms·
Algernon's Law
- DennisP 13y agoSeems to me a flaw in this argument is that much smarter humans do show up from time to time, without apparent ill effect. It's conceivable that we could at least enhance intelligence to John von Neumann's level.
- jameskilton 13y agoThat's not the argument. The argument is that it's impossible to artificially improve a person's intelligence.
- NotOscarWilde 13y agoI concur. In my opinion the "impossibility of improving IQ" in gwern's first sentence should be understood as "impossibility of improving IQ through supplementation at the current level". I think the source of the problem is rather our very limited understanding of maintaining and improving the brain functions. As far as my limited knowledge goes, we still cannot reverse many dementia-inducing illnesses; once we see deeper into them, maybe better supplementation will appear. It's understandable that various "trivial" methods at increasing IQ fail. (Heck, we don't know much about benefit/hazard of many chemicals that enter our body; and even when we do -- smoking, obesity -- people tend to disregard the advice.)
- gverri 13y agoWhile you can't improove your IQ overall (in controlled tests), it's completely possible do get better at logical games, thus increasing you score at IQ tests. I know it because I have trained a bit for some IQ tests and the results improve the more you train for it. That's something everyone should be capable of.
- gwern 13y agoIt's conceivable, but it's not going to be easy or simple. Think of how many billions of humans existed simultaneously with John von Neumann without being anywhere near his level. If we figure that Neumann was mostly due to a stellar combination of alleles, then that implies he got lucky on a very large number of alleles (imagine a bunch of alleles which can be on or off, and Neumann got all of them 'on'; then because he was 1 out of 5 billion or whatever, he got log_2 5,000,000,000 = 32. This is not 1 variation, which is easy to select on, or 2, but 32. The current state of the art, using n=100,000 is around 3 SNPs. (I apologize in advance to the geneticists for my reasoning here.)) And I would note that Neumann, despite being happily married, a gifted negotiator, lady's man, and party-goer, never had children. So Neumann might violate either the simple or reproductive fitness requirements: to the extent we can hope to manufacture Neumanns through genetic engineering, it's not going to be easy; and to the extent we can judge from n=1, the reproductive fitness penalties may be large.
- Gravityloss 13y agoHe also died from pancreatic or bone cancer at age 51
- gwern 13y agoYeah, but that's almost certainly unrelated. It's not like geniuses routinely die young of cancer.
- thromeaway34 13y agofyi, http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marina_von_Neumann_Whitman http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marina_von_Neumann_Whitman
- gwern 13y agoAh. My bad. I guess I was thinking of his second marriage and didn't remember he had a daughter. But I see she only has 2 kids, so maybe it will still be true soon that von Neumann was without any surviving descendants...
- pallandt 13y agoI haven't read the whole article, but there is at least one inaccuracy I spotted. Piracetam's primary mechanism of action is glutamatergic, not cholinergic. This is why the known side-effects include anxiety, headaches, insomnia or irritability. The cholinergic impact is less pronounced.
- Pxtl 13y agogoogles > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glutamic_acid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glutamic_acid so wait, the natural protein that correlates with being a fast learner and thinker also causes anxiety, insomnia, and irritability? I am so not surprised in the slightest.
- mistercow 13y agoCitation?
- pallandt 13y agoI don't have much time right now to sift through so many papers, but see these for instance: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10583700 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10583700 , http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1372342 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1372342 I haven't stated anything outrageous, it's been known for a long time that piracetam is a positive modulator of glutamate receptors.
- mistercow 13y agoI'm not disputing that. But I've read a ton of studies about piracetam, and I've always had the impression that its primary mechanism was cholinergic.
- pallandt 13y agoIt largely depends on what you've read: how reputable the journal, how well-informed and genuine the researchers were etc. Some papers are written just for the sake of making one researcher's 'quota' or fulfilling the minimal requirements for a grant. It's not unusual even in the research community to keep rehashing old information.
- a3voices 13y agoLet's say you have a dog, and you want to make it as smart as a person. How would you do that? Giving it drugs won't work. The dog is limited by the brain structures that make it distinct from a human. Regardless of whatever drugs or supplements you give it, the dog will always act like a dog. Maybe it will be slightly smarter, but not in any truly astonishing way. Maybe with the right drug, it could learn 100 words instead of 20. But the dog won't be able to do everything a person can do. The same goes for people. There's no way you'd be able to make a person meaningfully smarter through supplementation or drugs.
- msane 13y agoEssentially you just said: > Supplementation could hypothetically improve the cognitive ability of dogs. But it could never make them as smart as humans. > The same goes for humans. Supplementation could never improve their cognitive abilities. I suppose maybe this shoddy little syllogism would be forgivable if you haven't had your coffee yet this morning.
- judk 13y agocoffee would help, if supplements can improve cognitive ability.
- msane 13y agoA little distraction for the Larry David file: It's annoying when you make a joke, and someone points out the joke as if you are unaware you are even making it. It's like they are simultaneously usurping credit for the wittiness, and insulting the intelligence of the originator. Why improve your cognitive ability at all, it's smart to be dumb. And how about the food they serve on airplanes? Come on am I right?
- gwern 13y ago> I suppose maybe this shoddy little syllogism would be forgivable if you haven't had your coffee yet this morning. Caffeine may not be improving his intelligence, but removing damage ie. withdrawal. (And so about as surprising as 'lack of sleep deprivation increases intelligence!' or 'lack of iodine deficiency increases intelligence!') This is one of the challenges of studying addictive stimulants: how do you know whether, for experienced tolerant users, the apparent benefits are genuine benefits or just treating withdrawal?
- maaku 13y agoGwern, this whole subject is sloppy. It is trivially simple to improve IQ scores by practicing the types of questions IQ tests make. There is no reliable way to measure IQ, therefore it's not clear that IQ is measuring anything reliably. What, exactly, are you talking about then?
- selmnoo 13y agoI improved my IQ by 20 pts in an year's time. It was pretty simple: study SAT/GRE words, and do a lot of arithmetic exercises. I know that it increased by 20 pts. because I underwent an IQ test conducted by a licensed psychologist twice.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eloff 13y agoExactly, my logic professor always used to say that studying logic improves your IQ (btw, so does programming.) Well it does, because a bunch of the questions on an IQ test are logical riddles. Math and vocabulary have the same effect.
- viggity 13y agoit was always my understanding that "good" IQ tests should have almost zero variance based on your vocabulary, or hell, even your mathematical abilities. A "good" IQ test simply tests your logic facilities. Example "good" questions would show a sequence of 6 shapes and ask you what the next one in the series should look like. or perhaps a question like "given that all boogles are quinks and some quinks are flets, are all flets boogles?". A question on a "bullshit" IQ test would be: "'Daring' is an appropriate adjective for: A. Rocks. B. Planets. C. Humans.". Another would be "x^2 = 36, solve for x" Now, I know that some standardized tests (ACT, SAT, IBTS), will sometimes try to estimate your IQ by correlating your scores, but that is fraught with problems and shouldn't be taken as gospel.
- foobarbazqux 13y ago
- oh_sigh 13y agoAnother day, another gwern.net post.
- _exec 13y agoNot a fan?
- oh_sigh 13y agoIt's not that I am not a fan, but it's just strange that we've been seeing so many posts from gwern.net, considering he's been writing for many years. This article, for example, is from 2010.
- alecdbrooks 13y agoHe explained why he's submitting so many nine days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6466422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6466422. He constanly updates and expands the articles on his website, so it isn't so strange for an article created in 2010 to be posted now. This post, for example, was last modified today.
- tachyonbeam 13y agoHe talks about MDMA and how it reduces anxiety near the end. When I first tried it, I found it quite amazing how a pill could completely eliminate my social anxiety for a few hours. I'd never felt so comfortable in my own skin and surrounding environment. I'd never realized that at every waking moment, even when alone, even when I think I'm pretty relaxed, I always feel some amount of background anxiety. This drug was able to take the anxiety down to zero. I was no longer afraid to go talk to strangers, I could really have fun at parties. The downsides, though, are pretty obvious. For one, MDMA causes a crash. Sometimes, I'd be down for 2, even 3 days afterwards, which would be quite unpleasant and kill my productivity. Another thing is that well, anxiety and fear are sometimes useful. If you're too trusting of people around you, you might eventually get yourself in risky situations. You might trust people you really shouldn't. There's also been a study on MDMA that showed that it changes the way you interpret signs of rejection given off by people. You interpret people's response to you more positively, even if it isn't all that positive. MDMA can help you approach people, but it can also make you a little delusional (over optimistic) about the way people perceive you. My personal opinion is that people with less baseline anxiety are probably still generally better off in the modern world. They're less stressed, they're more open to approaching and being approached by people, they end up having more friends because of this. They might have a tendency to be more trusting and not notice as much when they annoy people, but it probably generally works in their favor. I probably worry too much about displeasing other people.
- bitwize 13y agoMDMA sounds to humans what Toxoplasma gondii infection is to rats.
- tachyonbeam 13y agoWith the difference that you're presumably much more intelligent than a rat. Even if you don't feel anxious, you can reason on a purely logical basis as to what might be a bad idea. Even if you stopped feeling fear, you'd probably still be intelligent enough to look on both sides before crossing the street. I do agree that it can, and probably will increase risk taking, though. The risks I took on MDMA were social risks, things I don't actually deem to be dangerous, things my fear stops me from doing but that I should probably be attempting more often. I find that MDMA makes it very easy to "open up" to people and tell them what you think. This is probably one of the reasons why people are looking into using it as a therapeutic aid for PTSD and rape victims. In the context of a party though, this can translate in you being very comfortable telling your friends what you really think about them, even if it isn't a good idea. I found I'm still able to ask myself rationally "is this something I should be telling this person?", "could this be hurtful to this person?" and stop myself from saying stupid things. This is different from alcohol, which makes you both less anxious and less intelligent. I can tell you that on MDMA, I actually feel extremely sharp, more than normal (better recall, better verbal fluency, etc). I can tell you that people have said stupid and offensive things to me while high on MDMA, however. One girl told me that she disliked my new hairstyle (thanks, I like it just fine), and also told me that she frequently had sex dreams about me, but that nothing could come of it since she had a boyfriend. Both of these were things I didn't want to know. I will say though that this same girl has said more offensive and annoying things to me while sober.
- stiff 13y agoIf the proposed intervention would result in an enhancement, why have we not already evolved to be that way? This is completely misguided, because evolution does not necessarily "progress" in any sense. Here is a good explanation: http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/misconceptions_faq.php#a3 http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/misconceptions_faq.... This looks like a typical example of what happens when people from mathematical fields or philosophers take up evolution and A) view it as some sort of simple optimization procedure and B) use it as some all-pervading philosophical principle from which things can be derived and don't have to be proven.
- Symmetry 13y agoI think that the author covered most of the same objections in his essay that the FAQ you link does, missing only that evolution doesn't necessarily work well in small populations.
- stiff 13y agoHe nevertheless proceeds as if this is something that is generally true, with it only being false in exceptional situations. There is no reason to suppose that this is generally true, which makes the heuristic useless, and hence his reasoning gets very shaky, for example: How about opiates? Morphine and other painkillers can easily be justified as evolution not knowing when a knife cut is by a murderous enemy and when it’s by a kindly surgeon (which didn’t exist way back when), and choosing to make us err on the side of always feeling pain. But recreational drug abuse? #1 doesn’t seem too plausible - what about modern society would favor opiate consumption outside of medicinal use? If one wishes to deaden the despair and ennui of living in a degenerate atheistic material culture, we have beer for that.57 #3 doesn’t work either; opioids have been around for ages and work via the standard brain machinery. #2 might work here as well, but this dumps us straight into the debate about the War on Drugs and what harm drug use does to the user & society. He completely misses here what he wrote himself earlier for example about there not existing a simple mutation from the current state to the "desired" one.
- 13y ago
- SoftwarePatent 13y ago> it’s not too surprising that human medicine may be largely wasted effort or harmful 13 (although most - especially doctors - would strenuously deny this). This claim requires evidence, but the citation is to a blog post about nutrition, not medicine.
- gwern 13y ago> This claim requires evidence, but the citation is to a blog post about nutrition, not medicine. I didn't realize nutrition had nothing to do with medicine. And actually, the citation is to a list of 24 posts by Hanson covering various aspects of the negative case for medicine, including but not limited to nutrition.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoHuman brain is stupid - fit to the wrong environment. I was thinking the other day: Babies are afraid of strangers, any new people, especially if those are a little scary. But that makes no sense in modern countries - nobody ever threatens this child, and if on off-change somebody does, he'll try to be as "friendly" as possible when doing so. Children scares make no sense! Adult anxiety makes no sense either!
- codex 13y agoI think that should civilization collapse a lot of behaviors will begin to make a lot of sense. Hopefully that never occurs.
- mumbi 13y agoI believe that gwern is a little too obsessed about IQ.
- tedks 13y agoIt's common on less wrong to be very pro-IQ. I think this is a mix of contrarianism and desperately wanting to be superior at something, since most people on less wrong don't seem to be terribly well-off in other respects. That said, it does seem like IQ correlates well with various other measures of success, unless all of the articles Gwern cites are wrong in some way (which is fairly probable), so you'd expect something to be there.
- tokenadult 13y agoPrevious discussion (of an earlier version of this article?) 461 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4201233 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4201233 Readers who are interested in following up on the professional literature on human intelligence and IQ testing are invited to dig into the "Intelligence Citations" bibliography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/IntelligenceCitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/Intellig... in Wikipedia user space.
- SnacksOnAPlane 13y agoIntelligence is not an unalloyed good as the article claims. An excess of intelligence without some outlet for it produces frustration and, in extreme cases, depression.
- Anderkent 13y agoSo it has a cost, exactly as the article claims? The very point of the article is that there is no free lunch. Intelligence improvements are bound to be trade-offs, because otherwise they'd have evolved already. Frustration and depression may be some of these costs.
- notahacker 13y agoThe article opens with a claim that (i) an individual's brain is wired in a way which makes change in IQ difficult for a set of healthy humans with IQ over a certain threshold which is basically orthogonal to the main thrust of the article (ii) that higher [potential] IQ has an evolutionary disadvantage Sure, one can posit that (i) occurs because of (ii): i.e. (iii) to mitigate against the risk of people harming their reproductive ability by training up their IQ, the evolutionary process selects for immutable IQ But that seems like a hypothesis with little to recommend it against the alternate hypothesis that mutability of IQ is neutral with respect to evolution but evolving brain structures whose performance in certain tasks can be radically improved in adulthood is difficult, period. Especially when one considers that high IQ at birth isn't eliminated from the gene pool, and marked increases in 1930-normalised IQ between generations doesn't appear to markedly disadvantage modern Westerners. Similarly, it seems simpler to accept that the phenotype "potential 140 IQ" is the consequence of specific, rare combinations of certain genes which overall aren't correlated with survival, without positing side effects of IQ-linked genes. Ubermensch can't be bred because their kids aren't clones rather than because they're necessarily deficient in other ways. I'd see the incidence of Tay Sachs disease as a counterexample to the theory that high performance in a specific brain function necessarily has evolutionary tradeoffs. Ashkenazi Jews on average test with higher verbal and mathematical intelligence and lower spatial intelligence than other ethnic groups, which could imply that human brains naturally-selected for optimal function in one area are punished in other areas. Ashkenazi Jews are also more likely to carry the recessive gene for the very rare and very debilitating Tay-Sachs disease. But since 26 out of 27 Ashkenazi Jews don't have that recessive gene, which afaik is uncorrelated with IQ amongst Ashkenazi Jews, it suggests the common factor between Askhenazi intelligence and Ashkenazi Tay-Sachs incidence is inbreeding. Reduced average spatial intelligence could, like Tay-Sachs, be the unfortunate effect of a restricted gene pool rather than an "tradeoff" which must inevitably be caused by higher scores in other tests.
- Anderkent 13y ago> alternate hypothesis that mutability of IQ is neutral with respect to evolution but evolving brain structures whose performance in certain tasks can be radically improved in adulthood is difficult, period. Merely 'difficult' is not much of a counter-argument - almost every component of a human being is at least 'difficult' to design. There doesn't seem to be reason to believe creating higher intelligence is especially more costly, in comparison to the already achieved intelligence.
- tedks 13y agoGwern has some very good essays; I don't think this is one of them, because it's about 'laws' created on less wrong rather than anything actionable. It seems possible to dismiss this entire article with another less wrong catechism: "life isn't fair."
- gwern 13y ago> It seems possible to dismiss this entire article with another less wrong catechism: "life isn't fair." I don't see how that's remotely relevant.
- tedks 13y agoWell, it's a bit of a fully general counterargument, but then, so is "there's no such thing as a free lunch." > If the proposed intervention would result in an enhancement, why have we not already evolved to be that way? Life isn't fair. Drugs seem to make you think faster/stay up later/be happier? Evolution didn't get it right the first time? Life isn't fair.
- gwern 13y ago> Well, it's a bit of a fully general counterargument, but then, so is "there's no such thing as a free lunch." It's not a fully general counterargument because it predicts a lot of things. Claiming that's a fully general counterargument is like saying the Halting problem is a fully general counterargument. It isn't. > Life isn't fair. Huh? How does that follow? 'Water is flowing uphill. Guess life isn't fair.' 'The hot air is not dispersing throughout the room due to convection. Guess life isn't fair.' 'Wall Street is incorrectly pricing a derivative, leaving billions in profit on the floor. Guess life isn't fair.'
- tedks 13y ago>Huh? How does that follow? Evolution isn't guaranteed to arrive at optimal outcomes at any given point in time. Obviously "algernon's law" isn't a, you know, law, because if that were the case humans wouldn't exist because any increase in intelligence would be accompanied by a corresponding drop in chimpanzee fitness. Why are modern humans the point where this stops being true? The whole thing smells like sour grapes. Why do people on MDMA have so much fun? Because life isn't fair. All the people who lived before MDMA will never have that much fun. Evolution just didn't hit the lucky path where humans are constantly tripping balls. Life isn't fair. >It's not a fully general counterargument because it predicts a lot of things. So what doesn't it predict? >Claiming that's a fully general counterargument is like saying the Halting problem is a fully general counterargument. It isn't. Well, the specific counterexample that indicates the halting problem is never generally solvable is not a fully general counterargument, yes. But I don't see how this is related. Is there some reason why you think that using drug therapies to drastically increase human general intelligence is an impossibility akin to water flowing uphill? This is the logical step that the article failed to convey adequately to me.
- codex 13y agoTo me, a related supposition is more interesting: if you put a human in an environment which minics closely their recent evolutionary history, will previously-missing environmental triggers boost intelligence (or any other bodily function?) to their optimum, perhaps via hormesis? Such an environment would include: - higher amounts of exercise - periodic fasting and/or malnutrition - lower carb intake (sugars, grains) - higher plant intake - higher sunlight exposure - sleep/wake cycle dictated by the Sun - less sitting ... but might also include: - exposure to rotted food and disease - increased bodily injury - increased exposure to the elements
- scythe 13y agoI find the overall argument to be rather weak. The most relevant problem is that it starts on a premise that might as well be this: "Intelligence is a substance, and a nootropic is a drug that makes the brain produce more of it." Of course I've intentionally phrased this as to make it seem ludicrous, but throughout the article he talks of "more" or "less" intelligence as though it were a fungible sort of thing. Really, though, intelligence is just a way that human beings interpret each other's behavior, related to performance on various tasks (mathematics, etc). There's no particular reason to assume that evolution would have optimized for, e.g., skill in mathematical analysis, and therefore there isn't any particular reason to assume that even the silliest of low-hanging fruit wouldn't have been picked, for instance an elderly and distinguished analyst, such as Paul Erdos, may benefit from taking amphetamine. There are also radical differences in what we measure as "IQ", which is mostly performance on a battery of strange tasks, and the sort of mental performance that leads to evolutionary success. There are, for example, arguments to the evolutionary sufficiency of ADHD[1], OCD[2]. 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis 2: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocd#Causes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocd#Causes More critically, though, is that this represents yet another article on the basis of "I-think-it-oughta" evolutionary reasoning. You think "intellectual low-hanging fruit" ought to be selected for, but you don't have empirical evidence. The claim is based almost entirely on hand-waving and citations of Eliezer Yudkowsky, who is not in any case an authoritative source [3], and whose claims have not been in general accepted by contemporary neuroscientists [4]. 3: http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.se/2010/09/eliezer-yudkowsky-on-bayes-and-science.html http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.se/2010/09/eliezer-yudkow... 4: notably absent here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_of_human_intelligence and here: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=evolution+intelligence+algernon&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C11 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=evolution+intelligence+a... Meanwhile, experimental evidence is contradicted. For instance, amphetamine is correlated with improvements in IQ, not to the tune of 20 points, more like four[5]. In fact, things as random -- and ostensibly detrimental -- as mescaline[6] can improve certain aspects of mental functioning, albeit at the cost of others. That what are essentially shots in the dark can produce noticeable improvements in certain qualities bodes well for rational drug design, which has been a success in other fields e.g. cisplatin vs. imatinib. 5: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphetamine#Medical http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphetamine#Medical 6: http://www.medpagetoday.com/Psychiatry/Addictions/2070 http://www.medpagetoday.com/Psychiatry/Addictions/2070 Another thing that is important to keep in mind is that the workings of the body can be highly counterintuitive. For instance, one might expect choline supplementation to increase the level of brain acetylcholine. It seems natural, right? But it's not true[7]. Furthermore, while piracetam's effects are commonly considered to be affected (and side-effects reduced) by choline supplementation[8], it is now generally believed to act primarily as an allosteric modulator on ion channels linked to AMPA-sensitive glutamate receptors[9]. Facile reasoning of the sort "what negative effects might have prevented evolution from doing this" thus cannot, itself, tell us very much. 7: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mrm.1910390619/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mrm.1910390619/fu... 8: popular claim on longecity et al, e.g.: http://www.pillscout.com/2013/06/17/your-piracetam-dosage-is-wrong/#comment-36 http://www.pillscout.com/2013/06/17/your-piracetam-dosage-is... , http://www.bluelight.ru/vb/threads/181563-any-piracetam-users-out-there http://www.bluelight.ru/vb/threads/181563-any-piracetam-user... 9: http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jm901905j http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jm901905j The most immediately difficult claim to me is the advocacy of spaced repetition, when it is not clear why the claims of the article necessarily apply to drugs but not to techniques such as this -- could we not evolve to use it instinctively? For all this, there is a little useful data in the article. It is indeed widely suspected that choline is underrepresented in modern diets[10], possibly because major dietary sources of choline include eggs and fatty meats, which have been discouraged in Western diets due to a now-controversial belief that cholesterol and saturated fats are antinutrients. There are indeed large differences between WEIRD[11] and historical environments, many of which go without mention -- socializing is much easier, our lives demand much less energy, the risk of malnutrition has been all but eliminated, etc. 10: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Choline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Choline 11: http://www.facstaff.bucknell.edu/jvt002/BrainMind/Readings/Henrich_2010.pdf http://www.facstaff.bucknell.edu/jvt002/BrainMind/Readings/H... The general thrust of my post is that "evolution" is not an argument that computer scientists can throw around in order to do biology without actually studying it[12], and that evolutionary psychology is often subject to epistemological problems, cf. The Emperor's New Paradigm[13]. 12: http://www.amazon.com/Behavioral-Genetics-Robert-Plomin/dp/1429205776 http://www.amazon.com/Behavioral-Genetics-Robert-Plomin/dp/1... 13: http://commons.lib.niu.edu/bitstream/10843/13182/1/BullerTiCS%20Reprint.pdf http://commons.lib.niu.edu/bitstream/10843/13182/1/BullerTiC...
- trendoid 13y agoI wonder how many people thoroughly read these gwern articles before jumping to comment their opposing views. There is a lot of information inside. It may take me 5-6 hours to properly go through it before concluding that gwern didnt take X into account. Idea : On HN, even if I save long articles for later and read a week after, my posted views will not be read by anyone since the discussion is already over. Maybe HN can provide a service where everyone gets update whenever a new comment is posted on such articles. I get to choose which posts I want updates from(and most will be ones having lots of words since updates will be few and far between). That way even if someone comments after a week, she atleast knows few people are getting aware of it.
- mietek 13y agoI wish there was a service like this.
- jmmcd 13y agoI've been collecting examples of the abuse and misunderstanding of the no-free-lunch theorems, and this is a pretty flagrant one: > "Any simple major enhancement to human intelligence is a net evolutionary disadvantage." The lesson is that Mother Nature know best. Or alternately, TANSTAAFL: there ain’t no such thing as a free lunch.
- Houshalter 13y agoWhy do you think that is wrong?
- jmmcd 13y agoThe NFL theorem (for search and optimisation) states that all algorithms for searching a fixed problem space perform the same, in expectation, when you don't know anything about the fitness (cost) structure over that space. There is a tradeoff in a sense: an algorithm can only do better than random search on some instances of the problem if it does worse on others. There's no sense of a tradeoff between multiple objectives on a single instance of a search problem, which is what gwern is talking about.
- Houshalter 13y agoI believe it's actually a reference to the general expression "There ain't no such thing as a free lunch" and has little to do with the computer science theorem of a similar name. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_ain't_no_such_thing_as_a_free_lunch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_ain't_no_such_thing_as_a...)
- jmmcd 13y agoYes, but Gwern links to the wiki page on the NFL theorems.