3 ms·
He's teasing apart what are seen to be the traditional purposes of prison: 1. Retribution. 2. Rehabilitation. 3. Removal. In particular, he argues that the
by jacques_chester 13y ago
He's teasing apart what are seen to be the traditional purposes of prison:
1. Retribution.
2. Rehabilitation.
3. Removal.
In particular, he argues that the first purpose can be replaced with corporal punishment for most crimes. The second purpose is still an open question amongst criminologists because it seems some criminal personalities cannot be changed; which leads to the third purpose of removing such people from the general population.
It's all a bit hypothetical, though. Short of amending the Constitution I think any scheme of corporal punishment would be seen as cruel and unusual. You need to remember that the substitution of prison for all other punishments was to prevent abuses of corporal punishment by vindictive governments. That problem doesn't just go away.
- EliRivers 13y agoany scheme of corporal punishment would be seen as cruel and unusual Presumably, as soon as it becomes established, it's no longer unusual; it's the new norm. It wouldn't meet Brennan's four principles on what is "cruel and unusual" and as such wouldn't fall foul of the 8th amendment.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThanks. It seems to me that the difficulty would be in going from unusual to usual without in the meantime being shot down by the Supreme Court. Are there cases where something became usual before it was brought to judicial review?