4 ms·
qr codes for gpg public keys - sounds a great idea. Any idea why no one done it yet - seems like it could be a simple transform from an ASCII armoured output.
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
qr codes for gpg public keys - sounds a great idea. Any idea why no one done it yet - seems like it could be a simple transform from an ASCII armoured output.
Bookmarking reply
- XorNot 13y agoYou have to use a very large QR code to do it. It won't fit on a business card and phones are picky about scanning them.
- betterunix 13y agoSure, but we have key servers for distributing the actual keys. You would only need the fingerprint in the QR code.
- XorNot 13y agoKind of defeats the point - how do you know you're downloading the private key you scanned? While someone might have their business cards replaced, it's a lot easier just to send a different key to someone.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI thought a QR code could be effectively any size - I certainly remember a Japanese billboard that used shadows etc. A QR code can have ~4000 chars of a-z and ~3000 Latin1 iirc so with my limited gpg knowledge that handles my public key quite happily. would be interested on the business card front though
- betterunix 13y ago"Kind of defeats the point - how do you know you're downloading the private key you scanned?" Assuming that "private key" is a typo (you download public keys), you can just check the fingerprint of the key against the fingerprint you were given. That is easily automated.
- XorNot 13y agoThis puts us back in the same kind of problem that was being complained about though - keyservers, publishing keys etc.
- betterunix 13y agoNot really. The problem is not about publishing keys or key servers, but with the cumbersome process of having to enter a hexadecimal string (and having to check an even longer string). The point of using QR codes is to simplify things: the user just scans a QR code, and the key is fetched and assumed to be valid (i.e. no need for the user to check fingerprints).