4 ms·
Ask HN: Why is difficulty for difficulty's sake highly valued?
It's most obvious in theoretical fields such as mathematics where completely useless conjectures/theorems are highly valued because they are/were difficult to settle/prove.
It's also something that you see in the software industry. People brag about how difficult something was to accomplish in a technical sense. Are they trying to scare away potential competitors? Brag about their IQ?
Perhaps this all stems from an education system that glorifies difficulty above all else.
Just because something is difficult doesn't make it interesting. Conversely, just because something is easy doesn't make it uninteresting.
I find this all very strange.
- ram1024 17y agodifficult things narrow the spectrum of individuals capable of accomplishing them. when you hear a guitar jam that is merely simple and easy are you impressed? are you interested? no it does not strike us because it is a commonplace accomplishment. it is simply a form of elitism, and i don't mean that as a derogatory term. really if you don't understand why something difficult and challenging is impressive and admirable i suggest you hang out on twitter where you can be entertained all day by banal mediocrity
- quoderat 17y agoMany -- if not most -- human intellectual pursuits are a form of stotting. (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stotting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stotting ) In fact, competing with other minds, not meeting direct challenges in the environment, is probably what led to most of humanity's advanced intellectual development. Sure, it can be couched in the language of the "thrill of discovery" and all that, and some of that is true -- but that doesn't explain its genesis, and doesn't explain what you're talking about, as all too often, the difficult solution is taken over the easy solution merely because it is difficult.
- menloparkbum 17y agoPerhaps this all stems from an education system that glorifies difficulty above all else. Weren't you also the guy who was talking about being ostracized by your teachers and peers because you weren't math olympiad material? From your comments you have had the most atypical educational experience I've ever heard described.
- bmm6o 17y agoCan't it be because they are proud of accomplishing something difficult? The harder the challenge, the greater the pride. Also, you're looking for a specific answer to a very abstract question. You can't ask why something is highly-valued without specifying by whom. Is there a particular instance of this behavior that you are looking to explain? Otherwise it could just be confirmation bias.
- lionhearted 17y agoI don't think it's normal in mainstream education - mainstream education seems to reward obedience and fact-memorization above all else. Critical thinking and creativity tend to be tolerated at best, punished at worst. But difficult for difficult? Maybe it's because challenges can stimulate you to find new ways there. I like playing the highest difficult levels of Civilization IV - itself one of the hardest and most complex games ever made - because it forces you to keep re-examining and questioning your assumptions. Strategies that work on the lower levels get you stomped on upper levels, so you're forced to adjust to a whole new style of play and find solutions you never even thought about. Good for the mind.