5 ms·
So, what's the solution, here? It seems reasonable for a court opinion to include a copy of the source, if possible. What about for something like a YouTube vid
by coldpie 13y ago
So, what's the solution, here? It seems reasonable for a court opinion to include a copy of the source, if possible. What about for something like a YouTube video, which could disappear at any time, but can't be represented on paper? How would you agree on a digital format for representing a supreme court opinion?
- martindale 13y agoBuild awareness of the importance of the permanence of URIs and what they mean to Hypertext. The only full solution is a cultural one, not a technological one.
- dionidium 13y agoWhile I agree that there's a necessary cultural aspect here, it does not seem sufficient in this context. If the highest court in the land is citing a source in a decision, then that source needs to be available, by technological solution, if necessary, regardless of external, cultural forces.
- jerf 13y agoCulture isn't going to encourage people to host websites they're no longer interested in, where by "host websites" read "pay money for". The only solution is some form of legalized archiving. We need the right to copy for archiving without profit, or something. Not sketching out a full, legal solution here, just pointing out that it has to include some form of right-to-archive.
- chimeracoder 13y ago> We need the right to copy for archiving without profit, or something. Just throwing it out there - this is (in some sense) one of the intended purposes of the Library of Congress. The Library of Congress already even announced a few years back that they were planning on archiving every public tweet. Having them archive every video referenced in official documents (such as a Supreme Court decision) isn't that much of a stretch.
- jaggederest 13y agoThat exists. Fair use covers non-profit educational uses, such as the awesome Internet Archive: http://archive.org/ http://archive.org/
- InclinedPlane 13y agoArchive.org, as cool as it is, does not archive the entirety of the internet. Moreover, it's a bit silly to posit that one website that we can surely rely on to exist always! is the solution to the fact that you can never rely on the existence of any particular website in the future.
- jaggederest 13y agoNo, I'm not saying that "the internet archive completely solves this problem", what I'm saying is "there exists no legal barrier to making something like this a reality, since things like the internet archive already exist".
- InclinedPlane 13y agoSure, sure. That's comparable to how to fix communism. All we need to do is change the way human beings work, change fundamental economic incentives, and everything will be golden. It's just not possible. There's only one way to fix these problems, and it's not something most people are ready to accept. It's to turn the internet inside out, from a client-server model to a store-and-forward model. It's to treat web content more like ebooks than like fliers posted to a cork board.
- nitrogen 13y agoSounds like content-centric networking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content-centric_networking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content-centric_networking There are upsides, like decentralization, and downsides, like everybody knowing exactly what data you're asking for if it's strictly addressed by hash (no way of obscuring your political activities from an oppressive regime by using an unrelated name for common data).
- elmuchoprez 13y agoSome sort of verified caching protocol. Like mixing together the Wayback Machine and a notary.
- dublinben 13y agoIsn't the answer to this DHT? A well chosen hash algorithm should give you suitable prevention from collisions and serve as a way to verify the contents of the retrieved file.
- smsm42 13y agoI wonder if archive.org would provide a paid authenticated (notarized) snapshot service, on-demand (i.e. by request and after payment, create a copy and guarantee it's not changed and deleted ever) - maybe they could even make some money out of the thing.
- gwern 13y agoThey pretty much do: http://archive-it.org/ http://archive-it.org/
- rayiner 13y agoThe Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts has recommended, and many (most? all?) of the federal circuits now have an official policy of, saving web page links to PDF and filing them along with opinions. The Supreme Court tends to do its own thing, but I think that's a simple effective solution.
- kriro 13y agoThis is our policy for student papers of all sorts as well. All cited weblinks must be submitted in PDF form as well. Pretty sure that's super standard practice.
- phogster 13y agoI don't understand. Are you citing the links, or the pages they reference? What about videos?
- nonchalance 13y agoYou are citing a source. MLA and other schemes require you to give an access date, and the only way to definitively prove you saw content on a given date is to provide the content you saw. Web servers don't magically give users a way to go back in time. Whether PDF is an appropriate format is a different story.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> the only way to definitively prove you saw content on a given date is to provide the content you saw. Providing a copy of the content that you claim is the source does not come anywhere close to definitively proving that that content is the content at the cited source on the identified date. All it does is provide what you claim to be the original source, which, assuming that you do it honestly, provides the content backing the characterizations for which you cited, and the context for any limited excerpts you quoted. So, its useful, but not as proof that you saw the content in the cited source on that date.
- echohack 13y agoPut the documents on bittorrent and let the world mirror it for you.
- dublinben 13y agoUsing DHT could be a really powerful solution for this.
- sbierwagen 13y agohttp://webcitation.org/ http://webcitation.org/
- gwern 13y agoGiven WebCite's financial woes, it wouldn't be a good idea to put too much emphasis on them.