3 ms·
People had similar ideas when television came out. Televised lectures were an early part of the American public television movement and Open University in the U
by ilamont 17y ago
People had similar ideas when television came out. Televised lectures were an early part of the American public television movement and Open University in the UK. Yet they never managed to make much of a dent in the established way of educating people, mainly because interaction and the process of dialogue does not easily carry over to the electronic realm.
The same can be said for many online education now -- asynchronous communications with professors and classmates using email and discussion boards is hardly a substitute for being able to raise your hand to ask questions or start debates on the fly.
I've seen some interesting experiments in real-time online class sessions using virtual worlds and other tools, but the technology still needs a lot of work to make it easier for educators and students to use.
- evgen 17y agoVery true. Another point that often gets ignored by those who think online education will replace standard lectures and discussions is the fact that a decent lecturer can get a lot of feedback just by watching the non-verbal responses to the progress of the lecture. It is not hard to notice when everyone is bored, when most of the class has that universal puzzled look that lets the prof know that she needs to go back and re-explain the last point, etc. None of this comes through the real-time virtual channel and until this problem is solved the online course will be a pale substitute for the real thing.