4 ms·
Reposting what I posted two weeks ago when this was posted the first time (and promptly ripped to shreds and then deleted) Where this utterly falls apart is th
by TylerE 13y ago
Reposting what I posted two weeks ago when this was posted the first time (and promptly ripped to shreds and then deleted)
Where this utterly falls apart is that it doesn't consider that the major barrier is NOT the price. It's overcoming the friction of getting the user to pay anything, at all. If you can do that, conversion rates are similar at $0.10 and $10.00. That is why micropayments are dumb. They're leaving money on the table.
NB: I work in the industry and this is coming from direct professional experience. I'm not really at liberty to go much more in depth than I did, but I have strong real world data that says micropayments are a disaster, plain and simple.
- triplesec 13y agoThank you! Can you link here to any better economic analyses which are not so osecret but worth reading, to enlighten us some more?
- TylerE 13y agoI don't really have anything formal that i can cite...just my observations from the trenches. I'll just say that we tried (and promoted heavily) a system where you could buy the access to a PDF of one day's content for a quite low price (Less than $1). In roughly a year that the system was up we sold less than $50 worth...TOTAL, but we have thousands of customers on a paid sub at $10+/monthly.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- derekp7 13y agoSo the solution is to have some sort of premium content Internet pass. It costs $10 a month, but can be used to get free content at whatever sites are signed up with it. Kind of like Amazon Prime, but with an arbitrary number of vendors. Then, the $10 per user is split among all the products that the user uses it with. Now here's the kicker -- come up with a marketing deal with various ISPs, where they can include this with their subscriptions. Either as a premium that comes automatically with their higher-speed tiers, or something that can be billed as extra for the lower speed tiers.
- Kylekramer 13y agoSounds like a lot like the old Readability (except with a hard paywall instead of donation model). I liked Readability idea in concept, but it didn't exactly take off.
- jacques_chester 13y agoReadability made three errors, in my opinion: 1. They charged too little. Far too little. 2. In an attempt to be more viral, they took payment for websites that were non-participants, with the theory that this would entice them to sign up to receive payment. What happened is that they ended up with a pile of zombie cash that they could not touch. 3. They routed everything through their servers, meaning that a large fraction of their costs was controlled by third parties. This is connected to 1.
- TylerE 13y agoYea, pretty much, that's where I think it should go. Sort of Spotify for written content. Some very high profile outlets (WSJ, NY Times, New Yorker, the Economist) might be able to make their own things work, but those are the exception, not the rule.
- walid 13y agoI'm sorry but you're wrong with the elitist view you're taking on paid content. The problem is not that high profile publishers succeed while others fail. The real problem is that no new monetizing mechanism is used. Take in-app purchasing as a payment model for news and voila, money rolls in the coffers. To make a point, FarmVille is not high profile. It is for everyone who is anyone. On the other hand EA bought a game called Pet Society which had a loyal following whom I knew some of. The first thing EA did was change the payment model and then all hell broke loose. People I personally know started complaining and EA eventually closed down that game. The problem is not in either elitism or micro-payments but rather in the sales approach.
- joanofarf 13y agoSort of Spotify for written content. Wouldn't this end up leaving even more money on the table? Spotify pays artists based on their share of total plays. Say two sites (X and Y) join up to offer a $10/month pass for unlimited access to both sites, with the say pay scheme as Spotify. Site X has 3 times as many articles/videos as Site Y. If every user reads/watches 100% of Site Y's content, Site X may still receive an equal or larger share of the payouts even though users consumed a much lower percentage of it.
- zanny 13y agoI don't get why writers try to abuse copyright law to artificially constrain the disbursement of their material. I know anything I've written (fantastic internet rants for the most part, but also code) I'd try to get out to as many people as possible. Emailing everyone a copy of my book would not take more than seconds effort, yet publishers treat it as a limiting factor, when distribution just isn't. Instead, I'd attach a donation link, except rather than say "please give me $$ for beer" I'd say "please give me $$ so I can write my next book rather than sweep floors". Charge for the expense, and with the exception of an initial ice breaker to get visibility, you have access to the same potential capital, except more, because it is a variable rate. You could see your big fans throwing thousands at you a piece. Even with a 1% conversion rate, having 1000x the audience because your material is free and open would mean more long term sustainability. I'm not saying don't pay for the dead tree that cost 50c to chop and 30c to print on, that has a marginal cost per unit. But when you are passing around digital material all the time, it is absurd to be trying to bill per unit like its scarce.
- bmm6o 13y ago> I don't get why writers try to abuse copyright law to artificially constrain the disbursement of their material That's not an abuse of copyright law, that's it's exact purpose. > Instead, I'd attach a donation link [...] Just because you can make up numbers where this is successful doesn't mean it would be successful, or give any insight into the situations that are most amenable to it.
- walid 13y agoThe most successful selling model for apps by far is in-app purchases. Whether for games items or for a more powerful app. The strategy is always to get your customers' foot in the door first and then give them the option to get more. On the other hand selling an app for a fixed amount does reduce purchases. This is the problem for conversion rates. Most pay-walls are all or nothing. The New York Times currently allows me to read a page referral but asks me to sign up when I try to navigate elsewhere which is smart but probably not good enough. I understand your stance on low conversion rates for pay-walls but the problem lies in what users perceive as value. In-app purchases work when users want more however news sites try to sell an all or nothing. I think the right approach to increase conversion rates is when publishers learn from FarmVille. That being said, the value of Bitcoin is that it allows anyone to buy/sell without going through legal processes. I for one live in Lebanon and I can't for example sell paid apps (only free apps) in Google Play which means I'm not a publisher. The primary reason for that is financial law and what have you. Bitcoin simply bypasses all that allowing anyone to be a publisher or consumer. For newspapers they even can rely less on advertising and start focusing on what users are willing to pay for instead on what hype gets users to click through. What I'm trying to say is that Bitcoin frees publishers from local regulations while allowing them to be international on day one, but the problem is the sales approach not the selling value. The proof is in the pudding: in-app purchases.
- TylerE 13y agoThe problem is that a Newspaper isn't Candy Crush.... in Candy Crush you can either pay or beg your friends. If it's news an alternative source is just a google away. Frankly the mere fact that you are making that comparison tells me you don't understand the market at all.
- walid 13y agoNot all articles are news in the traditional sense. Editorials, opinion pieces, historical perspectives, analyses of markets, etc. are not a google away. The dilution of the news market is because a lot is poured into hype, that is a google away. High quality content gets people back which is evident in how the New York Times manages to maintain loyal readership and profitability.