3 ms·
> Unlike Erlang's built-in notion of actors, in scala Akka is "just" a library. So what? In Erlang it's part of the language because Joe Armstrong et al. thoug
by pron 13y ago
> Unlike Erlang's built-in notion of actors, in scala Akka is "just" a library.
So what? In Erlang it's part of the language because Joe Armstrong et al. thought that this is how modern software should be written. They figured they'd need immutability, process isolation, and message passing. In Scala you can do that in a library minus (guaranteed) immutability and isolation, which were the whole point to begin with.
Same for Haskell. They've figured that an unbreakable type-system with functional purity will make it easier to write bug free code. So Scala takes the rich type system (that has its own mental cost), but removes the purity and the safety which are the the whole purpose of the exercise (or much of it, at least).
I could go on and on (with macros, implicits and more), but Scala never fails to miss the mark. It adopts a feature without adopting the philosophy that makes the feature powerful.
> Mutability and inheritance are good solutions to certain classes of problems, and it's valuable to have them in your toolbelt.
Sure, but not if I have to pay the price of such a complex type system, that was designed for languages without mutability and inheritance! Each of these features is good in isolation, but combine them, and you get a mess. Scala is a the pizza-ice-cream-soup-steak-salad. Each has its place, but not as part of the same fucking dish! What is wrong with using one coherent language for one problem, and another for a different one? That's what Scala's designers don't seem to get. They simply have no taste. They're gluttons.
I certainly wouldn't mind the generality if only the mental price I had to pay for it wasn't so high. A lack of guidance is not bad in and of itself - C offers no guidance and no guarantees, and is fit for many tasks - but combined with so many haphazard features and mind-boggling complexity, it becomes a liability rather than an asset. You end up paying the price for each of the features, but reaping few of the rewards. I think programmers are the last people this language is for. In fact, I think Scala is mostly made to amuse its compiler writers.
- pnathan 13y ago> What is wrong with using one coherent language for one problem, and another for a different one? Some shops really hate doing work in multiple languages. If designing a language for general industrial use, I'd think long and hard before writing a language that was not at least somewhat sort of decent at everything.
- jfb 13y agoScala reminds me of nothing so much as C++. Yeah, you may not want to use what is to you some obscure corner-case feature, but it's 100% certain that you will encounter some code written by someone with a different view of what is and isn't critical. So you need to keep this enormous pile of abstractions and their interactions in your working set, or you're off to the documentation. I don't entirely see the value in having these "big-tent" languages, where everyone writes their own dialect but imposes that mental cost on all of the other readers. Odersky is clearly a very smart guy, but I'm not persuaded around his way of thinking. Scala is more expressive than Java-the-language (it'd be difficult to be less so), but that's not the only metric one should use [1]. [1] PLEASE DO NOT READ THIS AS AN ENDORSEMENT OF JAVA-THE-LANGUAGE.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe value for big-tent languages like C++ and Scala comes pretty much from the following factors: 1) There is an existing language that has become widely used in a domain (or a variety of domains) with a well-developed ecosystem, and 2) There are well-known limitations of that existing language for the domains in which it has become widely used, and 3) The existing alternative languages that take conceptually pure approaches to addressing the problems with the existing dominant language have problems making use of the ecosystem that has evolved around that dominant language and/or pose a difficult transition for programmers versed in the dominant language, and 4) The "big-tent" language provides an easier transition for people versed in the language than purer alternatives (by way of more directly supporting the idioms of the dominant language) and has better support for leveraging the existing ecosystem that has grown up around the dominant language.
- pron 13y agoAh, but one of the great points of the JVM is that it provides easy interoperability. So much of being versed in a language is knowing its libraries, but on the JVM, many of the libraries are shared among languages. I use a lot of my Java and JDK knowledge when I write Clojure, and I'm using Clojure when it makes sense and Java when it makes sense. There doesn't even need to be a "transition" on the JVM, but a gradual, selective use of languages in certain circumstances. The JVM is the big tent.
- lmm 13y agoIt's not a mess. It's a language in which you can do what you did in Erlang, or what you did in Haskell, or what you did in Java, not because it's taken all their features but because the core language is expressive enough that you can write a library rather than making a separate language. You can shape the language to the problem, not because it's complex but because it's simple. It reminds me of go (the game, not the language) - yes, you can build up these very high level patterns, consisting of dozens of pieces, and sometimes you look at a master's beautiful play and wonder how he ever found it. But the underlying rules are very simple, and it's always possible to take a pattern apart and see why it works. So you get the expressiveness of a language like perl, or yes, C++; you can write in a huge variety of styles. But you don't get the problem where no-one can read anyone else's code, because underneath it all those styles are using the same language primitives. So even if you haven't seen a typeclass before, you can understand scala code that uses them, because it's just passing an implicit parameter of a certain type. Even if you haven't seen an actor before, you can understand code that uses them, because it's just a library of funny-named methods with particular semantics, and using pattern-matching in a particular way. Yes, you could write two actors that access mutable fields in another object. Yes, you could write a method in the I/O monad that also calls println. But you wouldn't do these things by accident. In 3+ years of professional scala development (with several quite inexperienced team members) I've never seen a bug caused by inappropriate mutability or inheritance. Yes, it would be nice if the compiler could draw a distinction between pure functions, those that performed I/O, those that modified state, and those that had other kind of effects. But it doesn't seem to be necessary in practice. Being able to use a single language means being able to use one set of tools, one set of infrastructure (the maintaining of which is often one of the more tedious parts of the job). It means not having to context switch, and not making mistakes because a similar-looking operation means something different in another language. It makes code reuse much easier (yes, even on the JVM - while it's possible to call from one language to another, an API designed for a different language will be cumbersome because it uses different conventions). Ultimately it's just a lot less mental overhead.