4 ms·
Sell out: "To abandon one's supporters or principles to seek profit or other personal advantage." There's a difference between "selling" and "selling out". Sel
by javajosh 13y ago
Sell out: "To abandon one's supporters or principles to seek profit or other personal advantage."
There's a difference between "selling" and "selling out". Selling your company does not mean necessarily mean "selling out". New ownership often means new control, new principles, new directions, often driven by pure money-motive, it isn't always. Berkshire Hathaway is famously hands-off with its acquisitions, for example.
- tokenizer 13y agoSemantically you could make the opposite argument however given the perspective/context. Abandon can mean relinquishing of control. It would depend on your employees/clients, but given a large enough sample size, I'm sure one party might feel cheated when power changes hands. That said, ownership gives you that power. The power to relinquish it. It seems perfectly ethical/moral to me.
- gohrt 13y agoPeople who use the term "selling out" don't believe in the term-sheet definition of ownership. Those people use words like "commmunity", "stakeholder", and "contributor", and attach important meaning to them. The world is not a perfectly efficient free market of isolated transactions.
- comrade_ogilvy 13y agoThat's nice, but the problem is that "selling out" has strong pejorative connotations, while being completely vague. Does Bill Gates have a positive moral duty to all those "stakeholders" employed at MS, until the day he is carted onto his deathbed? Obviously not. What would that duty actually mean in concrete terms? I have no idea. In fact, at some point, trying to hold on and control the company is in the disinterest of stakeholders, as Gates' personal interest and abilities wane. TFA is pretty vague too. I do not sell anything particularly wrong with selling a company at 10% of what you could have gotten several years later. A "measly" 2-3 million dollars in a bank account buys you a lot of freedom. Diminishing marginal returns means that another 10 or 20 or even 30 million buys you less happiness than you might think.
- jerf 13y agoWhile your distinction is a useful one, I think it's not a common one. Just as there seems to be some sort of cultural rush to be the first to declare something has jumped the shark, there's a very strong presumption that selling simply is selling out, a conclusion that can be leaped to without anything so tedious as examining the facts, and some sort of rush to be the first and loudest to so declare.
- mjn 13y agoIt could be that I discuss in odd circles, but the distinction between the two seems pretty commonly raised in my experience. Common to the extent that arguing over which side of the dividing line a particular sale falls is the key question often debated. The "con" side will argue that a given sale is not only a sale in the literal sense, but selling out in the more ethical sense of failing to do right by one's fans/customers/whatever, letting the cash being dangled lure you into doing something you wouldn't normally do. For example, when CDDB "sold out" to Gracenote, which took it proprietary, the problem wasn't just that CDDB sold at all, but that the trustees of a community project sold out their community's trust for a cash payment. The "pro" side will typically argue that a given sale is just changing ownership structure but not fundamentally auctioning off their values/trust/etc.